Influencer Characteristics on Customer Relationship Management

Introduction of the research topic

In the digital marketing age, influencer marketing is a technique that brands use to build connections with their audiences. The power of influencers, people with a predominant number of followers online, is in their ability to form consumer opinion, choice, and consumption. To achieve and maintain stable relationships with customers in the present market where businesses compete, it is necessary to analyze the involvement of influencers in customer relationship management (CRM) (Trivedi and Sama, 2020).

The research questions that will guide this exploration are:

1. What are the key characteristics of influencers that resonate with consumers and contribute to effective customer relationship management?
2. How do influencer characteristics influence consumer trust, brand loyalty, and purchasing decisions?
3. What strategies can businesses employ to leverage influencer characteristics for successful customer acquisition and retention?
4. How can businesses align influencer characteristics with their brand values and target audience preferences to foster long-term customer relationships?

Influencer marketing has created a new niche in the marketing landscape, and it is more synergistic with social media platforms and their reach and persuasive abilities in the lives of their followers. Customers, especially young people, are now skeptical about traditional advertising tactics, and they tend to give more credibility to the reviews or recommendations that they know rather than the ones done by the advertisements. The marketing world has established advocates dubbed influencers who possess relevant affinity and relatability to suffice this aim of strategic partnership between companies and their customers (Weismueller et al., 2020). One of the major attributes of influencers is their capacity to produce user-friendly and trendy content, which influences followers. Story-telling can be simply visual, through breathtaking images, or in-depth, through absorbing videos and writings; for influencers, their craft is to hold the attention of the fans. The content plays the role of a catalyst for building emotional connections with customers, capable of creating a feeling of connectedness among the consumers, which translates to a large following and customers who are likely to be loyal to the brand.

Another feature that is responsible for the effectiveness of influencer marketing is that influencers are viewed as authentic and transparent by targeted audiences. Buyers really appreciate those who are open and transparent in their promotion as well as a mark for disclosing that sponsored content. Whether it is a thorough preview or a paid endorsement, consumers mostly regard their openness in a positive way (Yesiloglu and Costello, 2020). This truthfulness subsequently contributes to building trust and integrity, which are irreplaceable components of productive customer relationship management. In addition to that, influencers have more significant information about the niche of their industry or target audience. They have been able to achieve that followership by frequently providing content that fills the viewers’ needs and wants as well as reinforcing their value systems. This entails the delivery of brand messages by influencers, who in turn communicate them in a manner that seems to be appealing to the audience, thus creating associations of brands that are positive in the audience’s hearts and more effectively engaging them.

Influencers also play a crucial role in creating a sense of community and fostering customer advocacy. By actively engaging with their followers, responding to comments, and encouraging user-generated content, influencers foster a two-way communication channel that strengthens customer relationships. This interaction not only enhances brand awareness but also provides businesses with valuable insights into consumer preferences and feedback, enabling them to tailor their products, services, and marketing strategies accordingly.

Significance of the Research

The importance of this study resides in the fact that it can provide useful findings to businesses that are looking for ways to refine their customer relationship management strategies through influencer marketing. With the modern consumer behavior evolutions and the customers tend to look for more trust towards brands and personalized brand experiences, it is important to research the influencers and their characteristics, which they believe have the most impact on customer engagement and loyalty (Trivedi & Sama, 2020). By analyzing the appeal factors of influencers that catch consumers’ attention, businesses can work with influencers who share their brand values and reach out to their intended audiences. This enables the influencer marketing campaigns to develop trust and credibility while remaining authentic and relevant to the consumers. Finally, this will contribute to enhanced brand awareness, customer acquisition, and retention, which are crucial components of success in business.

Moreover, this study provides an overview of the tactics that organizations can use to utilize the qualities of influencers to increase customer acquisition and retention. The digital area, which is forever changing, makes it necessary for companies/businesses to be flexible in terms of adaptation of their marketing strategies in order to be competitive and meaningful. Knowing the actions of character influencers convince client’s trust, brand loyalty, and buying choices, businesses develop a purpose that involves influencing strategies that effectively build and harness customer relationships. Furthermore, the research results provide helpful knowledge on how businesses match influencer characteristics with their brand values and target audience preferences. This alignment is very essential for long-term relations built on trust, honesty, and shared values of which they are both partners. Through the comprehension of influencer composition and its effects on customer perceptions, brands can make informed selections when choosing and partnering with influencers to integrate brand communications and influencer content effortlessly (Taylor, 2020). Not only that, the findings may broaden insight into the subject of consumer behavior and the expanding role that influencers are taking in the contemporary marketing sphere. While influencer marketing gains more ground, it is necessary to evaluate its implications on customer relationship management from a scientific and data point of projection. The research can add to the knowledge basis of existing literature and serve as a guide for future studies in this rapidly increasing field of study.

Methodology

An extensive and rigorous research method will be used to explore how influencer characteristics affect customer relationship management; therefore, a multi-faceted methodological approach will be adopted. These will involve the use of a combination of mind mapping, research logs, and a range of both qualitative and quantitative research methods. To begin, mind mapping will be applied as a visual method to collect and put together the different concepts, ideas, and themes related to the research topic (Saima & Khan, 2020). The use of this approach will, therefore, play a vital role in designing and developing appropriate strategies for identifying the essential traits of influencers, their possible effects on the relationships between companies and customers, and how businesses can use the traits to their benefit. Using the mind map will be the very start of formulating a research plan and determining the points that need to be investigated more closely.

Furthermore, a research log will also be compiled so the entire research process can be recorded in detail. This blog will document and be kept as a multisource report of the materials referred to, using journals, industry reports, case studies, and accessible online resources. Also, it will encounter insights, observations, and notes that come up during research, and so the researcher will have the chance to lay out any patterns, gaps, and possibly more areas that require rethinking (Shamim & Islam, 2022). The investigation under the question will be carried out using a mixed methods approach, so both qualitative and quantitative techniques will be involved. The qualitative part will be implemented using in-depth interviews with marketing professionals, influencers, and other industry experts. Within these interviews, it will be critical to get the experience as to how power influencers to commercial businesses are perceived; the strategies applied to that effect, and the outcome concerning consumer relationships with the business. On top of that, the study will undergo a comparative analysis of the case studies of successful influencer marketing campaigns so as to identify the common elements and philosophies that individuals or teams mostly rely on.

Moreover, a comprehensive literature review will be undertaken to explore the existing academic research, theories, and frameworks related to influencer marketing, consumer behavior, and customer relationship management. This evaluation will develop the theoretical perspective necessary for the project and contribute to the creation of a paradigm that combines the key behavioral traits of influencers and how they affect customer relationships. In order to achieve this goal, the qualitative data examination will be supplemented with the quantitative methods used in distributing surveys to be filled by a representative group of consumers (Shokouhyar et al., 2020). These studies will look for consumer views of the personality factor of the influencer, the reliability, how the collaboration between the influencer and the brand, and the favorite forms of influencer-brand collaborations influence loyalty. A statistical analysis of the survey data will be carried out to identify implications for the existing models or relationships, revealing greater insight into the research questions.

Also, data mining and analysis of social media platforms will be done to recognize consumer behavior, engagement levels, and sentiment toward endorsed brands and influencers. This result will provide good background information and will also indicate the most important influencers and advocacy efforts that need to be studied in depth. Ethical issues will be taken very seriously, and these will include participant privacy, informed consent, and conformance to relevant research regulations and protocols (Taillon et al., 2020). The research will be based on a multi-methodological approach that includes brainstorming, research logs, and qualitative and quantitative methods (e.g., interviews, case studies, literature review, surveys, surveys, data mining, and statistical analysis) to ensure that its conclusions are sufficiently comprehensive and credible. The usage of different data sources and methods aims to increase the accuracy and dependability of the results. Besides, the collection of coherent and actionable knowledge is what businesses can do to have effective influencer marketing campaigns.

Literature Review

Authenticity and Transparency

The authenticity and openness of influencers, which are the most valuable characteristics for consumers, play a crucial role. Consumers, especially the young ones, resonate a lot when it comes to seriousness, honesty, and transparency during campaigns (Pick, 2021). It is the influencers who are perceived as authentic, relatable, and transparent, and they are generally perceived positively by viewers. Sophisticated users tend to be more skeptical toward major marketing messages, including endorsements, as trust has become their main concern (Pina & Dias, 2021). In a research work by Movaghar and Kazemi Saraskanrood (2023), they argued that the influencers who disclose the sponsored content and maintain a balance between their commercial and non-commercial activities are regarded as more truthful and authentic by the followers. It is thus very important that sponsored posts are transparently mentioned and honest. This builds trust with customers, which is a vital factor in effective customer relationship management (Movaghar & Kazemi Saraskanrood, 2023).

As Mirowska and Arsenyan (2023) advocate for the emphasis on authenticity in influencer marketing, consumers are now inclined to follow and trust influencers who exude naturalness and organicity rather than those who appear to be solely motivated by commercial interests (Mirowska and Arsenyan, 2023). This authenticity stems from a sense of relationship and relatability between influencers and followers. Therefore, the product has become the best associate in brands and has more long-lasting customers.

Content Creation and Storytelling

Besides the fact that influencing marketers are able to create and curate interesting content that their target group can relate to, it is also their power to effectively persuade the target group, which results in their success. These days, influencers develop excellent storytelling skills in which they draw more followers from their visually appealing images, captivating videos, or thought-provoking written content (Masuda et al., 2022). Migdadi (2020) investigated the role of influencer content quality and its effects on consumer engagement. They found that consumers’ attitudes toward the brand and purchase decisions were positively enhanced with high-value and in-context content (Migdadi, 2020). The trust that influencers are able to build among their followers who have the same interests, values, and lifestyles is what makes them become reliable content sources. This way, influencers reinforce customer loyalty. This influence may ultimately result in the increased awareness of a brand by its followers (Martínez-López et al., 2020).

Furthermore, Kim and Kim (2021) researched to keenly examine the role of storytelling in influencer marketing, and this report showed that the influencers who tell people stories, like narration, evoking emotions, and incorporating personal experiences, usually make up their audience and create a sense of community. Here lies the key part of brand-building, where customers get inclined to be brand advocates and have lifelong relationships with the brand (Koay et al., 2021).

Niche Expertise and Target Audience Alignment

Blogging or vlogging influencers typically have a reputable track record in their niche field of expertise, which builds up their social credibility. As a result, they gain a sizeable following as they consistently produce content that resonates with their followers’ interests, values, and lifestyles (Kurdi et al., 2022). Thus, there is communication of the brand messages effectively that is not only believable but also in line with the audience’s expectations, a factor that enhances the positive brand associations and the level of customer engagement with the brand (Lee and Kim, 2020).

Leung et al. (2022) investigated the influencer-product congruence effect on the consumer response in their academic article, and their research found that such endorsements gain credibility and become trustworthy when an influencer promotes a brand or a certain product that matches his or her specific professional niche expertise and personal brand (Leung et al., 2022). Overlap between an influencer’s personality/skills and the brand’s common consumer base is really significant in the general customer management process. Moreover, Li et al. (2023) also examined the function of influencers in the fashion industry to discover that influencers who are knowledgeable in fashion trends and styles and are also in sync with the respective target audience’s preferences are more likely to influence the purchase decisions of consumers and show a feeling of loyalty more brands (Lou, 2022).

Community Building and Engagement

Influencers contribute significantly towards a sense of community and building advocacy of customers through an active and ongoing engagement with their followers (Kim and Kim, 2021). Influencers can do this by, for instance, answering the comments, empowering user-generated content as well as providing a two-way way channel for communication, which enables them to build strong customer relationships for their businesses and also help in providing valuable insights into consumer preferences and feedback (Khan et al., 2022).

Kapitan et al. (2022) investigated the contribution of influencers to a brand’s community building. They identified that influencers who interrupt the followers, discuss personal stories, and build up a community feeling foster loyal and devoted brand communities (Kapitan et al., 2022). These communities not only strengthen brand awareness but also ensure that the customers remain loyal and serve as an undeniable source of customer feedback and advocacy. Moreover, Jung and Im (2021) studied the effects of the involvement of followers and influencer interaction on the trust of consumers. They discovered that influencers who make an effort to listen and reply to their followers’ comments and questions are seen as trustworthy and reliable (Jung and Im, 2021). This trustworthiness and confidence are an underlying foundation for the birth of positive customer relations and, lastly, in the formation of brand loyalty (Jun and Yi, 2020).

Influencer Credibility and Trust

The trust of consumers in influencers has proven to be a very crucial factor that determines how influential marketing campaigns, carried out through influencers, will be successful in enhancing customer relationship management (Hugh Wilkie et al., 2022). The credibility and trustworthiness of influencers play a decisive role in influencing consumer attitudes, purchase patterns, and brand loyalty (Gil-Gomez et al., 2020).

The study by Deng et al. (2023) focused on influencer credibility factors, which revealed that influencers who show respect, trust, and knowledge while in their content are trusted more among consumers (Deng et al., 2023). Such credibility hence empowers marketers to be more persuasive, and healthy customer relationships are built on it (Farivar et al., 2021). Moreover, Chopra et al. (2021) considered the question of the effect that trustworthy influencers have on consumer opinion, and the output was that people follow and trust influencers who are trustworthy and who have established a pattern of delivery on their promises, transparency, and ethical branding. Hence, this trust will be a solid basis for the relational bonding of a customer in many ways and the stability of the brand (Chopra et al., 2021).

Alignment with Brand Values and Messaging

Businesses must incorporate influencers’ characteristics with their brand values and intended audience preferences to nurture long-term customer relations. Micro-influencers who have the same values, norms, and themes passed through by the brand they endorse are more likely to be correlated to the consumers and lead to the production of a positive brand association (Campbell and Farrell, 2020).

Bu et al. (2022) focused on the extent of consistency between influencers and brands in the sustainable fashion sphere under the auspices that when an influencer represents a brand that possesses similar values in terms of sustainability and ethical proceedings, consumers perceive that endorsement as authentic and trustworthy (Berne-Manero and Marzo-Navarro, 2020). Consequently, this compatibility of the influencer attributes with a company’s value system increases the possibility of consumer involvement and makes customers more loyal. A parallel study, the inducibility of brand-consumer relations to perception byBarta et al. (2023), indicated that an influencer gets a chance to be heard by and is trusted by people only in case a correlation between the brand and its personal portfolio is evidenced. By doing so, the brand meets its ideal of providing content that is relevant and congruent with the influencer that is naturally loved by consumers (Blanche et al., 2021).

Influencer Marketing Strategies and Best Practices

With businesses taking on influencer features for effective customer relationship management, it is critical to be well-informed about the key practices and strategies needed in influencer campaigns (Saima and Khan, 2020). Along these lines, the research paper by Shamim and Islam (2022) elaborated on some winning strategies of influencer marketing, and it underscored the need to select and work with influencers who are compatible in terms of the audience, values, and messaging of the brand (Shamim and Islam, 2022). They stress the fact that genuine collaborations, long-term partnerships, and co-creation of thoughtful content will be more meaningful to the consumers and establish in-house trust and credibility. In addition, Srivastava (2021) investigated the effect of the various types of influencer marketing strategies, from product seeding and sponsored content and the brand ambassadorship perspective, on customer response. During their research, they discovered that long-term, genuine collaboration with influencers as brands’ ambassadors was more successful in creating relationships with customers and fostering brand loyalty than short-term sponsored campaigns (Shokouhyar et al., 2020). Taylor (2020) further illustrates the fact that the choice of influencers matters, the involvement of the public is crucial, oral disclosure is required, and involvement of the campaign with broader initiatives is crucial (Taylor, 2020). This holistic approach avoids disparities between marketing channels and allows the creation of a continuous branding experience that is favorable to building good customer relations (Taillon et al., 2020).

Measurement and Evaluation

Effective use of influencer characteristics and optimized customer relationship management are needed to measure and evaluate the impact of influencer marketing campaigns. Different metrics and analyses have been discussed in the literature to evaluate the efficiency of influencer marketing campaigns and the way they influence customer relationships (Trivedi and Sama, 2020). Weinlich and Semerádová (2022) have looked into the employment of social media analytics and engagement metrics to control influencer marketing promotion. They discovered that such factors as the likes, remarks, shares, and followers’ numbers could be very useful for business, causing engagement to rise and, eventually, customers’ interest to grow (Vrontis et al., 2021).

On the other hand, Yesiloglu and Costello (2020) studied the use of sentiment analysis and natural language processing techniques in capturing consumer sentiment toward influencers and the brands they advocate (Yesiloglu & Costello, 2020). Such an analytical approach can offer businesses a deeper understanding of customer perceptions as well as the probability of a negative outcome on customer relations. In addition to that, Ye et al. (2021) stated the necessity of performance metrics like the rate of customer acquisition, customer retention, as well as lifetime value in measuring the effect of the influencer marketing campaigns in the long run customer relationships (Ye et al., 2021). They state that the integration of both customer data and influencer marketing data onto the same platform will allow businesses to get all the information they need about the influencer’s impact on customer behavior and brand loyalty (Weismueller et al., 2020).

Strengths and weaknesses of the arguments

Strengths of the Arguments

Authenticity and Transparency

The literature highlights the paramount role of authenticity and transparency, which form key pillars of the influencer marketing strategy that consumers intimately understand. The evidence from the studies shows that consumers put great emphasis on the level of trustworthiness, authenticity, and transparency that they can find in the endorsements of their favorite influencers as well as in their social media posts. This is a source of boosting consumer confidence and trust all the same, which contributes to better customer relationship management (Trivedi and Sama, 2020).

In addition to the above observation, consumers today are remarkably discriminating. Their customers are buyers who constantly seek narratives by which they can trust the brand. Influencers who show a natural smile when promoting certain brands or things consequently cause people to be even more honest and trustworthy. Ultimately, this kind of engagement allows for a more powerful connection between the influencer and their followers (Srivastava, 2021). The research demonstrated that consumers were more prone to engage in the communication stream with influencers who were upfront about sponsored posts, product affiliations, and their true feelings. Transparency builds brand loyalty since consumers feel they are treated with respect and honesty and are guaranteed a long-term relationship between the brands and the influencer as well as the consumer.

Content Creation and Storytelling

The evidence that shows the role that content creation by influencers and storytelling impacts in these areas is supported in numerous studies. They, in conjunction, provide empirical proof and explore the underlying power of in-depth content, individuality, and entertainment in this kind of digital marketing. The skill of storytelling has been mastered by influencers in the shape in which digital media has assumed today. They are able to tell in an engaging mode, but the content in their stories fits well with the fans, likes, and causes they stand for (Shamim and Islam, 2022). This is so because immersive experiences, which are created with the help of content that attracts the consumer, go beyond just mere product placement. Be it through their narration of life events, sharing experiences, or even failures, influencers tap into an emotional knot with their fans.

Also, the research suggests a view that people are more likely to remember and react favorably toward the brands that are an integral part of a foundational story. This content created by influencers will advertise the brand to consumers who are just like them and have the experiences that they have drawn inspiration from and the ambitions they hope to achieve. Not only does this increase awareness about the brand, but it also inspires the consumers to buy the products (Pina and Dias, 2021). They become more than mere endorsers; they are rather storytellers who continually narrate not only the products but also the influence they have on consumers’ buying the products.

Niche Expertise and Target Audience Alignment

The literature is very clear about influencers that actually have deep knowledge of the niche and, at the same time, assess what the target consumer group will find interesting based on their enthusiasm and preferences. Extensive research reveals that when influencers promote a product or a brand that has a deep connection with their specialized field or personal brand persona, the endorsements of the brand will be considered significantly more credible and trustworthy by the consumers. That is why it increases the brand’s loyalty as well as its visibility because of good customer engagement. To give an idea, Movaghar and Kazemi Saraskanrood (2023) explore the fine parts of influencer marketing. It shows how the influencers’ real attachment to their niche area can speed up the followers’ opinion of them as well as the reaction of the brands they back up, thus raising the level of the campaign’s effect (Movaghar & Kazemi Saraskanrood, 2023). Further, Migdadi (2020) digs into the psychology that affects consumer trust and discovers that if an influencer shares the values of their audience, the possibility that their suggestion will be accepted and executed becomes much higher.

Moreover, Lou (2022) examines influencer authenticity in depth, indicating that the influencers who stay true to their narratives and niche and have a consistent narrative are seen as credible and trustworthy by their followers. It implies the concept of compatibility between influencer and brand, a principle that stands central in the present marketing literature. In fact, these studies cumulatively highlight the paramount position of niche expertise and alignment in influencer marketing strategies, which act as the premises for the establishment of timeless consumer-brand relationships (Lou, 2022).

Community Building and Engagement

The benefits to customer communities of incorporating influencers as central to community development and nurturing customer advocacy through participatory engagement are, therefore, well demonstrated by a variety of studies. Research has shown that the transformative power of influencer marketing stems from the fact that these influencers creatively stimulate the interaction between their followers, share their own personal experiences and amplify the user-generated content of which they publish when they make it public. Leung et al. (2022) focus on the roles of influencers within the relationship bond of the brands and the audience, pointing towards the influencers’ function as connectors or vehicles that ensure exposing the target audience to the brand (Leung et al., 2022). Besides, this is another way to improve brand awareness and interact with customers who give their feedback and promote products and services to other potential customers. Moreover, Li et al. (2023) focus on the psychology of engagement that touches upon how influencers produce shareable and original content inside. In return, they create belongingness among their followers. Such influencers create a place for interaction and dialogue where bonding societies that are based on commonality of interests and values are created (Li et al., 2023). This social spirit manifests itself in the form of customer loyalty, according to the study byHugh Wilkie et al. (2022). It is, indeed, also a great shaper of effective word-of-mouth marketing and consumer brand promotion.

Weaknesses of the Arguments

Limited Generalizability

The existing body of literature plays an important role in providing insights into influencer characteristics and their impacts on customer relationship management, but it is relevant to recognize that these findings may be limited to generalization. A lot of these proven studies may be specifically tailored to limited contexts or populations that may hinder the application of their results on a large scale. To illustrate, an investigation that, for example, narrowly touches on a particular industry or a single group isn’t necessarily relevant to other contexts or the variety of content (Farivar et al., 2021). The limitation in generalizability is that it could be used to contest the conclusions made from such studies, and it is therefore critical to serve with caution when transferring them to different contexts.

Potential Bias

Along with that, this issue deals with the bias aspect, which is common in research devoted to the evaluation of influencer marketing. Different kinds of biases, such as self-selective bias or social desirability bias, should be taken into account by scientists when researching because these biases can greatly affect validity and reliability. Biases of self-selection typically arise in situations where individuals in surveys and studies select themselves to participate, potentially leading to results with biases, as volunteering may have different characteristics from those who don’t. Additionally, the social desirability bias can play a role in reaction to responses that line up with the sociocultural norms or popular beliefs previously formed in an individual’s mind (Chopra et al., 2021). Evaluating and discerning these potential biases are crucial as they may help or hinder the illustration of customer experience improvement, and hence, investigation of research methodologies to prevent such distortions will be required.

Rapidly Evolving Landscape

The influencer marketing industry is a fast-changing field, with much of the dynamicity being driven by new platforms, trends, and consumers’ evolving behaviors. Nevertheless, the literature available may not overcome these changes as they occur too fast to enable all their findings to remain relevant or sufficient all the time (Barta et al., 2023). Consequently, the field grows, and this results in the dominance of new platforms, identification of trends that come and go, as well as the evolution of consumer tastes, so that some of these cannot be fully captured or accounted for in the existing literature. Therefore, the applicability of some results in the long term may be limited and require continuous reevaluation of strategies and insights to maintain influence in an influencer marketing environment that is constantly changing.

Lack of Longitudinal Studies

Though this research does report important things about how the qualities of the influencer have an impact on customer relationship management, there is still a large shortage of longitudinal studies in the area. Much research has been conducted on the short-term and present effects, but relatively little has been done to establish the long-term influence that the techniques of influencer marketing have on customers’ relationships. Longitudinal studies are the best way of knowing how influencer-customer dynamics shape up in time, therefore putting on the spot the transient effects, the evolving perceptions, and the possible lateral shifts in customer behavior (Belanche et al., 2021). This lack of horizontal dimensions makes it difficult for us to develop a conceptual framework to fully grasp the long-term consequences of influencer marketing efforts to attract and retain customers. Conclusively, there is a major deficit in terms of comprehensive longitudinal investigations intended to unravel the potent and long-lasting effects of influencer marketing on customer management strategies.

Limitations and Critique of the Arguments

Limited Generalizability

The literature, including studies of influencer characteristics and their influence on customer relationships, also provides us with important key lessons as the field of influencer marketing continues to evolve. On the contrary, a set of these studies represents their narrow frameworks or gets restricted to particular groups of people, which decreases the chances for the studies to be adopted by a larger audience. When research is specifically designed for a particular industry or a particular demographic group, it may not be readily applicable to other settings or a wide range of societies. The lack of applicability in the context of the phenomenon creates an obstacle in using the results from such studies as a basis for drawing conclusions of a universal nature (Deng et al., 2023). Thus, it is vital to take care not to jump to conclusions when trying to apply these findings to every situation. In addition to that, the not-applicability of it includes marketing all strategies as well. Take, for instance, how that which seems to work powerfully for technology and health industry influencers might not necessarily deliver the same output as they do for those in the fashion industry. For this reason, marketing through influencers should follow the granular requirements of every niche industry, and due to its functioning in different contexts, it should be understood from a nuanced perspective.

Potential Bias

In the context of research in influencer marketing, a few biases can considerably affect the reliability and validity of the study results. Another big problem is self-selection bias because people who really want to fill in questionnaires or take part in a study may have a special character from those who don’t want to participate, which can lead to the results being erroneous. On the other hand, the positively minded influencer-followers might be more involved, and this could lead to an overestimation of the impact of influencers.

On the other hand, social desirability can be another hurdle. This bias develops as respondents react to the labels of society with their answers so that their answers do not actually reflect their opinions and behavior. For instance, participants may find themselves forced to give a favorable response to questions about purchasing decisions influenced by an influencer, which may differ in real life from what they have actually done (Jun and Yi, 2020). Besides this naturally happening bias, the bias may extend to the selection and portrayal of influencers themselves. Marketers or researchers might inadvertently allocate a greater amount of resources towards influencers from certain age groups, races, or other milieus, which can restrain the level of variety of life experiences and interests assessed.

Rapidly Evolving Landscape

The influencer marketing arena is, indeed, a dynamic ecosystem with the continuous appearance of new platforms, old trends as human beings, and consumer behavior, just to mention a few. The fast-paced, dynamic nature of literature clashes with the static character of the existing literary works that eventually lags to pace up with the quick developments. Thus, the executive result of new technologies that come to market continuously can be outdated or partial information from existing endeavors. With time and experience, it becomes obvious that certain generalizations depend on the period and, therefore, need to update the way of thinking as well as the choice of tactics (Khan et al., 2022). Such an endeavor requires not only carefully watching the new apps like Clubhouse or Fleets but also a profound knowledge of how the consumers’ interests and attitudes vary within different periods of time. Being able to keep up with or adapt to this vast set of circumstances that are always transforming compels a consistent involvement in the news, pivotability, as well as being prepared to try others’ means of doing it.

Lack of Longitudinal Studies

Given that they generate very useful data, it is still a fact that there is a limited amount of longitudinal research within the field. Most of the research has highlighted the short-term or immediate effects, with a limited number concentrating on the long-term consequences that an influencer marketing strategy has on a consumer (Kurdi et al., 2022). Given the fact, longitudinal studies are of the utmost importance in unfolding how influencer-customer dynamics take place over time by focusing on the long-term effects together with the gradually changing attitudes and possible shifts in consumers’ behaviors. The lack of those longitudinal viewpoints hinders us from having a holistic understanding of the persistent effects of some influencer marketing initiatives on establishing and conducting relations with customers.

Conclusion and Recommendations

Studies done on the effect of influencer traits on customer relation management have resulted in significant findings and have shown that influencers have a significant influence on customers’ opinions, choices, and purchases. Some important features have become a must for the customers and, in turn, are the main components of effective customer relationship management. The authenticity and transparency that have been identified as the key hook for consumers have increasingly become valued by consumers, who now value the honesty and genuineness of brand communications and media. The influencers who serve as real versus fake in the follow-up paces themselves disclose sponsored content and exhibit authentic behavior, thereby developing trust and building powerful connections with the customers. Furthermore, influencers present the skill of making and selecting appealing content that forms a bond with their audience, which is the biggest advantage of influential influencers. Influencers utilize visual images, enticing videos, and emotionally powerful narratives to engage their fans on a deeper level and create awareness and loyalty among customers.

Furthermore, the issue is that the influencers who have more than just a working knowledge of their niche, pay close heed to brand messages, and put their audience’s interests, values, and lifestyles into consideration have them at a pole advantage with brand perception and a capability to achieve more. This alignment contributes to increased customer engagement and the likelihood of influencing purchasing decisions. Another role of influencers lies in community building and customer advocacy through their active interaction with their followers. With the help of user-generated content, responding to comments, and building two-way communication channels, influencers build relationships with customers and give companies advice on consumers’ preferences and feedback. The research also pointed out that an influencer’s credibility and trustworthiness heavily affect the attitude, purchase intention, and loyalty of consumers to the brand. Influencers who often keep their word, provide full transparency and demonstrate high moral attributes are highly likely to retain the trust of their followers, leading to some positive customer relationships.

Recommendations

First and foremost, authenticity and transparency should be at the heart of it all. Working with influencers who are always real and open will inevitably help to create a trustful reputation among customers. Encouraging influencers to promote the adverts and maintaining a good mix of commercial and non-commercial properly reflects their authenticity in the eyes of their audience. Apart from a strong workplace culture, compelling content writing and the art of storytelling are also necessities. It is indeed imperative to invest in seasoned influencers who know how to create and write impactful visuals and content that is both worthy and entertaining so the target audience can always relate to it. The ability to use story-telling techniques such as personal anecdotes, taking others on a journey, or tapping into emotions will promote a stronger link between the audience and the product.

Additionally, in-depth market expertise and audience interest survey comprehension are vital. Analyzing the influencers whose specializations closely match with the audience and who can perceive the message and emotions of the brand correctly increases the effectiveness of brand messaging. This alignment makes the client appreciative of the way the brand is involved and positively associated with their lives, which results in greater customer engagement. Engaging with viewers and creating a community in influencer collaborations go hand in hand with a successful campaign. Companies must choose influencers who are really active in communicating with their followers, promote user-generated content, and put up channels that will serve as a means for direct two-way communications. This strategy not only tightens customer relations but also inputs some market research results into consumer preferences, increasing customer advocacy.

The credibility and reliability of the influencers are of extreme importance. Not everyone can be trusted to guarantee the quality of products or deliver on promises, which is why businesses must always carefully vet the influencers to ensure they are consistent in their promises, transparent, and ethical. One of the most powerful ways influencers can participate in the marketing ecosystem is by building trusting relationships, encouraging brand image, and ultimately increasing consumer loyalty. It is necessary to think about what characteristics are in common with the influencer and the brand since an unmatching partnership may cause confusion and lead to poor message integration. Making sure that the influencer is connected to the brand’s values and that they talk to the target audience in a way that is a good fit creates good relationships and long-term brand loyalty with customers.

Emphasizing long-term and genuine partnerships rather than only temporary campaigns is also a suggested idea. Establishing more lasting partnerships with influencers and co-creating content with authenticity has a stronger effect than simply displaying the brand on an influencer’s social media platforms to strengthen the trust and credibility of the consumer towards the brand. Thus, these lead to stronger customer relationships. Eventually, the establishment of comprehensive performance and program assessment processes is the key to fine-tuning strategies. Through various metrics and analytical tools used for evaluating influencer marketing campaigns in relation to the development of customer relationships, a holistic picture is portrayed. Data integration between influencer marketing and customer data will enable businesses to develop effective strategies that will guarantee growth in the long term.

References

Barta, S., Belanche, D., Fernández, A. and Flavián, M., 2023. Influencer marketing on TikTok: The effectiveness of humor and followers’ hedonic experience. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 70, p.103149.

Belanche, D., Casaló, L.V., Flavián, M. and Ibáñez-Sánchez, S., 2021. Understanding influencer marketing: The role of congruence between influencers, products and consumers. Journal of Business Research, 132, pp.186-195.

Berne-Manero, C. and Marzo-Navarro, M., 2020. Exploring how influencer and relationship marketing serve corporate sustainability. Sustainability, 12(11), p.4392.

Bu, Y., Parkinson, J. and Thaichon, P., 2022. Influencer marketing: Homophily, customer value co-creation behaviour and purchase intention. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 66, p.102904.

Campbell, C. and Farrell, J.R., 2020. More than meets the eye: The functional components underlying influencer marketing. Business horizons, 63(4), pp.469-479.

Chopra, A., Avhad, V. and Jaju, A.S., 2021. Influencer marketing: An exploratory study to identify antecedents of consumer behavior of millennial. Business Perspectives and Research, 9(1), pp.77-91.

Deng, F., Lin, Y. and Jiang, X., 2023. Influence mechanism of consumers’ characteristics on impulsive purchase in E-commerce livestream marketing. Computers in Human Behavior, 148, p.107894.

Farivar, S., Wang, F. and Yuan, Y., 2021. Opinion leadership vs. para-social relationship: Key factors in influencer marketing. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 59, p.102371.

Gil-Gomez, H., Guerola-Navarro, V., Oltra-Badenes, R. and Lozano-Quilis, J.A., 2020. Customer relationship management: digital transformation and sustainable business model innovation. Economic research-Ekonomska istraživanja, 33(1), pp.2733-2750.

Hugh Wilkie, D.C., Dolan, R., Harrigan, P. and Gray, H., 2022. Influencer marketing effectiveness: the mechanisms that matter. European Journal of Marketing, 56(12), pp.3485-3515.

Jun, S. and Yi, J., 2020. What makes followers loyal? The role of influencer interactivity in building influencer brand equity. Journal of Product & Brand Management, 29(6), pp.803-814.

Jung, N. and Im, S., 2021. The mechanism of social media marketing: influencer characteristics, consumer empathy, immersion, and sponsorship disclosure. International Journal of Advertising, 40(8), pp.1265-1293.

Kapitan, S., van Esch, P., Soma, V. and Kietzmann, J., 2022. Influencer marketing and authenticity in content creation. Australasian Marketing Journal, 30(4), pp.342-351.

Khan, R.U., Salamzadeh, Y., Iqbal, Q. and Yang, S., 2022. The impact of customer relationship management and company reputation on customer loyalty: The mediating role of customer satisfaction. Journal of Relationship Marketing, 21(1), pp.1-26.

Kim, D.Y. and Kim, H.Y., 2021. Trust me, trust me not: A nuanced view of influencer marketing on social media. Journal of Business Research, 134, pp.223-232.

Koay, K.Y., Teoh, C.W. and Soh, P.C., 2021. Instagram influencer marketing: Perceived social media marketing activities and online impulse buying. First Monday, 26(9).

Kurdi, B.A., Alshurideh, M., Akour, I., Tariq, E., AlHamad, A. and Alzoubi, H., 2022. The effect of social media influencers’ characteristics on consumer intention and attitude toward Keto products purchase intention. International Journal of Data and Network Science, 6(4), pp.1135-1146.

Lee, S. and Kim, E., 2020. Influencer marketing on Instagram: How sponsorship disclosure, influencer credibility, and brand credibility impact the effectiveness of Instagram promotional post. Journal of global fashion marketing, 11(3), pp.232-249.

Leung, F.F., Gu, F.F. and Palmatier, R.W., 2022. Online influencer marketing. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 50(2), pp.226-251.

Li, B., Chen, S., & Zhou, Q. (2023). Empathy with influencers? The impact of the sensory advertising experience on user behavioral responses. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 72, 103286.

Lou, C., 2022. Social media influencers and followers: Theorization of a trans-parasocial relation and explication of its implications for influencer advertising. Journal of Advertising, 51(1), pp.4-21.

Martínez-López, F.J., Anaya-Sánchez, R., Fernández Giordano, M. and Lopez-Lopez, D., 2020. Behind influencer marketing: key marketing decisions and their effects on followers’ responses. Journal of Marketing Management, 36(7-8), pp.579-607.

Masuda, H., Han, S.H. and Lee, J., 2022. Impacts of influencer attributes on purchase intentions in social media influencer marketing: Mediating roles of characterizations. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 174, p.121246.

Migdadi, M.M., 2020. Knowledge management, customer relationship management and innovation capabilities. Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing, 36(1), pp.111-124.

Mirowska, A. and Arsenyan, J., 2023. Sweet escape: The role of empathy in social media engagement with human versus virtual influencers. International Journal of Human-Computer Studies, 174, p.103008.

Movaghar, M. and Kazemi Saraskanrood, Z., 2023. Identifying the Determining Components of Value of Influencer Marketing for Businesses with Content Analysis. New Media Studies, 9(33), pp.390-363.

Pick, M., 2021. Psychological ownership in social media influencer marketing. European Business Review, 33(1).

Pina, R. and Dias, Á., 2021. The influence of brand experiences on consumer-based brand equity. Journal of brand Management, 28(2), pp.99-115.

Saima and Khan, M.A., 2020. Effect of social media influencer marketing on consumers’ purchase intention and the mediating role of credibility. Journal of Promotion Management, 27(4), pp.503-523.

Shamim, K. and Islam, T., 2022. Digital influencer marketing: How message credibility and media credibility affect trust and impulsive buying. Journal of Global Scholars of Marketing Science, 32(4), pp.601-626.

Shokouhyar, S., Shokoohyar, S. and Safari, S., 2020. Research on the influence of after-sales service quality factors on customer satisfaction. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 56, p.102139.

Srivastava, M., 2021. Mapping the influence of influencer marketing: a bibliometric analysis. Marketing Intelligence & Planning, 39(7), pp.979-1003.

Taillon, B. J., Mueller, S. M., Kowalczyk, C. M., & Jones, D. N. (2020). Understanding the relationships between social media influencers and their followers: the moderating role of closeness. Journal of Product & Brand Management, 29(6), 767-782.

Taylor, C.R., 2020. The urgent need for more research on influencer marketing. International Journal of Advertising, 39(7), pp.889-891.

Trivedi, J. and Sama, R., 2020. The effect of influencer marketing on consumers’ brand admiration and online purchase intentions: An emerging market perspective. Journal of Internet Commerce, 19(1), pp.103-124.

Vrontis, D., Makrides, A., Christofi, M. and Thrassou, A., 2021. Social media influencer marketing: A systematic review, integrative framework and future research agenda. International Journal of Consumer Studies, 45(4), pp.617-644.

Weinlich, P. and Semerádová, T., 2022. Emotional, cognitive and conative response to influencer marketing. New Techno Humanities, 2(1), pp.59-69.

Weismueller, J., Harrigan, P., Wang, S. and Soutar, G.N., 2020. Influencer endorsements: How advertising disclosure and source credibility affect consumer purchase intention on social media. Australasian marketing journal, 28(4), pp.160-170.

Ye, G., Hudders, L., De Jans, S. and De Veirman, M., 2021. The value of influencer marketing for business: A bibliometric analysis and managerial implications. Journal of Advertising, 50(2), pp.160-178.

Yesiloglu, S. and Costello, J., 2020. Influencer Marketing. Building Brand Communities and Engagement.

Appendix