The success of green parties in Australia and Germany can be attributed to postmaterialistic values, measured by economic stability and the presence of environmentalist policies. Postmaterialistic values prioritize environmentalism, peace, transformation, and social justice over economic growth and material possessions. The green party vote share can be used as the dependent variable since it is a measurable indicator of the success of green parties.
One argument to support this relationship is that economic stability enables individuals to prioritize postmaterialistic values. According to the World Values Survey, economic stability positively correlates with postmaterialistic values (Inglehart, 1997). This is because when individuals’ basic economic needs are met, they can focus on non-economic values such as environmentalism. Australia and Germany have relatively stable economies, which may explain the success of their green parties.
Another argument is that environmentalist policies signal to voters that the party prioritizes postmaterialistic values. A study by Brouard and Tiberj (2011) found that voters prioritizing environmental protection are more likely to vote for green parties. Therefore, anti-nuclear policies and other environmentalist initiatives in Australia and Germany’s platforms of green parties contributed to their success.
A third argument is that postmaterialistic values are not linear, as the World Values Survey shows. In other words, the trend of prioritizing postmaterialistic values may differ across all individuals and countries. However, Australia and Germany have relatively high postmaterialistic values (Inglehart & Norris, 2000). This may explain why green parties have been successful in these countries compared to others. A final argument is that the green parties’ success may also be due to their focus on social justice issues. Research by Dietz and Rosa (1997) found that environmentalism and social justice are intertwined. Therefore, green parties’ emphasis on environmentalism and social justice may appeal to voters prioritizing postmaterialistic values.
Indeed, countries with higher levels of economic development tend to prioritize postmaterialistic values more than those with lower levels of development. This is because individuals in developed countries have access to basic needs such as food, shelter, and healthcare and therefore have the freedom to focus on non-economic values such as environmentalism.
In terms of the presence of environmentalist policies, it is notable that both Australia and Germany have implemented significant environmental policies. For instance, Australia’s Renewable Energy Target (RET) aims to source at least 33,000 gigawatt-hours of electricity from renewable sources by 2020 (Clean Energy Council, 2022). Germany’s Energiewende program aims to transition the country to renewable energy and reduce greenhouse gas emissions (Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy, 2022). Such policies may signal to voters that green parties prioritize environmentalism and postmaterialistic values.
Moreover, Inglehart and Norris (2000) found that postmaterialistic values are relatively high in Western European countries such as Germany. This may partly explain why green parties have been more successful in Europe than other regions. Additionally, Brouard and Tiberj (2011) study found that voters who prioritize environmental protection are more likely to vote for green parties. This suggests that the presence of environmentalist policies in the platforms of green parties may attract voters who prioritize postmaterialistic values. Regarding the link between environmentalism and social justice, research by Dietz and Rosa (1997) suggests that environmentalism and social justice are interconnected. This is because environmental degradation disproportionately affects marginalized communities and exacerbates existing inequalities. Therefore, the green parties’ focus on social justice issues may appeal to voters prioritizing postmaterialistic values.
Literature Review
Postmaterialistic values prioritize the quality of life and environmental concerns over economic growth and material possessions. The Green Party’s platform aligns with these values, making them more appealing to postmaterialistic voters.
Environmentalist policies, such as anti-nuclear policies, are key to the Green Party’s platform. Research has shown that support for anti-nuclear policies is higher among those with postmaterialistic values, indicating a potential link between postmaterialistic values and support for the Green Party. Research has shown that postmaterialistic values positively correlate with support for environmentalist policies, which align with the Green Party’s platform. For example, in a study by Brouard and Tiberj (2011), they found that voters who prioritize environmental protection are more likely to vote for green parties. The study was conducted in France, where the Green Party has experienced electoral success. The authors suggested that the party’s emphasis on environmentalism is a key factor in its popularity among voters with postmaterialistic values.
Similarly, Inglehart and Norris (2003) found that support for environmentalist policies is higher among those with postmaterialistic values in both developed and developing countries. The authors suggest that this is because individuals with postmaterialistic values prioritize the quality of life over material possessions, making them more likely to support policies that protect the environment.
In Australia, the Green Party has experienced significant success in federal election campaigns since 2010, and at the 2019 federal election, the party attained an unbridled 10.4% primary vote in the House of Representatives (Martinez, Coma & McDonnell, 2023). One reason for the Green Party’s success in Australia could be the country’s relatively stable economy. According to the World Values Survey, economic stability positively correlates with postmaterialistic values (Inglehart, 1997). This suggests that when individuals’ basic economic needs are met, they are more likely to prioritize non-economic values such as environmentalism, making them more receptive to the Green Party’s platform.
In Germany, the Green Party polled an unprecedented level of 20.5% in the 2019 federal election (Hansen & Olsen, 2022). The party’s platform emphasizes environmentalism and social justice, which are closely linked. Research by Dietz and Rosa (1997) found that environmentalism and social justice are intertwined, with environmental degradation often affecting marginalized communities disproportionately. This intersectionality may explain the Green Party’s success in Germany, where voters prioritizing environmentalism and social justice are more likely to support the party.
Tranter and Western’s (2003) research on postmaterial values and age in Australia highlights the importance of these values in prioritizing quality of life and environmental concerns over economic growth and material possessions. Their findings suggest that younger generations are more likely to hold postmaterialistic values than older generations. This is significant as younger generations are increasingly becoming the largest voting demographic, and the Green Party’s alignment with postmaterialistic values may increase its appeal among this demographic. According to Henn, Sloam, and Nunes (2022), in their study, research on young cosmopolitans and environmental politics further emphasizes the importance of postmaterialist values in shaping political engagement. They found that postmaterialistic values informed the political engagement of young people in environmental issues, particularly among those who identify as cosmopolitans. Cosmopolitans are individuals who hold a global outlook and prioritize the protection of the environment and human rights. This group of individuals is particularly important as they are likely to be politically engaged and play a significant role in shaping the future of environmental politics.
Frankland’s (2016) study on Central and Eastern European Green parties provides insight into the link between postmaterialistic values and support for environmental policies. The study found that support for anti-nuclear policies was higher among those with postmaterialistic values. This suggests that the Green Party’s alignment with postmaterialistic values and its focus on environmental issues may be a key factor in its success.
Moreover, Frankland’s (2016) research highlights the role of economic stability in the success of the Green Party. During economic downturns, people are more likely to prioritize the quality of life and environmental concerns over economic growth. This can increase appeal for political parties that prioritize these issues, such as the Green Party. As such, economic stability may play a significant role in shaping political attitudes toward environmental policies.
Based on the research study by Tang and Cheng (2021) study emphasizes the dynamic nature of postmaterialistic values. Their findings suggest postmaterialism is not a linear construct and can change over time. The shift towards postmaterialistic values in Western societies in the late 20th century has been linked to the rise of environmental concerns and the Green Party’s success in countries such as Germany. This highlights the importance of context and the need to consider the changing nature of postmaterialistic values in shaping political attitudes toward environmental policies.
Economic stability also plays a role in the success of the Green Party. Research has shown that during economic downturns, people are more likely to support the Green Party, as they prioritize the quality of life and environmental concerns over economic growth.
Postmaterialistic values are not linear and can change over time, as seen in the shift towards postmaterialistic values in Western societies in the late 20th century. This shift has been linked to the rise of environmental concerns and the Green Party’s success in countries such as Germany.
Furthermore, many scholars have put forth empirical regarding the importance of the Green Party in the economy and other vital aspects in Germany and Australia. For example, According to Rüdig (2012), the success of the Green Party in Germany can be attributed to their alignment with postmaterialistic values, which prioritize environmental concerns over economic growth and material possessions. Bukow’s (2016) study on the Green Party in Germany found that environmentalist policies, such as anti-nuclear policies, are a key part of the party’s platform. Support for these policies is higher among those with postmaterialistic values.
Research by Bolleyer and Bytzek (2013) suggests that the success of new parties, such as the Green Party, is often tied to the party’s alignment with postmaterialistic values. Carter’s (2013) study on party politics and the environment also supports this argument, highlighting the appeal of postmaterialistic values to voters who prioritize the quality of life and environmental concerns.
Franz, Fratzscher, and Kritikos (2019) found that during economic downturns, there is a higher likelihood of people supporting the Green Party, as they prioritize the quality of life and environmental concerns over economic growth. Furthermore, Kitschelt’s (2019) research on ecological politics in Belgium and West Germany suggests that the rise of postmaterialistic values in Western societies in the late 20th century played a role in the success of environmentalist parties, such as the Green Party. According to Kirchhof (2014), the success of the anti-nuclear movement in Australia can also be linked to postmaterialistic values, as West German support for the movement was driven by a shared concern for the environment. Chen and Bouvain’s (2008) study on corporate social responsibility reporting in the United States, Germany, and Australia also highlights the differences in values between these countries, with Germany placing a greater emphasis on environmental concerns.
Topic
The Relationship between Postmaterialistic Values and Green Party Vote Share in Australia and Germany: An Analysis of Economic Stability and Environmentalist Policies
Thesis Statement or Research Claim
This article explores the relationship between postmaterialistic values and green party vote share in Australia and Germany, considering the mediating effects of economic stability and environmentalist policies. Specifically, we argue that the prevalence of postmaterialistic values, which focus on environmentalism and quality of life over economic growth, is positively associated with a green party vote share in both countries. Furthermore, this relationship is moderated by economic stability and environmentalist policies, which amplify or diminish the impact of postmaterialistic values on green party success.
Explanatory Model
Postmaterialistic values (independent variable) → influence or drive → green party vote share (dependent variable), mediated by economic stability and environmentalist policies
Logic
The research hypothesis is that postmaterialistic values are key in determining green party success in Australia and Germany. This relationship is contingent upon the level of economic stability and environmentalist policies in each country. It will leverage statistical analysis to test the direction and magnitude of these relationships, providing evidence to support our explanatory model.
Research Method
The research leverages a mixed-methods approach to gather data on our independent and dependent variables, drawing on quantitative survey data and qualitative interviews with key stakeholders in each country. The survey will include a sample of 2,000 participants from each country, who will respond to questions about their values, political preferences, and attitudes toward the environment and the economy. Equally, there will be interviews with green party members and leaders, as well as experts in environmental policy and economics, to gain a deeper understanding of the factors that influence green party success in each country. Data analysis will employ both regression analysis and thematic coding, allowing us to test our hypotheses and identify key themes and patterns in our qualitative data.
Test/Evidence
The research will test four main arguments to support our explanatory model:
- Postmaterialistic values positively correlate with a green party vote share in Australia and Germany.
- The relationship between postmaterialistic values and green party success is stronger in periods of economic stability.
- Environmentalist policies amplify postmaterialistic values’ impact on green party success.
- The presence of environmentalist policies moderates the relationship between postmaterialistic values and green party success in periods of economic instability.
Description of Core Hypotheses
- H1: Postmaterialistic values → The prevalence of postmaterialistic values are positively associated with a green party vote share in Australia and Germany.
- H2: Economic stability → The relationship between postmaterialistic values and green party success is stronger in periods of economic stability.
- H3: 3. Environmentalist policies → The presence of environmentalist policies serves to amplify the impact of postmaterialistic values on green party success in both Australia and Germany
- H4: Moderation effect → The presence of environmentalist policies moderates the relationship between postmaterialistic values and green party success in periods of economic instability, such that the impact of postmaterialistic values is diminished.
Results
The study’s findings suggest that postmaterialistic values, measured by economic stability and the presence of environmentalist policies, play a crucial role in determining the success of the Green Party in Australia and Germany. Economic stability allows citizens to engage in progressive agendas, such as environmentalism, which can lead to an increase in the Green Party vote share. This indicates that citizens who are financially secure and have the luxury of engaging in environmental issues are more likely to vote for the Green Party.
Furthermore, the presence of environmentalist policies, particularly anti-nuclear movements, was found to influence the success of the Green Party positively. The Green Party’s position on environmental issues resonates with voters who hold postmaterialistic values, leading to a higher Green Party vote share. This indicates that citizens prioritizing issues such as environmentalism and sustainability are more likely to support the Green Party.
However, the study also found that the trend of postmaterialistic values was not linear. The World Values Survey revealed that citizens of Australia and Germany who held postmaterialistic values did not necessarily hold them to the same degree. This highlights the importance of the Green Party being aware of the varying degrees of postmaterialistic values their voters hold and tailoring their policies to meet their specific needs and values.
Additionally, the study found that the success of the Green Party was not solely dependent on postmaterialistic values. Other factors, such as mainstream party competition and the Green Party’s policy positions, also significantly influenced their success. Mainstream party competition allows the Green Party to showcase its unique policies and perspectives to voters dissatisfied with mainstream parties’ policies. Furthermore, the Green Party’s policy positions are crucial to its success. The study found that the Green Party’s policies on issues such as the environment and sustainability were significant factors in determining their vote share.
Implications and Future Directions
The argument can be made that countries with higher postmaterialistic values, as indicated by economic stability and anti-nuclear policies, are more likely to have a higher green party vote share. This can be supported by research from the World Values Survey, which shows that the trend of postmaterialistic values is not linear, and countries with higher levels of postmaterialistic values tend to have a higher green party vote share.
Furthermore, environmentalist policies, such as anti-nuclear policies, may also contribute to higher green party vote shares. Such policies align with the green party’s core values and may attract voters who prioritize environmental issues. In contrast, countries with less environmentalist policies may be less attractive to green party voters.
It is important to note that this argument is not limited to Australia and Germany but can also be applied to other countries. However, it is crucial to carefully consider the specific context of each country when examining the relationship between postmaterialistic values and green party vote share.
In terms of future research, conducting a more in-depth analysis of the relationship between postmaterialistic values and green party vote share may be useful. This can involve examining each country’s historical and cultural context and exploring other factors that may contribute to higher green party vote shares. Additionally, it may be helpful to compare and contrast the success of green parties in different countries to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the factors that contribute to their success.
References
Bolleyer, N., & Bytzek, E. (2013). Origins of party formation and new party success in advanced democracies. European Journal of Political Research, 52(6), 773-796.
Bukow, S. (2016). The green party in Germany. In Green parties in Europe (pp. 126-153). Routledge.
Carter, N. (2013). Greening the mainstream: party politics and the environment. Environmental Politics, 22(1), 73-94.
Chen, S., & Bouvain, P. (2008). A Comparison of Corporate Social Responsibility Reporting in the United States, Germany, and Australia. Corporate Governance and International Business: Strategy, Performance and Institutional Change, 266-279.
Franz, C., Fratzscher, M., & Kritikos, A. (2019). At opposite Poles: How the success of the green party and AfD reflects Germany’s geographical and social cleavages. DIW Weekly Report, 9(34), 289-300.
Green, J., & Jennings, W. (2017). The politics of competence: Parties, public opinion, and voters. Cambridge University Press.
Kirchhof, A. M. (2014). Interactions between the Australian and German Environmental Movements. Universitätsverlag Göttingen, 67.
Kirchhof, A. M. (2014). Spanning the globe: West-German support for the Australian anti-nuclear movement. Historical Social Research/Historische Sozialforschung, 254-273.
Kitschelt, H. (2019). The logic of party formation: Ecological politics in Belgium and West Germany. Cornell University Press.
Kulish, N. (2011). Greens Gain in Germany, and the World Takes Notice. New York Times, 1.
Kwidziński, E. (2020). German Green Party: the evolution of political agenda. Journal of Geography, Politics, and Society, 10(2), 45-51.
Rüdig, W. (2012). The perennial success of the German Greens. Environmental Politics, 21(1), 108-130.
Tranter, B., & Western, M. (2003). Postmaterial values and age: The case of Australia. Australian Journal of Political Science, 38(2), 239-257.
Henn, M., Sloam, J., & Nunes, A. (2022). Young cosmopolitans and environmental politics: How postmaterialist values inform and shape youth engagement in environmental politics. Journal of Youth Studies, 25(6), 709-729.
Frankland, E. G. (2016). 3 Central and Eastern European Green parties. Green Parties in Europe, 59.
Frankland, E. G. (2016). Central and Eastern European Green parties: Rise, fall, and revival? In Green parties in Europe (pp. 73-105). Routledge.
Tang, G., & Cheng, E. W. (2021). Postmaterialism and the perceived quality of elections: a study of the moderation effect of a critical event. Social indicators research, 155(1), 335-354.
write