As contemporary landscapes of healthcare delivery attempt to pursue social equity for all citizens, an overview of system-level obstacles in achieving a paramount goal must be undertaken. “Social Justice in Health Systems: A Qualitative Comparative Study” provides the research groundwork necessary to facilitate this critical inquiry. Using qualitative comparative analysis, this peer-reviewed journal article explores and exposes the difficulty registered nurses (RN) have attempting to provide care to the marginalized in Canadian healthcare delivery (Hosseinzadegan et al., 2020). The analysis then moves forward to examine the significance of its scholarly contribution, exploring relevant systems analysis rhetoric: discourse, style and lexis, structure, argumentative importance, and implication.
Stylistic and Lexical Choices
The article uses storytelling to get the reader involved and make it easier to understand the complicated sociopolitical issues inside the medical system. They use evidence and personal stories that give the reader a sense of how important it is to fix the basic nursing structural problems inside the medical system and the bigger issues around it. Storytelling is more of a way to crossover from scholarly writing to real-world application, and, like many times in life, it’s easier to care about it when you hear a personal story. The researchers want readers to think outside of just their academic work and think about the bigger picture.
Argumentative Significance
One of the key ways the article is significant for this field of work is that it looks at the systemic causes that are barring nursing professionals from working towards the advances of social justice in the healthcare system. It uses thematic analysis to come up with these causes. This article is significant in that it breaks down the causes into categories to make it easier to understand. The categories the article has broken down are Lack of Professional autonomy, Revenue generation by the institution as the cornerstone, and Medicine ruling the roost.
The article is also significant for this field of work because once it has used thematic analysis to find these causes, it uses Social Justice and Health Equity as the base on which to break down the topic, and this will help to further my argument on the causes of the problems inner city health care provider needs to address
In addition, the article uses an intermediary way of arguing the point, understood by acknowledging the concerns in both articles but giving out the best reasons why promoting social justice is a very important concept to visitors in a persuasive manner. The article doesn’t present one way of thinking but also acknowledges the different types of patients and concerns there may be for a particular patient. By understanding the perspectives of other nurses, the passage helps us realize that it is not enough to be an advocate. However, through the author’s argument, you can further understand how a patient’s social needs affect their health.
Structure
The paper follows the structure of a qualitative research paper, comprising an introduction with a statement of the problem, objectives, and importance, a literature review, methodology, results, and a conclusion. In the introduction, the researcher uses the methodology to represent the whole research paper as the sum of all other chapters. It is the main part of the whole paper, which is why it has to be per perfect guidelines.
They present each of the categories of systemic barriers in methodical order with another depth of explanation. The participant perspective and the personal answers from the interviewees give deeper meaning to their analysis, give us a break from what is always being said, and teach us about different people.
The article also demonstrates a structured approach similar to critical analysis by using theoretical frameworks and empirical research. The article’s author has structured the empirical research process based on the theoretical frameworks and model of the study. The author has answered all the research questions by applying the empirical research process and utilizing the tied-up research bodies and real-time perspectives (Emerald Publishing, 2022). Using the theories of social justice, nursing ethics, and health policy, the author has built a concrete study framework that has answered the research questions. The authors have been able to argue and counter-argue their study by assimilating different studies that have already been done on the topic. The article has made a theoretical contribution since it has offered a platform for educators, policymakers, and researchers to use in nurse education since it encompasses the whole issue. It has also made an empirical contribution since the research findings can be used in implementation to improve health policy and practice. Though the article has made both empirical and theoretical contributions, it has made a greater theoretical contribution since it can answer all the research questions, and the research questions are based on research frameworks, which are all tied up by research bodies and real-time perspectives.
Connections and Implications
With established facts on the socioeconomic makeup of students enrolled in nursing programs in California, the paper has implications for nursing education, policy making, and practice. The findings call for structural reforms, and advocacy work is crucial to level the playing field in nursing education, increase the nursing workforce, and promote social justice.
In bringing together the key findings from the qualitative and quantitative portions of the study, the article provides a vivid illustration of the human cost of systemic barriers to social justice. By drawing on the voices of the study participants, the article shows how individuals’ experiences can be powerful motivators for change-making.
Conclusion
Conclusively, in order to present its research data and advance its core argument, “Social Justice in Health System: A Qualitative Study” employs rhetorical strategies to its advantage. By carefully considering diction and linguistic choices, rhetorical signification, and logical structure, the article effectively provides key observations into nurses’ difficulties in promoting social justice in the health system. This expanded analysis provides a detailed examination of the rhetorical features present in the article, offering deeper insights into its scholarly contributions and implications for the field of nursing and healthcare.
References
Emerald Publishing. (2022). Conduct empirical research | Emerald Publishing. Www.emeraldgrouppublishing.com. https://www.emeraldgrouppublishing.com/how-to/research-methods/conduct-empirical-research
Hosseinzadegan, F., Jasemi, M., & Habibzadeh, H. (2021). Factors Affecting Nurses’ Impact on Social Justice in the Health System. Nursing ethics, 28(1), 118–130. https://doi.org/10.1177/0969733020948123
write