Current Health Human Resource Planning Challenges and Incentive Framework for a New Public General Hospital in Rural Jamaica

St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital is a fictional rural Jamaican healthcare hub. This hospital is a lifeline for residents who depend on its medical services in the region’s lush landscapes and vibrant culture. However, St. Andrew’s struggles to manage its health human resources; HR is essential for providing quality care to its community. St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital’s shortage of nurses, doctors, and specialists is a significant issue. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), Jamaica, like many other countries, is facing a shortage of healthcare workers, especially in rural areas with limited access to healthcare (WHO, 2021). Due to staff overwork, this shortage increases wait times for appointments, diagnostic tests, and surgeries and lowers care quality. Bed space shortages worsen the hospital’s capacity constraints, especially for social cases—people who are not sick but have nowhere else to go. Bed shortage results from homelessness and the absence of social support, which puts a strain on the hospital’s resources, hence the inability to respond to patients in a timely and appropriate manner (Loop Jamaica News, 2023). St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital is confronted with staffing issues, a lack of capacity, and outdated health information management systems with manual processes that reduce efficiency and increase the risk of data inaccuracy. An ineffective health information system slows down the retrieval of patient information, increases the risk of error, and compromises patient safety. The complexity of the hospital’s problems is aggravated by the low level of staff and client satisfaction, which negatively impacts the staff’s morale, retention, and performance. High dissatisfaction among staff members and medical errors negatively affect care quality.

This paper will discuss St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital’s strategic human resource planning in light of the complex issues that encompass the health service. The task is to enhance healthcare delivery in rural Jamaica by evaluating the current situation, browsing the possible solutions, and developing a realistic incentive plan for staff. After a deep analysis of these issues, we can grasp the healthcare workforce management and come up with measures to enhance the quality and access of healthcare services in the region.

Current Health Human Resource Planning Challenges

Shortage of Healthcare Professionals

There are very few nurses, doctors, and specialists at St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital in rural Jamaica. The healthcare system of Jamaica faces a deficit of skilled workers, indicating low quality and access. World Health Organization’s report during the COVID-19 pandemic reveals that the number of medical practitioners in Jamaica is insufficient to cater to the populace’s needs, especially in rural areas (WHO, 2021). The shortage of healthcare specialists limits St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital to treat patients quickly.

Impact on Hospital Operations

The shortage of healthcare workers is a factor that affects many aspects of St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital’s operation.

Long Waiting Times for Outpatient Clients

Long outpatient wait times are the most visible adverse outcome of the healthcare professional shortage. The existing bed capacity at the hospital is not enough to meet the growing number of patients, which causes delays in scheduling appointments and consultations. A large amount of time spent in outpatient lines significantly reduces patient satisfaction and health outcomes, as determined by McIntyre and Chow (2020).

Insufficient Bed Space due to Social Cases

Due to a healthcare professional shortage, St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital lacks social care beds for those who are not sick enough to be hospitalized. These people fill hospital beds, straining resources and causing overpopulation. Sartini et al. (2022) found that overcrowded hospitals increase healthcare-associated infections and impair service delivery.

Long Wait Times for Diagnostic Tests and Operations

A healthcare workforce shortage similarly impacts diagnostic and surgical wait times at St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital. Insufficient staff support delays scheduling, testing, and procedures, leading to patient dissatisfaction and poor clinical outcomes. McIntyre and Chow (2020) demonstrate the importance of prompt surgery in survival and death rates.

Outdated Health Information Management System

St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital struggles with a workforce shortage and an outdated health information management system that employs manual methods and old technologies. This old-fashioned technology results in inefficient patient data collection, storage, and retrieval, which calls into question the clinical workflows and patient safety. In their study, Epizitone and others (2023) emphasize the role of modernized health information systems to ensure better patient care. They underscore the significance of cost-cutting mechanisms, speed-up in getting patient and medical data from records, higher efficiency in accessing and keeping patient data, and centralized health information for all stakeholders with remote access.

Low Staff and Client Satisfaction

Staff and patient satisfaction at St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital is poor due to a shortage of healthcare professionals and hospital operational issues. The Journal of Nursing Management found that poor staff satisfaction increases medical mistakes and improves care quality (Nantsupawat et al., 2022). Studies have linked low customer satisfaction to worse health outcomes and treatment adherence.

Lack of Specialized Mental Health Professionals

The lack of mental health experts is another major issue for St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital. Jamaica has a high rate of mental health issues, yet rural regions lack access to mental healthcare (Leonie, 2021). Lack of qualified mental health specialists worsens mental healthcare access inequities and poor mental health outcomes for hospital patients.

High Turnover Rate Among Administrative Staff

The turnover of administrative personnel at St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital is substantial, hindering health human resource planning. Administrative churn can hinder leadership, organizational continuity, and strategic healthcare workforce objectives. Administrative staff turnover exacerbates the hospital’s people challenges, requiring specialized actions to improve retention and stability.

Current Strategies and Actions

Importation of Nurses and Doctors from Cuba

St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital has implemented several strategies to tackle the healthcare worker shortage problem. One solution is offering Cuban nurses and physicians the opportunity to work for short periods. This strategy takes advantage of Cuba’s well-developed healthcare system and trained medical personnel and, for a limited time, increases the hospital’s workforce (Squires et al., 2020). St. Andrew’s is looking to recruit healthcare specialists from foreign countries to address the acute staffing shortage and continue providing healthcare at the local level. Cuba has long supported health and medical education in low-income countries, as Squires et al. (2020) mentioned. Enlisting the services of Cuban nurses and doctors on a contract basis can be a realistic solution to the hospital staffing challenges. The shortage of local healthcare workers can be reduced momentarily using an intervention. However, this intervention cannot resolve the long-term problem of this shortage. It becomes a question of how foreign medical staff members can be smoothly integrated into the hospital healthcare team through planning and coordination that involves overcoming cultural competence, language barriers, and treatment continuity.

Recent Increase in Wages of Nurses and Doctors

The 50-100% pay increment for doctors and nurses is another way St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital can address the shortage of health sector workers. This monstrous increment in salary is geared towards stabilizing the services of the health sector staff by offering compensation and allowances corresponding to their skills. There are several studies that point out the fact that competitive wages not only help to attract healthcare professionals but also make it possible to hire and retain them, especially in those areas that are marginalized and have workforce shortages (Abelsen et al., 2020). This pay increase is thus an acknowledgment that healthcare professionals deserve fair compensation for their enormous contributions to patient care and the healthcare system. St. Andrew’s provides competitive remuneration to attract healthcare workers, reduce staff turnover, and increase employee retention. Higher pay, in turn, is proven to positively affect staff morale and job satisfaction, which are excellent predictors of improved patient outcomes and organizational performance (Abelsen et al., 2020).

Analysis of Current Actions

Effectiveness of Current Strategies

St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital’s present personnel policies, such as the importation of Cuban healthcare workers and the pay increase of nurses and doctors, have proven less effective. These ways have eased human resources shortages and upgraded the financial incentives for health workers. However, they have not dealt with the systemic causes of the Jamaican healthcare workers’ crisis. The Federation for American Immigration Reform offers to use the services of foreign healthcare workers in short-term staffing gaps, but it is by no means a sustainable solution (Hickey, 2020). Foreign labor reliance may also bring up cultural competency, language, and continuity of care issues that could result in the low quality and effectiveness of healthcare.

The current salary enhancement for nurses and doctors aims to attract and retain skilled healthcare professionals. Competitive compensation helps recruit and retain healthcare workers, especially in underserved areas with workforce shortages (Abelsen et al., 2020). Higher wages may temporarily improve staff retention and morale, but they may not address the systemic issues causing the healthcare workforce shortage, such as inadequate training and education programs, limited career advancement opportunities, and difficult working conditions.

Implications of Wage Increase and Staff Importation

St.The pay hike and Cuban staff imports affect Andrew’s Regional Hospital’s solutions and worker morale. The wage rise may boost worker morale and retention in the short term, but the hospital’s ability to generate enough income to cover the costs will determine its long-term survival. The pay increase may not be financially viable if it does not improve organizational performance and patient outcomes. Strategic compensation can boost job dedication and passion, according to Okoye (2022).

Importing healthcare experts from Cuba may temporarily relieve staffing shortages, but it may not solve Jamaica’s healthcare personnel crisis. Cultural competency, language hurdles, and continuity of care may also be issues with imported workers. Al Shamsi et al. (2020) remark that overcoming linguistic barriers makes it harder to satisfy medical practitioners and patients, provide high-quality healthcare, and ensure patient safety. Healthcare personnel and patients who do not speak the same language sometimes face cultural and language barriers.

Additional Actions for Addressing Health Human Resource Challenges

St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital must holistically address its complex health human resource issues. Several other activities can help improve workforce capacity, staff satisfaction, and rural community care.

Implementing Targeted Recruitment Drives

Targeted local and worldwide recruitment initiatives for competent healthcare workers work well. Abelson et al. (2020) found that proactive recruitment and tailored marketing initiatives can assist hospitals in filling key staffing gaps by reaching more candidates. St. Andrew’s can promote its unique chances to prospects through recruitment agencies, job fairs, and online channels.

Enhancing Training and Development Programs

Building a talented workforce requires investing in personnel training and development. Continuous training can help St. Andrew’s staff adapt to changing healthcare practices. Specialized training modules, workshops, and certification programs help staff improve patient care. Medical education must emphasize primary care to improve Universal Health Coverage. Global health workforce education leaders recommend overhauling medical training to meet population health needs, according to Squires et al. (2020).

Collaborating with Educational Institutions

By developing a recruitment and internship pipeline, St. Andrew’s can attract and retain local and international students of learning institutions. The hospital can recruit highly skilled individuals and speed up the educational-to-workforce transfer by partnering with nursing, medical, and allied health schools (Squires et al., 2020). St. Andrew’s may also partner with academic institutions to make the forthcoming healthcare workers adaptable to the community’s changing needs.

Upgrading the Health Information Management System

The health information system should be updated to the point where it will be possible to improve the data flow, accuracy, and accessibility. St. Andrew’s can enhance its administrative workflow, clinical decision-making, and error reduction through the use of EHRs and interoperable technologies (Epizitone et al., 2023). EHRs improve care by promoting continuity of information interchange and facilitating communication among the videos. Tsai et al. (2020) state that EHR data standards have improved data transfer, secondary use, and decision-making.

Addressing Social Cases Through Community Partnerships

St. Andrew’s can solve social problems by helping community groups and social programs. The hospital can liaise with homeless shelters, social service agencies, and advocacy groups to develop detailed treatment plans for the vulnerable. Housing subsidies, case management, and mental health assistance can decrease the load of hospital work and improve health outcomes at the same time for the homeless and unstable communities.

Improving Communication Channels

Communication between the staff and management is essential in creating an excellent working atmosphere and improving the organization’s performance. Employee trust and transparency are built through regular meetings, feedback systems, and open-door practices (Al Shamsi et al., 2020). Good communication can catalyze happiness, employee retention, and organizational effectiveness, according to Al Shamsi et al. (2020).

Strengthening Employee Wellness Initiatives

Staff wellness programs in a health system are fundamental for employees’ mental and physical health and for burnout reduction. Wellness programs, mental health services, and stress management programs would enable St. Andrew’s employees to remain active and resilient (Abelsen et al., 2020). Employee wellness programs are the keys to morale, work happiness, less absenteeism, productivity, and patient satisfaction (Okoye, 2022). St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital should focus on employees’ wellness programs since these programs would be a basis for the institution’s resilient and sustainable healthcare staff.

Incentive Framework for Motivating Staff

Importance of Incentives

Healthcare organizations like St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital should be encouraged to improve employee satisfaction and retention through various incentives. A well-designed incentive plan can increase employee engagement, job satisfaction, and organizational performance (Abelsen et al., 2020). A happy workplace with financial awards, recognition programs, and professional progression opportunities enhances performance. In a competitive job market, incentives can recruit and keep experienced workers, ensuring the community and patients have skilled healthcare providers.

Development of a Realistic Incentive Framework

The hospital should analyze its challenges and goals to create a realistic incentive structure. An in-depth needs evaluation shows where incentives can improve staffing, morale, and patient care. The framework must reflect the hospital’s mission, standards, and strategic goals. Frontline staff, supervisors, and administrators should help St. Andrew’s create an employee-friendly reward system.

Inclusion of Financial and Non-Financial Incentives

Staff at St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital should receive financial and non-financial incentives. Performance bonuses, wage increases, and retention bonuses reward work (Abelsen et al., 2020). An inclusive workplace needs financial and non-financial rewards, including recognition, professional progress, and flexibility (Okoye, 2020). Worker engagement and satisfaction increase with non-financial rewards for gratitude, teamwork, and progress.

Strategies for Effectiveness and Sustainability

The hospital may need to disclose reward system criteria to maintain staff fairness. The hospital must set performance goals, provide regular feedback, and take responsibility for results (Burlea-Schiopoiu & Ferhati, 2020). It should assess the incentive program’s influence on staff satisfaction, retention, and organizational success while establishing and changing it. The hospital can evaluate the incentive program and allocate resources to improve it by measuring staff turnover, patient satisfaction, and care quality (Burlea-Schiopoiu & Ferhati, 2020). It should solicit worker feedback, implement good practices, and alter the incentive system based on work conditions and organizational objectives to encourage lifelong learning and creativity.

Implementation Plan

Implementing the additional activities and reward system at St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital is challenging. It requires the organized and collaborative work of all stakeholders. The proposed plan identifies the main steps, schedule, resource allocation, and monitoring system to ensure implementation success.

Timeline for Implementation

1. Recruitment Drives: Target local and international recruiting in the first month of the implementation plan. Maintain a pipeline of qualified individuals by recruiting year-round.
2. Training Programs: The hospital should schedule staff training within the first three months of the implementation plan. Provide year-round professional development and learning to improve staff abilities.
3. System Upgrades: The hospital should upgrade the health information management system within six months of the deployment plan to minimize hospital disturbance, phase improvements, and system advancements throughout the year.
4. Incentive Framework: Implement the reward system during the first three months of the strategy. Staff should have access to financial and non-financial incentives that support organizational goals.

Allocation of Resources and Budget Considerations

1. St. Andrew’s Regional Hospital should finance advertising, recruitment firms, and travel. Use social media and partner with local educational institutions to recruit within the hospital’s budget.
2. The hospital should fund training materials, facilitators, and staff coverage. Prioritize education programs that address skill shortages and enhance hospital and patient care professionals.
3. Set aside funds for software licensing, hardware updates, and IT support. Prioritize scalable and sustainable technological solutions that support the hospital’s strategic goals and consider long-term fiscal implications.
4. Budget for incentive payouts, recognition, and administrative support. Budget financial incentives for the hospital’s annual operations.

Stakeholder Engagement and Communication Strategies

1. Staff Engagement: Develop a communication system that includes regular meetings and feedback from frontline personnel, supervisors, and administrators to ensure the process’s implementation. Staff should be introduced to the training, incentive schemes, and system updates.
2. Community Engagement: Engage the community, the patient, and local organizations in the recruitment and outreach process. Join hands with community stakeholders to eliminate socioeconomic determinants of health and provide better healthcare access for underprivileged demographics.
3. Communication Channels: Use email, newsletters, and intranet portals to disseminate implementation plans, timescales, and progress. Communication should be reliable, timely, transparent, and easy for the stakeholders to understand.

Monitoring and Evaluation Mechanisms

1. Set KPIs for staff retention, patient satisfaction, and system uptime in the implementation plan. Track progress and results with goals and benchmarks.
2. Assess intervention efficacy with staff, patients, and stakeholders. Use questionnaires, focus groups, and performance reviews to collect qualitative and quantitative data on staff satisfaction, patient experiences, and operational effectiveness.
3. Monitor implementation plan efficacy and identify areas for improvement with frequent assessments and performance reviews. Compare results to goals and objectives and make adjustments to meet corporate priorities.

Evaluation of Impact

Methods for Evaluating Effectiveness

Surveys and Questionnaires

The staff, patient, and stakeholder surveys and questionnaires will enable the hospital to uncover how they perceive, experience, and are satisfied with the services provided. For example, HCAHPS (Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems) is a standardized survey to predict patient satisfaction. Another is the MBI (Maslach Burnout Inventory), a quantitative tool to assess staff burnout.

Interviews and Focus Groups

Focus groups and interviews with staff, management, patients, and community members enable in-depth discussions and qualitative data collecting. To assess treatments’ subtle impacts, consider staff morale, patient experiences, workflow improvements, and community impact.

Data Analytics and Performance Metrics

Key performance indicators may be quantified using data analytics and metrics from EHRs, operational databases, and financial reports. KPIs include staff turnover, patient wait times, readmission, infection, income, and cost reductions (Burlea-Schiopoiu & Ferhati, 2020).

Benchmarking and Comparative Analysis

St. Andrew’s Hospital may be benchmarked to similar healthcare institutions using peer hospitals, industry standards, and best practices. The number of patients to staff ratio, average length of stay, mortality rates, and patient satisfaction scores can guide performance improvement.

Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)

1. Assess staff satisfaction using surveys, focus groups, and turnover rates. Staff satisfaction KPIs include work satisfaction, retention, absenteeism, and professional development. Incentives and workforce development programs will significantly help improve the workers’ contentment.
2. Assess patient outcomes using KPIs, including satisfaction, PROs, mortality, readmission, infection, and clinical recommendations. Patient outcomes increase with better treatment, communication, and patient-centered approaches.
3. Monitor the patients’ time for outpatient visits, testing, operations, and emergency treatment. Wait time KPIs feature average wait times, treatment time, schedule vacancy, and time efficiency. Wait time improvements will lead to higher care effectiveness and utilization.
4. Assess the hospital’s efficiency using KPIs such as bed occupancy, length of stay, resource use, revenue per patient, and cost per patient as a benchmark—efficiency improvements help maximize resources, improve process workflow, and boost finance sustainability.

References

Abelsen, B., Strasser, R., Heaney, D., Berggren, P., Sigurðsson, S., Brandstorp, H., … & Nicoll, P. (2020). Plan, recruit, retain: a framework for local healthcare organizations to achieve a stable remote rural workforce. Human resources for health, 18, 1-10. https://human-resources-health.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12960-020-00502-x

Al Shamsi, H., Almutairi, A. G., Al Mashrafi, S., & Al Kalbani, T. (2020). Implications of language barriers for healthcare: a systematic review. Oman Medical Journal, 35(2), e122. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7201401/

Burlea-Schiopoiu, A., & Ferhati, K. (2020, December). The managerial implications of the key performance indicators in the healthcare sector: A cluster analysis. In Healthcare (Vol. 9, No. 1, p. 19). MDPI. https://www.mdpi.com/2227-9032/9/1/19/pdf

Epizitone, A., Moyane, S. P., & Agbehadji, I. E. (2023, March). A systematic literature review of health information systems for healthcare. In Healthcare (Vol. 11, No. 7, p. 959). MDPI. https://www.mdpi.com/2227-9032/11/7/959/pdf

Hickey, J. (2020). Importing Foreign Nurses is Not a Long-Term Solution to Staffing Shortages. Federation for American Immigration Reform. https://www.fairus.org/blog/2020/04/07/importing-foreign-nurses-not-long-term-solution-staffing-shortages

Leonie S. M. (2021). Behavioral Health Integration: Jamaica. LinkedIn. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/behavioral-health-integration-jamaica-leonie-s-mandeville/

Loop Jamaica News. (2023). Social cases soaking up bed space in the west. Loop. https://jamaica.loopnews.com/content/social-cases-soaking-bed-space-west

McIntyre, D., & Chow, C. K. (2020). Waiting time as an indicator for health services under strain: a narrative review. INQUIRY: The Journal of Health Care Organization, Provision, and Financing, 57, 0046958020910305. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/0046958020910305

Nantsupawat, A., Poghosyan, L., Wichaikhum, O. A., Kunaviktikul, W., Fang, Y., Kueakomoldej, S., … & Turale, S. (2022). Nurse staffing, missed care, quality of care and adverse events: A cross‐sectional study. Journal of Nursing Management, 30(2), 447-454. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9017335/#:~:text=Further%20significant%20international%20research%20studies,%2C%20falls%2C%20pressure%20ulcers%2C%20critical

OKOYE, V. C. (2022). Compensation and Organizational Performance, a Study of Muoka Foam Lagos. International Journal of Business Systems and Economics, 13(5), 225–234. https://www.arcnjournals.org/images/ARCN-IJBSE-2022-13-5-16.pdf

Sartini, M., Carbone, A., Demartini, A., Giribone, L., Oliva, M., Spagnolo, A. M., … & Cristina, M. L. (2022, August). Overcrowding in emergency department: causes, consequences, and solutions—a narrative review. In Healthcare (Vol. 10, No. 9, p. 1625). MDPI. https://www.mdpi.com/2227-9032/10/9/1625/pdf

Squires, N., Colville, S. E., Chalkidou, K., & Ebrahim, S. (2020). Medical training for universal health coverage: a review of Cuba–South Africa collaboration. Human Resources for Health, pp. 18, 1–10. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7026964/

Tsai, C. H., Eghdam, A., Davoody, N., Wright, G., Flowerday, S., & Koch, S. (2020). Effects of electronic health record implementation and barriers to adoption and use: a scoping review and qualitative analysis of the content. Life, 10(12), 327. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7761950/

World Health Organization. (2021). Impact of COVID-19 on human resources for health and policy response: the case of Plurinational State of Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador and Peru: overview of findings from five Latin American countries. World Health Organization. https://cdn.who.int/media/docs/default-source/health-workforce/hlm/pahocrbcovid19220001_eng.pdf?sfvrsn=5b1cb99a_3&download=true