Introduction
Turkish and Algerian nationalisms arose under the peculiar conditions of the Ottoman Empire and European colonization. The empire of Ottomans was comprised of different ethnicities, creating a polyethnic identity during the Ottoman period. The young Turks notably indicated the collapse of the Empire and gave rise to the emergence of Turkish nationalism, culminating in the formation of the Republic of Turkey in 1923.
The indirect rule and preservation of local customs marked the era of the second Ottoman occupation by Algerian nationals, whose nationalism was uniquely Ottoman. Different challenges emerged during the European colonization era. While Turkey aimed at achieving one Turkish nationality similar to Mustafa Kemal Atatürk, Algeria was fighting for independence from France’s colonization. In addition, Algerian nationalism translated into the war for freedom of the National Liberation Front, ending with the creation of independent Algeria.
The diversity of those ways demonstrates the complicated reactions toward exterior pressures determined by Turkish and Algerian nationalism based on history, culture, and geopolitics. Each stage is distinctively different and thus mirrors the effect of environmental factors on individual nationhood.
Turkish Nationalism
Ottoman Era
During the Ottoman Era, the vast Ottoman Empire comprised different territories and religious groups throughout several continents. However, the Turkish identity could have been stronger because a mixture of different cultures characterized the empire in this period; I cannot say that they contributed much to that society. “Contributed by: Abigail Helen” The Ottomans ruled by creating one united country including various peoples like Turks, Arabs, and “many more
However, the Ottoman Empire peaked in the 16th and 17th centuries under powerful sultans with a unique system that granted some independence to the provinces. The existence of local identities alongside Ottoman identity helped sustain the empire’s stability and strength. The imperial balance showed that the emperor could unify peoples of different cultures in a complex mixture, emphasizing unity rather than singleness based on ethnicity. The Ottoman Era became very important to understanding Turkish identity and how it changed, together with new geopolitics (Arai, 2021).
European Colonization Era
By the twentieth century, the Ottoman Empire started showing signs of falling apart due to territorial loss and internal problems. During this time, Turkish nationalism started to develop, among other things, in the Young Turks movement. The Young Turks supported the idea of a Turkish-oriented policy that sought to safeguard the Turkish heritage and freedom.
Following the Great War (World War I), the Ottomans fell, with Turkey born out of it under Atatürk in 1923. Ataturk brought about drastic changes intended to create a modern and secular Turkish nation that was uniform in culture. The reforms adopted the new alphabet, secularism laws, and Turkism (Öztan, 2020).
In the context of identity, the Ottoman Empire gave way to the Turkish Republic and resulted in a change from diversity based on multi-ethnicity to a relatively homogeneous Turkish nationhood.
Algerian Nationalism
Ottoman Era
Unlike in Turkey, the Ottoman era is regarded as part of Algerian nationalist history. Affiliation of Algeria into the Ottoman Empire beginning in the sixth was more indirect compared to others that faced the imperial dominion having nuanced traits. Despite this, Algeria was controlled indirectly through local beys who represented the Ottomans. Hence, there was a more complicated central rule system. As a result, the impression of Ottoman culture onto Algeria occurred indirectly, through its rulers having remained entirely independent.
Algeria’s population was mainly Berbers, while Arabs comprised a significant percentage during the Ottoman Era. A unique course about the demographic composition and political framework that incorporated indigenous tribal and communal features was developed in this context. In comparison with the areas in the Ottoman Empire that were more centralized, Algeria’s history within the empire established the groundwork for a specific nationalist perception, which later mixed with the challenges of European colonization and resulted in an Algerian national identity that emerged in the later stage (Rosenthal, 2021).
European Colonization Era
During the twentieth century, Algeria transformed from being a province under Ottoman administration to becoming a colony under France. French colonialism reshaped the Algerian population and its politics./ Upon the arrival of French colonists, its settler population grew, thus introducing changes in the demographic balances and significant friction.
Algeria, however, had its kind of nationalism that was born of French colonialism, which suppressed and kept natives in subhuman conditions. During the Algerian War of Independence (1954-1962), the FLN fought against the French colonists. FLN sought for the Algerian state to be autonomous and self-governing without foreign influence (Rosenthal, 2021).
Key Differences
Ottoman Influence
The difference in Turkish and Algerian responses to Ottoman influence provides a foundation for the complex evolution of their distinct national identities. Turkey was under direct rule as a core part of the imperial structure since it was the heartland of the Ottoman Empire. However, while Turkey partly colonized Algeria, it had a relatively de-central nature. Local beys represented the Ottoman authority and exercised a governing system with considerable regional independence. This kind of influence was loose, and consequently, Algeria managed to hold a distinct local culture, both politically and socially, different from most others within the Ottoman Empire (Kayali, 2023).
Nationalist Movements
Their reactions to external pressures and historical events gave their paths a unique twist. In the wake of the empire’s fall, a prominent nationalist movement would inevitably emerge, and it just happened to be Turkeesian nationalism. The empire’s fall created a sense of collectivity among Turks and led to the emergence of the Republic of Turkey in 1923 under Mustapha Kemal Ataturk. The Turkish nationalist movement was meant to establish a modern, secular, and unity-oriented state as opposed to the multi-ethnic nature of the Ottoman Empire.
On the other hand, Algerian nationalism emerged as a direct consequence of the threats posed by French colonization. One of the most notable periods in history experienced by Algeria is the European colonization era, which introduced drastic transformations in population and political aspects. However, Algerian nationalists also gave the FLN freedom to fight for independence. FLN waged a decades-long war with French colonizers, culminating in an independent Algerian state. While Algeria’s quest for autonomy differed from Turkey’s path, it developed from a struggle for liberation against a foreign colonial empire, distinguishing the two cases.
In summary, varying Ottoman influence and the nature of nationalist movements reveal different historical paths taken by Turkey and Algeria. In the meantime, Algeria’s nationalist struggle was inherently connected with the anti-colonial strife, contributing to the formulation of its post-independent identity.
Demographic Changes
Moreover, the demographic dimensions of Turkish and Algerian nationalism illustrate how distinctive these paths were. The ideology of Turkish nationalism that became prominent around the beginning of the twentieth century envisaged a homogeneous Turkish state. The process involved creating one Turkish identity that was linguistically and culturally uniform under the direction of Mustafa Kemal Ataturk. This was a conscious move in an attempt to cultivate national oneness among many ethnicities and cultures that once constituted the Ottoman Empire.
However, the population of Algeria underwent drastic alterations in the course of European colonization. The demographic composition of Algeria was significantly altered by prominent settlers’ settlers brought by French colonization. French colons came and, since then, contributed to the ethnic and cultural change in the Algerians who were marginalized. Algerian nationalists made the presence of settlers their rallying cry; they considered this foreign domination and needed immediate freedom and self-determination (Kayali, 2023).
Independence Movements
These two nations had different challenges toward independence, which can be seen in the paths that led them to freedom. Political and military reforms marked the way for Turkey toward autonomy during the early twentieth century. Ataturk presided over the transformation of a newly established Turkish republic into a modern and independent state while the fall of the Ottomans had transpired.
However, the battle for Algerian Independence was a prolonged and strenuous struggle against the French colonial administration. During the Algerian War of Independence (1954-1962), the National Liberation Front (FLN) fiercely fought against the French forces. The conflict climaxed with the Evian Accords of 1962, resulting in Algeria gaining independence. Interestingly, the Algerian case shows the extent to which any people can resist colonialism, especially when it’s a national liberation war.
Conclusion
This, however, does not mean that the experiences of Turkish and Algerian nationalism were not formed under individual historical conditions. Multi-ethnicity characterized the earliest stages of Turkic identity and the development of Algerian identity that combined localized tribal structures and Ottoman authority. These two countries went separate ways as they transitioned from the Ottoman Empire to the Republic of Turkey and independent Algeria, respectively; while one emerged from falling apart of numerous empires, the other came out of the fight with an external colonizer. The varied characteristics of the Ottoman Empire and French impacted their pathways to Turkish and Algerian nationalism.
References
Arai, M. (2021). Turkish nationalism in the Young Turk era (Vol. 43). Brill.
Kayali, H. (2023). Arabs and Young Turks: Ottomanism, Arabism, and Islamism in the Ottoman Empire, 1908-1918. Univ of California Press.
Öztan, R. H. (2020). Settlement law of 1934: Turkish nationalism in the age of revisionism. Journal of Migration History, 6(1), 82-103.
Rosenthal, M. (2021). Memories of the Algerian War: A Historiography from Independence to the Present.
write