Scenario Description
During a placement at a National Health Service (NHS) hospital in the United Kingdom, I observed a critical event involving a patient with severe respiratory pain caused by aggravation and worsening of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).Doctors, nurses, and respiratory therapists were among the medical professionals who treated the patient. The incident occurred in an acute care setting, namely the intensive care unit (ICU) of the hospital.
The condition of the patient worsened quickly upon admission, requiring immediate intervention from the medical team. The senior physician leading the team adopted a directive leadership style, providing clear instructions and making critical decisions regarding the patient’s treatment plan. Tasks were delegated to different team members based on their expertise, and conflict resolution was minimal but involved assertive communication to ensure tasks were carried out efficiently. Change management was implicit in the rapid adaptation of the team to the evolving clinical situation.
The outcome for the patient was positive, with timely intervention stabilizing their condition and preventing further deterioration. However, the outcome for the staff varied. While some appreciated the clear direction provided by the leader, others felt overwhelmed by the intensity of the situation and the pressure to perform under stress.
NMC Confidentiality Statement
I confirm that in accordance with the Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) guidelines on confidentiality, all identifying information about the patient, healthcare professionals, and the healthcare facility has been omitted or altered to ensure anonymity and confidentiality (Duffy & Gillies, 2018). The details provided in this reflection are for educational purposes only and do not compromise patient privacy or confidentiality.
Effective leadership is essential in healthcare settings to ensure optimal patient outcomes and a conducive work environment. Through the examination of the directive leadership style in decision-making and delegation, this analysis aims to highlight its effectiveness in facilitating quick responses and efficient task allocation in healthcare settings. However, alternative leadership approaches, such as transformational leadership and empowering delegation, could further enhance team engagement and accountability, ultimately improving patient care outcomes.
Leadership Style Observed
In this section, I will critically analyze the leadership elements of decision-making and delegation observed during the described event in the NHS hospital ICU setting. These elements were chosen due to their significant impact on team dynamics and patient outcomes, as outlined in the introduction.
Decision-Making and Task Delegation
The directive leadership style adopted by the senior physician facilitated quick decision-making in the high-pressure environment of the ICU. The urgency of the situation necessitated rapid responses to stabilize the patient’s condition. The senior physician centralized decision-making authority, providing clear instructions to the medical team regarding the patient’s treatment plan.
From a theoretical perspective, this leadership approach aligns with aspects of transactional leadership, where leaders provide clear directives and rewards based on performance (Barr & Dowding, 2016). The senior physician effectively assumed the role of a transactional leader by establishing clear goals and expectations for the team.
The effectiveness of this approach in the described event can be evaluated based on the positive outcome for the patient. Timely intervention and decisive actions led to the stabilization of the patient’s condition, preventing further deterioration. The directive leadership style contributed to the efficient coordination and implementation of the treatment plan, ultimately benefiting the patient.
However, an alternative leadership approach, such as transformational leadership, could have promoted greater team engagement and collaboration in decision-making. Transformational leaders motivate and inspire their teams to perform better by establishing a common vision and allowing everyone to contribute their ideas and expertise (Stanley, 2022).
In the context of the described event, a transformational leadership approach could have encouraged more active participation from the entire medical team in decision-making processes. By soliciting input from team members regarding the patient’s treatment plan, the senior physician could have leveraged the collective expertise and insights of the team to optimize patient care outcomes. The potential effectiveness of a transformational leadership approach in this scenario lies in its ability to enhance team morale and satisfaction (Bush, 2018). Transformational leaders instill a sense of ownership and accountability in their teams by involving them in decision-making processes, which leads to greater job satisfaction and motivation.
Effective delegation is crucial in healthcare settings to ensure that tasks are allocated to individuals based on their skills and competencies, maximizing efficiency and promoting accountability. In the described event, the senior physician delegated tasks to different team members based on their expertise, demonstrating an understanding of effective delegation principles. The senior physician’s delegation method is consistent with features of situational leadership theory, in which leaders adapt their leadership style based on their followers’ readiness and competency (Gopee & Galloway, 2017). By delegating tasks to individuals with the necessary skills and experience, the senior physician effectively adapted their leadership approach to the specific needs of the situation.
The effectiveness of this delegation approach in the described event can be evaluated based on the successful completion of tasks and the positive outcome for the patient. Delegating tasks to individuals with the relevant expertise ensured that critical aspects of the patient’s care were addressed efficiently, contributing to the overall success of the treatment plan.
However, an alternative delegation approach could involve more empowerment of team members to take ownership of their assigned tasks. Empowering delegation involves providing individuals with the authority and autonomy to make decisions within their scope of practice (Vu, 2020). In the context of the described event, empowering delegation could have further promoted accountability and engagement among team members. The effectiveness of empowering delegation lies in its ability to enhance team autonomy and accountability. Leaders build a sense of responsibility and commitment in their teams by empowering them to take ownership of their tasks, which leads to higher job satisfaction and productivity.
The concept of accountability for all staff involved
Accountability is a fundamental aspect of leadership in healthcare settings, ensuring that all staff members are responsible for their actions and decisions (Byansi, 2023). In the described event, accountability was implicit in the clear allocation of tasks and responsibilities by the senior physician. Each team member was accountable for their specific role in the patient’s care, whether it was administering medication, monitoring vital signs, or coordinating with other healthcare professionals. By clearly delineating roles and responsibilities, the senior physician promoted accountability among team members, ensuring that each individual understood their contribution to the patient’s overall care plan.
Moreover, accountability was reinforced through regular communication and feedback within the team. Team members were encouraged to report any concerns or issues promptly, fostering a culture of transparency and accountability.
Overall, the concept of accountability was effectively integrated into the leadership approach observed in the described event. By promoting accountability among team members, the senior physician ensured that everyone remained focused on delivering high-quality care and achieving positive outcomes for the patient.
The leadership elements of decision-making and delegation observed in the described event demonstrated effective leadership in a high-pressure healthcare setting. The directive leadership style facilitated quick decision-making, while effective delegation ensured that tasks were efficiently allocated based on individual competencies (Motacki & Burke, 2022). However, alternative leadership approaches, such as transformational leadership and empowering delegation, could further enhance team engagement and accountability. By critically analyzing these leadership elements, healthcare professionals can gain valuable insights into improving leadership practices and ultimately delivering better patient care outcomes.
Reflection on Future Practice and Leadership Development
This comprehensive examination of leadership in a hospital setting has produced remarkable insights into the intricacies of leadership and its impact on team dynamics and patient outcomes. Drawing on academic leadership literature and theories (Gumus et al., 2018), I now have a better grasp of the strengths and shortcomings of various leadership styles, as well as the implications for healthcare delivery. As I think about this research, I am encouraged to continue my leadership development path and aim to be a more effective leader in the future.
Knowledge and Understanding of Leadership
Through this analysis, I have deepened my knowledge and understanding of leadership theories and their practical application in healthcare settings. I have learned about various leadership styles, including directive, transformational, and collaborative leadership, and their respective strengths and limitations (Dugan, 2024). ). I now recognize the value of adaptive leadership, in which leaders tailor their approach to the specific needs of the circumstance and the persons involved.
Current Leadership Approach
Reflecting on my current leadership approach, I tend to lean towards a collaborative leadership style. I value teamwork and inclusivity, and I believe in empowering team members to contribute their ideas and expertise. While this approach fosters a positive team environment and encourages creativity and innovation (Ang’ana & Kilika, 2022), I acknowledge the need to balance collaboration with decisiveness, especially in critical situations where quick decisions are required.
Desired Leadership Style
In the future, I aspire to evolve into a transformational leader. I like this leadership style because it focuses on encouraging and motivating others to reach their greatest potential. Transformational leaders have a vision for the future and are committed to driving positive change. They promote a culture of continuous learning and progress, and they encourage team members to take responsibility for their work and contribute to the organization’s success (Farahnak et al., 2020). As a transformational leader, I envision myself setting a good example and cultivating a friendly and inclusive work atmosphere in which team members feel appreciated and empowered. I want to inspire others with a common goal of excellence in patient care and foster a culture of collaboration, innovation, and continuous progress.
Development of Leadership Skills
To develop my leadership skills in the future, I plan to engage in various learning activities and professional development opportunities. Continuous education will be crucial, as I aim to keep up with the latest advancements in healthcare leadership through continued education and professional development opportunities. This will entail attending conferences, workshops, and seminars, as well as obtaining further education or certifications in healthcare leadership. Mentorship and coaching will also play crucial roles in my leadership development journey. As noted by Garvey, Garvey, and Stokes (2021), mentorship and coaching provide invaluable guidance, support, and feedback.
By seeking out mentors and coaches who are experienced healthcare leaders, I hope to gain insights into effective leadership practices, improve my skills, and handle challenges more successfully. In addition, I appreciate the value of mentoring and coaching people on their leadership journeys. By sharing my knowledge, experiences, and experiences gained, I want to encourage and support young leaders to promote their growth and development.
Furthermore, criticism and self-reflection will be critical to my development as a leader. I will actively seek input from coworkers, supervisors, and team members to discover areas for improvement and track my leadership development. Regular self-reflection will also enable me to identify my skills and limitations and develop goals for continual progress.
Participation in leadership training programs offered by professional organizations, healthcare institutions, and academic institutions will provide additional opportunities for skill development and networking with other healthcare leaders. These programs will offer hands-on learning experiences and opportunities to exchange ideas and best practices with peers (Lacerenza et al., 2017).
Moreover, networking will be a priority as I aim to expand my professional network by connecting with other healthcare leaders through professional associations, conferences, and networking events. By seeking out opportunities to collaborate with colleagues from diverse backgrounds and disciplines, I hope to exchange ideas, share best practices, and learn from each other.
Lastly, engaging in action learning projects within my healthcare organization will be a cornerstone of my leadership development journey. By initiating and leading these projects, I will have the opportunity to tackle key challenges faced by the organization while driving positive change (Revans, 2017). These projects will serve as practical platforms to apply leadership theories and principles in real-world scenarios, allowing me to hone my decision-making, problem-solving, and strategic planning skills in a dynamic and evolving environment. Through collaboration with multidisciplinary teams and stakeholders, I anticipate gaining valuable insights, fostering innovative solutions, and enhancing my ability to lead effectively amidst complexity and uncertainty. Leading action learning projects will also enable me to demonstrate proactive leadership, inspire team members, and contribute to the organization’s overall success.
Ultimately, this reflective analysis has provided valuable insights into my current leadership approach and aspirations for the future. By leveraging academic leadership literature and theories, reflecting on my strengths and areas for growth, and actively pursuing opportunities for learning and development, I am committed to becoming a transformational leader who positively impacts patient outcomes and fosters a culture of excellence in healthcare delivery.
Conclusion
In conclusion, this assignment has critically examined a healthcare leadership scenario in an NHS hospital ICU setting, focusing on decision-making and delegation. The directive leadership style observed, akin to transactional leadership, contributed to swift decision-making and efficient task delegation, resulting in a positive outcome for the patient. However, alternative approaches, such as transformational leadership and empowering delegation, could enhance team engagement and autonomy. The concept of accountability was integral to the leadership approach, reinforcing a culture of responsibility and transparent communication.
Reflecting on this analysis, it is evident that leadership in healthcare is multifaceted, requiring adaptability and a nuanced understanding of various styles. The exploration of academic leadership literature has informed the recognition of the need for continuous learning and growth. Currently favoring a collaborative leadership style, the aspiration is to evolve into a transformational leader, inspiring positive change and fostering a culture of excellence. Future development strategies include continuous education, mentorship, feedback, leadership training, networking, and engagement in action learning projects. This journey aims to enhance leadership skills, contributing to the ongoing improvement of patient care outcomes and cultivating a dynamic and inclusive healthcare environment.
Reference List
Ang’ana, G.A. and Kilika, J.M., 2022. Collaborative Leadership in an Organizational Context: A Research Agenda. Journal of Human Resource & Leadership, 6(1), pp.48-71.
Barr, J. and Dowding, L., (2022). Leadership in health care. Sage.
Bush, T., (2018). Transformational leadership: Exploring common conceptions. Educational Management Administration & Leadership, 46(6), pp.883-887.
Byansi, P.K., 2023. Health Leadership and Management Practices that Support Accountability for Results (Doctoral dissertation, Walden University).
Duffy, K. and Gillies, A., 2018. Supervision and assessment: The new nursing and midwifery council standards. Nursing Management, 25(3).
Dugan, J.P., 2024. Leadership theory: Cultivating critical perspectives. John Wiley & Sons.
Farahnak, L.R., Ehrhart, M.G., Torres, E.M. and Aarons, G.A., 2020. The influence of transformational leadership and leader attitudes on subordinate attitudes and implementation success. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies, 27(1), pp.98-111.
Garvey, B., Garvey, R. and Stokes, P., 2021. Coaching and mentoring: Theory and practice. Sage.
Gopee, N. and Galloway, J., 2017. Leadership and management in healthcare. Sage.
Gumus, S., Bellibas, M.S., Esen, M. and Gumus, E., 2018. A systematic review of studies on leadership models in educational research from 1980 to 2014. Educational Management Administration & Leadership, 46(1), pp.25-48.
Lacerenza, C.N., Reyes, D.L., Marlow, S.L., Joseph, D.L. and Salas, E., 2017. Leadership training design, delivery, and implementation: A meta-analysis. Journal of applied psychology, 102(12), p.1686.
Motacki, K. and Burke, K., 2022. Nursing Delegation and Management of Patient Care-E-Book. Elsevier Health Sciences.
Revans, R., 2017. ABC of action learning. Routledge.
Stanley, D., 2022. Leadership theories and styles. Clinical Leadership in Nursing and Healthcare, pp.31-60.
Vu, H.M., 2020. Employee empowerment and empowering leadership: A literature review.
write