Introduction
Social work is a succession in which evidence-based theories are the stone pillars that guide practitioners on how to start, comprehend, assess, and intervene for families, individuals, and communities. Based on scientific proofs or explanations, such theories contribute towards a general frame for social workers to use for a comprehension analysis of complex behaviors in human societies and environments (Teater, 2019). By incorporating evidence-based theories into their practice, social workers can predict intervention outcomes, evaluate the effectiveness of their interventions, and gain a deeper understanding of the underlying causes of behavior (Teater, 2019). Knowing the role of a theory in social work is priceless; one can proceed with her job confidently since she is equipped with all the tools to help her clients deal with multiple social problems. The revelation of such evidence-based theories as Ego Psychology and Erikson’s Psychosocial Theory direct social work practice into a meaningful way of solving individual issues in the community (Teater, 2019). According to Ego Psychology Theory, the person’s emotional development is closely connected with their relocation of current functioning and prior mastery of other developmental stages (Freud & Strachey, 2024). This is the theory about how current life behaviors are consequences of the experiences in the past. It highlights the importance of understanding what is attended during the development stage in providing effective interventions. In contrast, Erikson’s Psychosocial Theory, a theory of the psychosocial developmental stages that Erik Erikson contributed, illustrates an in-depth eight-stage developmental model that covers every human lifespan stage. This theory conceptualizes personality as the result of a sequence of critical life stages that individuals usually experience; the successful way they pass through these stages leads to the formation of their personality.
Ego Psychology Theory
Ego Psychology Theory follows psychoanalytic concepts and focuses on the complexity of the ego as the significant personality entity. It is the crucial concept that theorizes that the ego mediates between instant gratification obsessions of the id and reality orientation balanced with the morality of a superego. However, these ego obligations enable a clear separation of external and internal experiences, prevent the runaway of drives and impulses, and permit functioning within every society (Freud & Strachey, 2024). Developmental phases take center stage and come up with present functioning since early encounters also stimulate what individuals will do in interaction with their world. Such independence marking the successful child efficiencies like before versus after confidence or shame/respect would strongly dictate the positive ability to have valuable relationships, confidence, and cope with life challenges. Aside from ego-forming difficulties, emotional regulation problems, relationships, and communication issues, such clients can also use the Ego Psychology Theory (Freud & Strachey, 2024). By discovering how bygone developmental stages affected their current functions, people can trace a route that will lead them to end their lack of self-awareness, improvement of coping strategies, and ability to grow personally in a therapeutic environment.
Moreover, Ego Psychology Theory can benefit clients facing problems related to self-esteem, decision-making ability, sadness, and control over emotions. Likewise, for example, when a person lacks the resources to remove boundaries or accept behavioral control, the ego-related concepts within therapy can bring that chance (Freud & Strachey, 2024). Clients presenting with either a defense mechanism impervious to change or one who cannot seem to maintain a sense of reality can benefit from an intervention that the Ego Psychology Theory inspires. With those that affect the client’s capacity for understanding and sadness, therapists work on those reaction mechanisms such as judgment and reality testing; ultimately, the client develops a healthy sense of self-awareness and appropriate coping mechanisms.
Erikson’s Psychosocial Theory
The psychosocial theory, a famous developmental theory put forward by Erik Erikson, consists of eight stages that are all unique and covered during the duration of a person’s life from infancy to late adulthood. This theory’s fundamental notions and principles point to their interdependences and how this applies at all stages of lifespan as the individual psychological process interacts with the environment (Orenstein & Lewis, 2022). These years are marked by a couple of crucial periods, including trust versus mistrust for infants, autonomy versus shame and doubt for toddlers, and identity versus role confusion for adolescents, and they strongly shape a person’s nature and behavior. The influence of the developmental stages on present behavior is remarkable, as there is always a successful resolution in every stage that forms one’s healthy ego identity and effective coping mechanisms (Orenstein & Lewis, 2022). For example, intimate relationships with partners with trust issues and independent or identity crises frequently use behaviors that reflect the initial conflicts that were not dealt with directly, suggesting how serious it is that these issues had not been resolved in the past and are still showing their effect in the present.
The clients will be influenced positively depending on their stage of life using Erikson’s psychosocial eight stages of development. However, they stand out among those who struggle with forming their identity and relationships and being torn by age. For instance, the youth trying to answer their questions about who they are and their roles regarding this process can find consolation and aid in programs whose subjects are this subject. Such adults who fail to build meaningful links with and those who have lost the idea of the search for destiny in midlife have something in common with two characters of the stages – Generativity and Stagnation. Moreover, for advanced adults who have been struggling with existential-depressive moods because they might have failed to achieve much in their lifetime, this theory is helpful as, through therapy, they will gain comfort and hence a self-understanding (Orenstein & Lewis, 2022). By exploring the delicate relationship between psychosocial development and behavioral outcomes at various developmental stages, social workers can create custom-made efforts suited to exact client demands, person assist assistance, and increase compassion to all age groups.
Comparative Analysis
Standard foundations are present in both Ego Psychology Theory and Erikson’s Psychosocial Theory, which is significant despite being rooted in different theoretical traditions. The main commonality of the two theories is that both of them pay much attention to the contribution of initial developmental stages in the creation of an individual psychological present, as well as mental health. Ego Psychology theory assumes that the successful resolution of conflicts throughout childhood will give rise to the healthy development of the ego (Richards & Lynch, 2020). At the same time, Erikson’s psychosocial theory focuses on coping with psychosocial crises across different life stages to achieve a sense of identity and satisfaction. Additionally, both theories focus on individual development and dynamic functioning as the individual keeps constructing intra- and ex-extra-factors throughout life (Orenstein & Lewis, 2022). Although ego mastery or psychosocial stage resolution are the common denominators in both theories, both theories underline the possibility of overcoming the difficulties a person may face and integrating these experiences as a part of their growing self-sense. Similarly, while Ego Psychology and Erikson’s influences see the effects of internal psychological processes and external environmental influences in the psychological development of individuals, they recognize their internal and sociocultural coming together to shape people’s lives.
Despite their shared emphasis on the developmental process, the Ego Psychology and Erikson’s Psychosocial Theory differ in the most critical points. One of the most outstanding differences is the discrepancy in their ideas about the main force pushing people to advance in their lives. The Ego Psychology Theory was developed as the extension of Freudian Psychiatry and gave greater weight to the intrapsychic conflicts between the id, ego, and superego (Richards & Lynch, 2020). The theory states that successful ego functioning occurs from adequately working through internal tensions. On the contrary, Erikson’s Psychosocial Theory is a broader version of development. It includes sociocultural influences on individuals who have to deal with external contexts and come through in their personal development journey and forming an identity (Orenstein & Lewis, 2022). Moreover, unlike the different ego theories, in which early childhood experiences are vital and will only influence an individual’s ego development during infancy, Erikson lays down a psychosocial development theory, which he expands to the entire lifespan of the individual. He delineates a series of stages throughout life in which an individual can be said to face psychosocial challenges.
Regarding client interventions, ego psychology theory commonly informs those in clinical psychology and counseling services about and assists clients facing ego-related problems such as self-control and active-reality listening. The Ego Psychology Theory interventions, which aim to strengthen Ego functions further and invent an individual’s ability to make intelligent decisions in life, are therapeutic interventions (Richards & Lynch, 2020). On the other hand, Erikson’s Psychosocial Theory grounds the behavior of social workers and therapists when it comes to the psychosocial crises experienced by clients at different stages of life, taking into account the critical points of identity formation and interpersonal relationships. Interventions with Erikson’s era mean these people help clients solve development problems, expand their self-integrity, and build healthy relationships.
Personal Reflection
While both Ego Psychology Theory and Erikson’s Psychosocial Theory give rise to helpful findings on human development and client intervention, I appreciate that Erikson indicates the importance created between an individual’s growth and the larger sociocultural setting. The theory introduced me to the multidimensional elements underlying clients’ lives and the identities existing within the cultural, social, and interpersonal facets (Orenstein & Lewis, 2022). This suggests that I address this issue as a psychologist by looking at an individual’s complexities and environment, like my holistic idea that humankind’s development is a continuing journey filled with growth and adaptation; even though the periods were always divided, Erikson’s continuous consecutive psychosocial stages likewise continue throughout our lifespan.
Conclusion
Including theory-focused methodologies such as Ego Psychology Theory and Erikson’s Psychosocial Theory in social work practice assists in formulating tangible plans for people interventions. These theories furnish clinicians with excellent platforms that capture the diverse nature of the human psyche and growth, making it possible to adjust the interventions according to the unique attributes and contexts of the clients. By applying these theories practically, social workers can help their clients evaluate, intervene, and ultimately affect their lives positively and persistently. In addition, the blending of empirical assertions in social workers’ skills development sends a signal to promote the profession, evidence-based practice, and advancement of all-sided health of people, families, and communities.
References
Freud, S., & Strachey, J. (2024). Group Psychology and the Analysis of the Ego: [Illustrated & Psychology Glossary & Index Added Inside]. E-Kitap Projesi & Cheapest Books.
Orenstein, G. A., & Lewis, L. (2022). Erikson’s stages of psychosocial development. In StatPearls [Internet]. StatPearls Publishing.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK556096/
Richards, A. D., & Lynch, A. A. (2020). From ego psychology to contemporary conflict theory: A historical overview. In When Theories Touch (pp. 541–558). Routledge.
Samsanovich, A. (2021). Theory and diversity: A descriptive study of Erikson’s psychosocial development stages.https://scholarworks.lib.csusb.edu/etd/1230
Teater, B. (2019). An introduction to applying social work theories and methods 3e. McGraw-Hill Education (UK).
write