1.1 Background and Context
The construction business could undergo many revolutions due to AI and the Metaverse. By utilizing image recognition, machine learning, on-site sensors, building information modeling (BIM), and blockchain-based “smart contracts,” AI can increase construction processes’ efficiency, accuracy, and safety. Architects, engineers, and contractors can use the Metaverse to collaborate and visualize building projects. This helps improve project management and communication. The study focuses on using artificial intelligence (AI) and the Metaverse in the construction sector, mainly when settling legal disputes over construction projects. Although the construction sector has historically hesitated to adopt new technologies, the growing usage of AI and the Metaverse has opened up new possibilities for enhancing cooperation, communication, and conflict resolution.
According to the stakeholders in this industry, construction conflicts are a severe problem for the business and can significantly affect how projects turn out. Integrating AI and the Metaverse in construction conflicts can bring significant benefits because conventional dispute resolution processes may be time-consuming, expensive, and ineffective. AI can speed up resolving disputes by providing objective data and analysis, cutting down on time and expense. The Metaverse can also give parties a digital stage to argue their case and bargain compromises, enhancing the effectiveness and timeliness of conflict resolution (Chen, 2022). The issues can be addressed using AI and Metaverse in construction disputes, which present several difficulties and moral dilemmas. The Metaverse raises worries about privacy and security, and the use of AI in conflict resolution raises questions about fairness and prejudice. As a result, it’s crucial to carefully analyze the difficulties and moral issues raised by their application in this situation.
1.2 Thesis statement: Integrating AI and the Metaverse in the construction industry can revolutionize the industry by improving efficiency, accuracy, and safety in construction processes and enhancing dispute resolution.
2. AI and Metaverse Revolution in Construction
2.1 AI and the Metaverse Can Improve Construction Processes
Two powerful technologies, artificial intelligence and the Metaverse, have a unique ability to change the building sector completely. Integrating these technologies can significantly enhance construction processes’ efficiency, precision, and safety. AI can analyze a lot of data, and decisions may be made based on that analysis. Because there is a lot of data to be evaluated in the construction business, it is a potent tool (Schumacher, 2022). Project management is one application for AI. Project timetables, labor needs, and material delivery are just a few variables that AI algorithms may examine to spot possible issues before they arise. AI is also applicable to architectural design. Engineers and architects can use AI algorithms to improve designs and spot potential structural problems. To ensure that designs are secure and effective, AI may examine data from various sources, such as building codes, climatic patterns, and material qualities. Safety on building sites is another application for AI. AI systems can examine data from various sources, such as weather trends and safety records, to find potential safety risks.
Additionally, a virtual environment called the Metaverse is produced by fusing virtual and actual data. The Metaverse can mimic a construction site virtually in the construction business. The usage of this virtual model allows for the simulation of construction procedures and the early detection of potential issues. Eliminating costly errors can help construction companies save time and money. Workers can be trained using the Metaverse to increase their overall productivity. Construction firms can develop virtual training programs that mimic actual construction procedures. Workers may benefit from learning new skills and methods in a secure setting. Building management is another area where the Metaverse can be applied. Building owners can utilize the Metaverse to monitor security, lighting, and HVAC. Building owners can use this to discover possible issues and take preventative action to avoid expensive breakdowns.
2.2 Challenges of Integrating AI and the Metaverse in Construction
The necessity for high-quality data is one of the leading technical obstacles to integrating AI and the Metaverse in a building. To create precise forecasts, AI systems need a lot of data, which might take a lot of work to obtain in the construction sector. Building information models (BIMs) can be a valuable source of data. Still, they are frequently insufficient or wrong, which can result in predictions from AI that could be more accurate and dependable. Also, getting the data required for AI algorithms within construction firms may be challenging due to the prevalence of data silos. The requirement for a reliable computing infrastructure represents another technical challenge. AI algorithms demand a lot of computing power, which can tax the capacity of the current IT infrastructure. The Metaverse also needs a lot of computational power because it processes a lot of data in real time (Liyanage et al., 2023). To meet these processing needs, integrating AI and the Metaverse into a building will necessitate a significant investment in both hardware and software. The requirement for a reliable computing infrastructure represents another technical challenge. AI algorithms demand a lot of computing power, which can tax the capacity of the current IT infrastructure. The Metaverse also needs a lot of computational power because it processes a lot of data in real time. To meet these processing needs, integrating AI and the Metaverse into a building will necessitate a significant investment in both hardware and software.
Integrating AI and the Metaverse in the building has additional difficulties due to cultural and ethical constraints. One worry is the possible loss of jobs as automation, and AI becomes more commonplace in the sector. AI and automation can replace human jobs even though they can increase productivity and cut expenses. Employee resistance to AI and automation and worries about the societal effects of automation may result from this. The possibility of bias in AI algorithms is a further worry that could result in skewed decisions about project management, recruiting, and promotion in construction. While incorporating AI and the Metaverse into a building, privacy, and security are equally crucial factors to consider. Large volumes of data on people and their activity are gathered and processed in the Metaverse. To ensure individual privacy, this data must be managed ethically and securely. Data breaches or cyberattacks may also be a problem with the usage of AI in a building. Integrating AI and the Metaverse in a building also faces legal and regulatory difficulties. In case of mistakes or accidents, using AI in building presents issues of liability and duty. There are also regulatory obstacles to overcome in areas with little legal or regulatory guidelines on using AI in construction.
2.3 Overcoming the Challenges of Integrating AI and the Metaverse in Construction
Researchers must look into the capabilities and restrictions of AI and the Metaverse in construction dispute resolution to address the problems. They must investigate the difficulties in using these technologies, such as moral and legal issues, technical constraints and requirements, and user acceptance. Additionally, researchers should look at how AI and the Metaverse may improve the dispute resolution experience for those involved in the building business. They should also suggest methods for guaranteeing the accessibility of these technologies to all stakeholders. The goals of the study should be to examine the difficulties in applying AI and the Metaverse in the construction sector, to look into how these technologies should be used ethically and responsibly, to suggest ways to ensure accessibility and to look into how these tools can improve stakeholders’ experience with dispute resolution (Shi et al., 2023). The advantages of applying AI and the Metaverse in construction disputes over conventional dispute resolution techniques should also be identified through the research. Last but not least, researchers should look into the future potential effects of AI and the Metaverse on the building industry and dispute resolution procedures and identify areas that need more research and exploration. In order to ensure accessibility and improve the dispute resolution process for stakeholders in the construction industry, researchers need to examine the possibilities and limitations of these technologies in construction conflicts. They also need to suggest accessibility assurance measures. The study’s conclusions will significantly impact the building sector and help develop new approaches to resolving construction conflicts.
3. AI and the Metaverse in Construction Disputes
3.1 Overview of its applications
Construction disputes are frequent, and the Metaverse and AI can be used to improve the methods for resolving them. The Metaverse, which may be used to model and evaluate construction projects, is a digital depiction of structures and infrastructure. This technology lowers the possibility of mistakes and disagreements by enabling stakeholders to envision and evaluate projects prior to construction. The Metaverse can benefit from AI integration to improve functioning and offer precise forecasts and insights. Predictive analytics is a suitable application of AI and the Metaverse in building disputes. Schedules, budgets, and quality assurance measures from building projects may all be analyzed by AI to spot possible issues and forecast how they will turn out. This idea can assist parties involved in a conflict anticipate potential conflicts and stopping them from worsening. Construction project stakeholders can visualize and experience projects in real time using VR and AR to build immersive experiences.
AI and the Metaverse can also facilitate processes for resolving disputes. For instance, stakeholders can quickly and effectively obtain information on the construction project and dispute resolution procedures through AI-powered chatbots. Moreover, virtual mediation and arbitration hearings can be held in the Metaverse, eliminating the need for in-person meetings and travel. The use of technology can lead to the avoidance of disagreements, the facilitation of more effective dispute-resolution procedures, and the provision of stakeholders with more precise predictions and insights (Anidjar et al., 2023). These technologies’ potential applications in construction conflicts will grow as they develop, providing significant advantages to those involved in the building sector. The likelihood of disagreements can be decreased by using this technology to spot possible problems before they happen and provide stakeholders with a better understanding of the construction process.
3.2 Advantages of these new technologies in construction disputes
3.2.1 Data analysis
The capacity to evaluate enormous amounts of data is one of the most important benefits. Large volumes of data are produced during construction projects, and managing this data using conventional methods can be time-consuming and error-prone. To find trends and abnormalities, AI systems can gather and examine data from various sources, which explains the progress of the project and any points of contention.
3.2.2 Predictive capabilities
Another benefit of adopting modern technology in construction conflicts is its forecasting powers. Based on the available information and evidence, AI and machine learning algorithms can be utilized to forecast the outcome of a legal issue. This algorithm can benefit parties who want to resolve a disagreement out of court. Parties can more accurately forecast a case’s result by utilizing AI-powered predictive models, and they can use that knowledge to bargain for a settlement that better serves their interests.
3.2.3 Risk mitigation
The other benefit of utilizing modern technology in construction conflicts is risk mitigation. By utilizing AI and the Metaverse, parties can recognize possible hazards and concerns before they develop into significant issues. AI-powered systems, for instance, can assess building blueprints and spot potential safety risks or problems that might develop while construction is underway. This system can assist parties in proactively reducing those risks and averting costly delays or disagreements in the future.
3.3 Examples of AI Impact on construction disputes
3.3.1 Building Information Modeling (BIM)
BIM software, used in planning, design, construction, and operation, digitally depicts a building’s structural and functional elements. Architects, engineers, contractors, and owners are just a few stakeholders who can collaborate on a construction project using BIM software, combining data from many sources (Sepasgozar et al., 2023). BIM technology has revolutionized planning, building, and managing construction projects. It has also shown to be a helpful tool for resolving disagreements in the field. There are a few instances of BIM technology affecting construction disputes and the value creation ability. Building information modeling, used in planning, design, construction, and operation, digitally depicts a building’s structural and functional elements. Architects, engineers, contractors, and owners are just a few stakeholders who can collaborate on a construction project using BIM software, combining data from many sources.
BIM technology has revolutionized planning, building, and managing construction projects. It has also shown to be a valuable tool for resolving disagreements in the field. There are a few instances of how BIM technology has affected construction disputes. It has also been demonstrated that using BIM technology can lower the number of disagreements that occur during construction projects. It offers a clear and unbiased information source that can be used to settle any discrepancies that might occur. Everyone working on the project has access to the same information and can quickly spot and fix any problems. The increased precision provided by BIM technology is another benefit. It offers a very realistic digital representation of the structure, allowing spotting any potential collisions or conflicts between various design aspects. This could help to avoid expensive building mistakes and rework. Potential problems can be discovered and handled with BIM technology before building ever starts, resulting in a more precise and efficient. BIM technology has the potential to save all parties involved a significant amount of money. BIM technology can help to save costly rework and delays by seeing potential design or construction faults before they happen. All parties, including owners, contractors, and subcontractors, experience cost savings.
3.3.2 Smart Contract and Blockchain Technology.
Blockchain and smart contract technologies have also impacted construction conflicts in addition to BIM technology. When specific criteria are met, these contracts are automatically carried out and stored on a decentralized blockchain network. By ensuring that everyone involved in the project is accountable for their actions, intelligent contracts can eliminate disputes in the construction sector. The contract’s terms are immutably preserved on the blockchain, which means they cannot be altered. This situation offers a clear and safe method of documenting and upholding agreements between parties. Project data and documents may be tracked and verified using blockchain technology, ensuring they are valid and cannot be changed or tampered with (Hutson et al., 2023). This procedure offers a reliable, unbiased data source that can be utilized to settle disagreements during the construction process. Hence, blockchain technology offers informational objectivity, security, and transparency. Construction disputes should become less frequent and simpler to resolve as these technologies continue to develop and be adopted.
4. Challenges and Limitations of AI and the Metaverse
4.1 Change in Scope
Dealing with scope modifications is one of the main obstacles to employing AI and the Metaverse in construction projects. Changes to a project’s design, materials, or other aspects may affect the project’s scope, schedule, and budget. Change orders that describe the scope alterations and additional expenses required are a part of traditional construction management strategies. However, the nature of scope changes may be more complex with AI and the Metaverse, which can cause complications and conflict (Bibri et al., 2022). Many design scenarios can be simulated, and possible problems can be identified before construction uses AI and the Metaverse. However, the simulation’s precision and capacity for foreseeing unforeseen changes are constrained. This change may lead to disagreements about extra expenses or delays brought on by scope revisions. Changes in scope may also result in disagreements on how risk and accountability should be distributed among the parties.
4.2 Contract Interpretation Issues
Understanding the contract terms is another difficulty when using AI and the Metaverse in construction projects. Contract language can become ambiguous due to new platforms and technology usage, which might result in disagreements. It is unclear how AI and Metaverse usage will affect a contract that demands a project be finished by a specific date. There may be disagreements between the parties’ interpretations of the contract. The distribution of risk and responsibility among the people concerned can also give rise to disagreements when AI and the Metaverse are used. For instance, it could not be obvious who is in charge of the results if a contractor employs AI to make design decisions. This insight can lead to liability, warranty, and insurance disputes.
4.3 Contract Management and Operational Performance
It cannot be easy to handle contracts and perform well when AI and the Metaverse are used in construction projects. Specialized knowledge and skills are needed for these technologies, which might not be easily accessible in the sector. To properly employ these technologies, the parties concerned may need to make educational and training investments, which could lead to extra expenses and delays. Moreover, the employment of AI and the Metaverse can affect how well operations are run. These technologies demand a lot of computer power and storage space, which may only be available in some places. The construction process may be delayed and hampered as a result.
4.4 Delay Issues
Delays brought on by modifications to the project’s scope can also result from the employment of AI and the Metaverse in construction projects. The capacity to visualize and simulate many design options and construction scenarios may increase the likelihood that project teams will alter the project scope, which can cause delays. The traditional construction process may also need to be significantly altered to incorporate AI and the Metaverse, including new processes, data exchange protocols, and coordination techniques. The planning and execution of this could take more time, which would cause a delay in the construction timeline. Delays can also be brought on by technological difficulties with utilizing AI and the Metaverse. These problems could involve data corruption, communication challenges, or software or hardware faults. The overall construction timetable may be affected by technical delays, which could result in litigation over liquidated and delayed damages.
The management of project hazards is another problem associated with delays. While AI and the Metaverse can help project teams better understand project hazards and manage those risks, they can also present new risks that weren’t previously considered. For instance, integrating several software platforms and data may be necessary to employ AI and the Metaverse, which raises the possibility of data breaches or cyberattacks. Project teams should carefully plan and coordinate the integration of AI and the Metaverse into their construction projects to reduce these delay difficulties. Additionally, they should create backup plans for potential technological problems and establish precise communication mechanisms to guarantee that everyone involved is informed of any project scope or timetable alterations. Project teams should also collaborate to identify and manage project risks, using the knowledge offered by AI and the Metaverse to guide their decision-making.
4.5 Design Issues
Design challenges can also arise when using AI and the Metaverse in construction projects. These technologies could have limitations when it comes to how well they can imitate specific elements of the design. For instance, utilizing AI to imitate how natural light affects a building’s interior might need to be more accurate. This may lead to disagreements over the performance and accuracy of the design. Using AI and the Metaverse might also raise moral questions regarding design choices (Wang et al., 2023). Biases that affect design choices could be programmed into these devices. For instance, an AI system can have preferences for particular sorts of materials or aesthetics in design. This may lead to disagreements over fairness and design decisions.
4.6 Payment Issues
Industry-wide norms and procedures may make the payment problems associated with using AI and the Metaverse in construction projects even more difficult. Because of the technology’s recent development, many players in the construction sector might need to become more familiar with the payment structures or implementation models needed. Conflicts and disagreements amongst the stakeholders engaged in a building project may result from this. Industry-wide norms and procedures may make the payment problems associated with using AI and the Metaverse in construction projects even more difficult. Because of the technology’s recent development, many players in the construction sector might need to become more familiar with the payment structures or implementation models needed (Qin et al., 2022). Conflicts and disagreements amongst the stakeholders engaged in a building project may result from this. The payment arrangements for construction projects may also alter as a result of the usage of AI and the Metaverse, mainly when the technology is employed to automate some steps in the construction process. The payment structure may change from a flat sum payment upon completion to a more gradual one that encourages consistent and high-quality materials, for instance, if AI is used to monitor the quality of construction supplies. A distinct payment model that considers the ongoing quality control inspections necessary to maintain the system is required for this kind of payment structure.
The risk of security breaches or data theft is yet another issue relating to payments in construction projects utilizing AI and the Metaverse. Significant volumes of data, including sensitive financial and payment-related data, are needed for these technologies. Malicious actors may target this information, resulting in monetary losses and reputational harm. Parties involved in construction projects should ensure that the proper security measures are in place and that data is processed and kept securely to reduce this risk. In order to take into account the use of AI and the Metaverse in construction projects, new payment structures or models might be required. These models need to account for the considerable costs involved in using the technology, the potential influence on project timetables, and the hazards related to using such technologies. To create these new payment structures, parties participating in construction projects may need to collaborate and engage in much bargaining.
5. Conclusion and Recommendations
To mitigate these delay issues, project teams should carefully plan and coordinate the implementation of AI and the Metaverse into their construction projects. They should also develop contingency plans for potential technical issues and have clear communication protocols to ensure that all parties are aware of any project scope or schedule changes. In addition, project teams should work together to identify and manage project risks, leveraging the insights provided by AI and the Metaverse to make more informed decisions. Construction sites can be modeled in 3D using drones to collect precise data. They can survey job sites, monitor work progress, and spot potential dangers, giving construction crew real-time information. Site mapping, surveying, and inspections can also be done with drones, which can increase productivity and lessen the need for manual work. A digital representation of a building or other structure called a BIM can be used to simulate and evaluate construction projects. It can be used to find possible problems before the start of construction, preventing the need for expensive rework and delays. BIM can track supplies, tools, and labor, giving construction teams access to real-time information.
Besides, data from cameras and sensors on building sites can be analyzed using artificial intelligence and machine learning. This can assist with locating potential safety risks, monitoring development, and streamlining the construction process. AI can also anticipate unexpected delays and spot opportunities for cost savings. Data from cameras and sensors on building sites can be analyzed using artificial intelligence and machine learning. This can assist with locating potential safety risks, monitoring development, and streamlining the construction process. Workers in the construction industry can have their health and safety monitored via wearable technology. It can be used to monitor vital indications like heart rate, temperature, and others to ensure that construction site personnel are safe and healthy.
Integrating AI and Metaverse in the construction industry has the potential to revolutionize the industry, particularly in dispute resolution. While these technologies can bring significant benefits, such as improved collaboration, communication, and accessibility, there are challenges and ethical considerations, such as bias, privacy, and security. This research paper aimed to explore the potential and limitations of AI and the Metaverse in resolving construction disputes and provide insights into how these technologies can improve the dispute resolution experience. The research identified several challenges and limitations associated with their use, including ethical and legal considerations, technical limitations and requirements, and user adoption and acceptance. The findings from this research can inform the development of future solutions to construction disputes and contribute to understanding how AI and the Metaverse can be used in the construction industry. Further research is required to explore the potential impact of AI and the Metaverse on the construction industry and dispute resolution processes in the future, as well as to investigate strategies for ensuring the ethical and responsible use of these technologies.
Anidjar, L. Y., Packin, N. G., & Panezi, A. (2023). The Matrix Of Privacy: Data Infrastructure In The Ai-Powered Metaverse. Available at SSRN. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4363208
Bibri, S. E., Allam, Z., & Krogstie, J. (2022). The Metaverse as a virtual form of data-driven smart urbanism: platformization and its underlying processes, institutional dimensions, and disruptive impacts. Computational Urban Science, 2(1), 24. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s43762-022-00051-0
Chen, J. W. (2022). Dispute Resolution in the New Digital Era-Exploring Arbitration as a Suitable Mechanism to Resolve Disputes over Crypto Assets. Contemp. Asia Arb. J., 15, 255. https://heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPage?handle=hein.journals/caaj15&div=15&id=&page=
Hutson, J., Banerjee, G., Kshetri, N., Odenwald, K., & Ratican, J. (2023). Architecting the Metaverse: Blockchain and the Financial and Legal Regulatory Challenges of Virtual Real Estate. Journal of Intelligent Learning Systems and Applications, 15. https://digitalcommons.lindenwood.edu/faculty-research-papers/451/
Liyanage, M., Braeken, A., Shahabuddin, S., & Ranaweera, P. (2023). Open RAN security: Challenges and opportunities. Journal of Network and Computer Applications, 214, 103621. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1084804523000401
Qin, R., Ding, W., Li, J., Guan, S., Wang, G., Ren, Y., & Qu, Z. (2022). Web3-Based Decentralized Autonomous Organizations and Operations: Architectures, Models, and Mechanisms. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics: Systems. https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/9993805
Schumacher, P. (2022). The Metaverse as opportunity for architecture and society: design drivers, core competencies. Architectural Intelligence, 1(1), 11. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s44223-022-00010-z
Sepasgozar, S. M., Khan, A. A., Smith, K., Romero, J. G., Shen, X., Shirowzhan, S., … & Tahmasebinia, F. (2023). BIM and Digital Twin for Developing Convergence Technologies as Future of Digital Construction. Buildings, 13(2), 441. https://www.mdpi.com/2075-5309/13/2/441
Shi, F., Ning, H., Zhang, X., Li, R., Tian, Q., Zhang, S., … & Daneshmand, M. (2023). A new technology perspective of the Metaverse: its essence, framework and challenges. Digital Communications and Networks. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352864823000524
Wang, Y., Su, Z., & Yan, M. (2023). Social Metaverse: Challenges and Solutions. arXiv preprint arXiv:2301.10221. https://arxiv.org/abs/2301.10221