The need to consider cultural differences and sensitivities while working as a journalist or trainer overseas is emphasized in John Bare’s piece “Advice and Guidance for International Journalism Trainers”. The article highlights the difficulties journalists face participating in the Knight International Press Fellowship Program and offers suggestions for efficient overseas training (Bare, n.d.). To define success, Bare emphasizes how important it is to comprehend people’s interests in various cultural contexts. He recommends risk analysis, considering possible issues, their likelihood, and their effects, for international trainers. As an example, the author presents Bonnie Huang, a Knight Fellow who encountered cultural obstacles in Cambodia while preparing journalists to cover elections. Success eventually resulted from Huang’s perseverance and ability to adjust to local obstacles.
Susan Talalay’s orientation program for Knight Fellows, which incorporates role-playing games and scenario planning to improve abilities in handling possible dangers, is mentioned in the article to highlight the need for preparedness. By encouraging an adaptable mentality rather than depending on a predefined strategy, Talalay’s utilization of real-life case studies assists trainees in dealing with the unpredictability of events overseas (Bare, n.d.). The piece also covers Lee Becker’s review, which shows how the Knight International Press Fellowship Program improved journalists’ attitudes, professional habits, and even the financial stability of media in host nations. Bare believes that information should be shared both ways since foreign journalists may teach trainees new skills.
According to the author, before beginning their responsibilities, trainers should establish baseline knowledge about the requirements, interests, and skills of journalists and media organizations. Better learning is made possible by this information, which also assists trainers in comparing progress made so far. To sustain the benefits of training after the trainer leaves, this piece also emphasizes the need to record journalists’ networks and create online learning communities (Bare, n.d.). In summary, John Bare contends that flexibility, awareness, and an emphasis on real-time feedback loops are necessary for training abroad experiences to be effective. According to him, acting is more important than strict preparation in unforeseen circumstances, and a more flexible approach is required.
Personal View
In my opinion, the article presents a strong argument for the need for cultural awareness in international training and journalism. I relate to the focus on learning about local interests and customizing training to fit certain cultural settings. In my opinion, a one-size-fits-all strategy for writing and journalism is unrealistic and may also backfire. Journalists need to be aware of the subtleties and expectations specific to each culture to connect and interact with their audience.
Based on my own experiences, I have come across circumstances in which cultural sensitivity greatly impacts how journalists are received. Taking on foreign jobs with predetermined assumptions or a standard approach might cause miscommunication and reduce the desired effect. Although comprehensive preparation is crucial, I agree with the article’s suggestion to get baseline knowledge about the professional and cultural context before beginning duties.
Effective journalism requires a detailed awareness of local settings, even if a worldwide standard for journalism may be an aspirational objective. According to the article, training programs must emphasize flexibility and a readiness to pick up tips from local journalists. Knowledge-sharing between the two parties may result in deeper partnerships and a more varied and vibrant journalism environment worldwide.
I concur with the article’s suggestion for authors who are employed overseas. Keeping an open mind, adjust to the cultural environment, and acknowledge that various contexts may have different definitions of success. Prioritize establishing connections, accept the hurdles, and become involved in the neighborhood. The ultimate objective should be to honor and value the distinct cultural viewpoints that form local media while making a meaningful contribution to the field.
Reference
Bare, J. (n.d.). Advice and Guidance for International Journalism Trainers. Nieman Foundation. Retrieved November 16, 2023, from https://nieman.harvard.edu/articles/advice-and-guidance-for-international-journalism-trainers/
write