Abstract
This paper deals with the ethical issues associated with the transformation of conventional teaching methods to online teaching through the focal point of Dr. Ramani Modi’s dilemma. Dr. Modi, an eminent college professor, is confronted with the issue of sustaining her welcoming classroom climate and the student value in the online mode. This paper adopts a case study methodology to examine ethics issues, dilemmas encountered, behavior, and leadership theories. Furthermore, it looks into the leadership power element, the process of negotiation, the phenomenon of followership, ethical culture, and the combined effects of scripture and worldviews. This paper looks into general aspects of ethical online leadership and organizational practices.
Introduction
Dr. Ramani Modi, a distinguished college professor admired for her homelike classroom environment, is switching to online teaching. The paper revolves around the ethical aspects of her ethical dilemma. Dr. Modi has to guarantee equity in access to education, maintain academic rigor, and promote a community spirit online. She struggles with enhanced surveillance and privacy issues. Additionally, the digital gap problem appears since all students have different access to technology. Striking this balance, though, while at the same time ensuring student success and involvement, poses ethical dilemmas of significant magnitude. Fairness, integrity, and inclusivity are key values in dealing with this multidimensional challenge.
Ethical Values and Perspectives:
Dr. Modi’s plight rests with the need to uphold ethical values, e.g., respect, fairness, and integrity in the online teaching environment. Student involvement and fostering a friendly learning space are integral ethical considerations in education. With the online educator, students’ various backgrounds become crucial in the online setting, where cultural sensitivities and individual needs vary widely(Manuel & Herron., 2020). Fairness implies that all students have the same chance of participating and doing their best based on their capacity. It does not take into account personal circumstances. Integrity goes beyond to maintain academic standards and honesty in assessments despite the challenges of online learning. Striking a balance amidst these ethical considerations must be objectively assessed and deliberately implemented to create an inclusive, ethical online learning space.
True Ethical Dilemma:
The most important dilemma is to preserve a cordial atmosphere in online classes despite the lack of face-to-face communication. The ethical mandate for students’ learning experiences and the limitation of technological tools must be balanced by Dr. Modi. Here, the approach’s creativity is on designing methods to build connections and engagement virtually. Examples include interactive classes such as breakout rooms, small group discussions, or any other multimedia tool that aids communication(Sperling., 2021). Furthermore, Dr. Modi might consider modifying individualized feedback and support approaches, such as scheduling online office hours or setting up online discussion boards where students can interact freely without any fear. By adjusting her teaching approaches to suit the online environment while maintaining students’ emotional wellness and classroom belonging, Dr. Modi will remain accountable for her ethical obligation to maintain an atmosphere of support and respect in her classes.
Ethical Behaviors and Decision Models:
Dr. Modi needs to come up with pedagogical approaches that have student engagement and respect while disregarding those that could contradict the imperative of disengaging or devaluing literate learners. She can use ethical decision models such as utilitarianism and deontology to consider the impact of her choices. Utilitarianism drives her to think not only about the likes and dislikes of her students but also about their overall happiness and welfare, taking into account the balance of the greatest happiness of the greatest number. Contrary to this, deontology stresses observing moral principles and duties irrespective of consequences. Using such models, Dr. Modi can determine the ethical implications of various teaching approaches and make decisions that, while prioritizing her students’ academic performance, ensure that the students’ well-being is also taken care of in the online learning environment.
Ethical Practices’ Impact:
Proper ethical practices, including transparent communication, individual feedback, and diversified forms of learning, can lead to successful online learning. Thus, disregarding these methods will result in alienation and dissatisfaction among students. Effective communication enables all parties to have clear expectations, thus promoting trust and mutual respect between Dr. Modi and her students. Personalized feedback highlights each student’s individualized strengths and weaknesses, affirming to that person that Dr. Modi will help them grow academically. Inclusive teaching practices cater to different learning styles and backgrounds, building a setting where all students feel appreciated and encouraged. By implementing these ethical considerations, Dr. Modi can develop an active and stimulating online learning community that promotes student success and development.
Power and Influence Manifestation:
Dr. Modi’s prof. The impact can facilitate an online class in a supportive learning environment. However, if exercised unethically, even the powerhouse charismatic teacher can inadvertently hinder the level of participation and self-determination of students. Conscious of her power, Dr. Modi should handle her role cautiously, ensuring that her actions cultivate rather than limit student agency. For ethical leadership, you must create an open discussion and collaboration environment where students hear each other out, embrace divergent views, and take their learning journeys seriously. Through careful use of her influence and fostering a culture of respect and inclusivity, Dr. Modi can make the most of her power as a force for positive change in the virtual school, enhancing the educational experience for all students.
Leadership Theories:
Dr. Modi can employ servant leadership to ensure that students are put first and that a sense of community and respect is nurtured online. This method, rooted in empathy and teamwork, resonates with her ideals of kindness and sincerity. She cultivates a supportive environment and encourages students to grow individually and academically by actively listening and empowering them.
Conflicts and Negotiation:
Online teaching methods should be negotiated with conflicting interests, technologically and pedagogically. Dr. Modi should thus deal with such conflicts in a fair and jointly-decided manner. Transparency means communicating openly with the students even on the difficulties and limitations of studying online. Thus, we establish trust and understanding(Tang et al., 2020). In collaborative decision-making, students are actively engaged in the process, and their thoughts and ideas are listened to as they give input and feedback concerning their needs and preferences. Through transparency and cooperation, Dr. Modi can maneuver the intricacies of online teaching with ethics in mind, searching for resolutions that consider technical restrictions alongside pedagogical aims while preserving moral values and excellence in student performance.
Followership Challenges:
Dr. Modi empathizes with the problems of technical issues and loneliness that occur in online learning. She gives resources like video tutorials and tech help. Dr. Modi creates connections by incorporating engaging activities and facilitating the free flow of ideas. The classroom dynamics engender an inclusive and supportive learning environment by emphasizing the student roles as well-being and engagement.
Ethical Group Danger Signs:
Indicators of unethical group dynamics are, for instance, exclusion or discrimination, which is why it must be dealt with straight away to ensure a respectful learning environment. Dr. Modi should promote inclusivity, and any incidences of unethical conduct within the student body should be addressed through open dialogue, education on diversity and inclusion, and setting out guidelines for respectful interaction and collaboration within the online class. The constituency of this environment creation includes a chance for students to share their concerns about mistreatment or discrimination(Wulandaria & Laksonob., 2020). Dr. Modi can lead discussions on diversity and inclusion-related topics, raising awareness of unconscious biases and building student empathy and understanding. Moreover, she can develop protocols for lodging complaints and resolving conflict, providing a mechanism for all the students to report unethical behavior and seek just settlement. By being proactive in promoting inclusivity and addressing unethical behavior early on, Modi can create a conducive environment that emphasizes diversity and ethical conduct.
Ethical Culture Observations:
Dr. Modi characterizes the ethical tone of the online class as leading through respect, integrity, and accountability. She sets behavioral norms and deals with dilemmas openly, developing student responsibility(Al Halbusi et al., 2021). She fosters critical thinking through ethics discussions to integrate ethics into the learning process, forming an atmosphere of ethical culture and respect.
Scriptural and Worldview Perspectives:
Scriptural and value-based perspectives speak about the underlying values like compassion, justice and humility in their teaching practices. Doctor Modi will get inspiration from these views to apply them when deciding on the ethical issue of online teaching. Adopting such principles into her pedagogical practice will enable Dr. Modi to create an empathetic and enlightened class of students while fostering an understanding of fairness and inclusivity in digital learning.
Conclusion:
In summary, Dr. Ramani Modi’s transition to online teaching holds complex ethical issues requiring careful deliberation of values, behaviors and leadership approaches. Through the answers to the questions faced and the incorporation of ethical principles into her teaching strategies, Dr. Modi can establish a caring and respectful online classroom. The presented case study proves that ethical leadership is crucial in educational dilemmas and brings the notion of continuous reflection and adaptation to changed conditions.
References
Al Halbusi, H., Williams, K. A., Ramayah, T., Aldieri, L., & Vinci, C. P. (2021). Linking ethical leadership and ethical climate to employees’ ethical behavior: the moderating role of person–organization fit. Personnel Review, 50(1), 159-185.https://www.researchgate.net/publication/340297763_Linking_Ethical_Leadership_and_Ethical_Climate_to_Employees’_Ethical_Behavior_The_Moderating_Role_of_Person-Organization_Fit
Manuel, T., & Herron, T. L. (2020). An ethical perspective of business CSR and the COVID-19 pandemic. Society and Business Review, 15(3), 235-253.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9842497/
Sperling, D. (2021). Ethical dilemmas, perceived risk, and motivation among nurses during the COVID-19 pandemic. Nursing ethics, 28(1), 9–22.https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33000673/
Tang, Y., Chen, Y., Hua, Y., & Fu, Y. (2020). Impacts of risk allocation on conflict negotiation costs in construction projects: Does managerial control matter? International Journal of Project Management, 38(3), 188-199.https://www.researchgate.net/publication/340920821_Impacts_of_risk_allocation_on_conflict_negotiation_costs_in_construction_projects_Does_managerial_control_matter
Wulandaria, R. D., & Laksonob, A. D. (2020). Education as a predictor of the knowledge of pregnancy danger signs in Rural Indonesia. Education, 13(1), 10.https://www.researchgate.net/publication/341616956_Education_as_Predictor_of_the_Knowledge_of_Pregnancy_Danger_Signs_in_Rural_Indonesia
write