John Snow pioneered new epidemiological methods to identify the source of the cholera epidemic in London. At a time when disease was believed to spread through miasmas or bad air, Snow hypothesized that cholera was transmitted through contaminated water. To test this, he created one of the first disease maps, plotting cholera deaths around water pumps in the Soho area. This spatial clustering showed many victims lived or worked near the Broad Street pump. Snow also conducted interviews and surveys, finding brewery workers unaffected as they drank beer rather than water. Through this pioneering use of mapping, statistics, and interviews, Snow provided quantitative evidence linking the outbreak to the Broad Street pump. Though germ theory had not yet been developed, Snow’s novel deductive techniques and data analysis were foundational to modern epidemiology. His work supported water-borne disease transmission by pinpointing the pump as the infection source. While the handle removal was likely symbolic, Snow’s rational investigation methods marked a significant turning point in public health, validating that robust data analysis and interviewing could identify disease sources for targeted intervention and prevention.
Proving a causal relationship requires collecting data that shows a link between a suspected cause and effect that is consistent, strong, specific, and temporal. Consistency means the effect always occurs with the cause. Strength refers to the magnitude of the effect resulting from the cause. Specificity means the cause leads to a single effect instead of multiple effects (Barons & Wilkerson, 2018). Temporality requires the cause to precede the effect. Data to support causal claims often comes from comparison groups. For example, Snow compared cholera rates in brewery workers (unexposed to pump water) versus Soho residents (exposed). This showed the effect – cholera – was far more common in the exposed group, suggesting causation. Analytic epidemiological studies also provide causal solid evidence. These include cohort studies tracking exposed and unexposed groups over time and case-control studies comparing those with and without disease. Data on dose-response relationships also back causation – more exposure causes more effect. Overall, causal inferences are most robust when supported by multiple rigorous studies with datasets showing consistency, strength, specificity, temporality, and biological mechanisms logically linking cause and effect. Snow’s analysis did not prove cholera’s waterborne nature but laid analytical foundations for the epidemiological methods that could.
John Snow did not conclusively prove that contaminated drinking water causes cholera in his 1854 investigation. While his data analysis strongly suggested the Broad Street pump was the source of the local outbreak, he did not establish a definitive causal link between the contaminated water and cholera for several reasons. First, his sample size was limited to one neighborhood, so expanding the mapping and statistical methods to other areas could have provided more substantial evidence (Tulchinsky 2018). Second, the timing of the earliest cases relative to the pump’s contamination was unclear, making the temporal relationship uncertain. Additionally, his theory relied on the water-borne transmission of an unknown pathogen without germ theory. While alternative explanations were not entirely ruled out, the clustering around the pump pointed to a likely causal role. Ultimately, Snow’s innovative investigative techniques pioneered analytic approaches that would later definitively prove cholera’s mechanism of transmission. However, with limited data and scientific understanding at the time, his individual study fell short of demonstrating that contaminated drinking water conclusively causes cholera. His work pointed the way but did not fully prove causation.
Reference
Barons, M. J., & Wilkerson, R. L. (2018). Proof and uncertainty in causal claims. Exchanges: The Interdisciplinary Research Journal, 5(2), 72-89. https://journals.warwick.ac.uk/index.php/exchanges/article/view/238
Snow, J. (2008, November 11). John Snow and the cholera outbreak 1854 with Mike Jay | Medical London [Video]. YouTube. https://youtu.be/Pq32LB8j2K8?si=PH9GP3DslhNJZX61
Tulchinsky T. H. (2018). John Snow, Cholera, the Broad Street Pump; Waterborne Diseases Then and Now. Case Studies in Public Health, 77–99. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-804571-8.00017-2
write