Introduction
The Minister’s Black Veil” is possibly the best example of American Romanticism (Hawthorne, 2021). Composed in the first half of the 19th century, the subject is concentrated on the human condition during communal disintegration in early American society (Obenland, 2021). It involves its accentuated themes of sin, guilt, and shame as well as the universal canon of the human social architecture, all alleviated by scanners against the background of upheaval and transformation in social and cultural frameworks of that dramatic era (Bužonja, 2023), at a kink.
This story also conveys sentimentalism, allowing the character’s emotions and thoughts to develop. The characters in this story are flexible mosaics as they express particular attributes that eventually manifest themselves in similar behaviors to fulfill the role of specific cultural expectations (Méndez & Judith, 2021). In the present article, I plan to analyze how characters, settings, and themes are integrally related to 19th-century social, economic, and cultural values and explore how Hawthorne conveys his views and sentiments to the American audience.
Historical Context and Literary Criticism
While reading ‘The Minister’s Black Veil,’ I feel that before I started reading a story by Hawthorne, I had a scarce perception of what the story would be. If Camus were the citizen planet of our world, Hawthorne would be the citizen of Salem. In 1804, Emerson was born in Salem. Moreover, even though most of his adult life had passed, he finally realized the lost art of homebound dwelling. And what a history. Hawthorne came from the town of Plymouth Rock or Mayflower: his ancestors – self-styled as well as documented – went, well, all the way back to Pilgrims evangelizing Indians; he was ‘of honorable and substantial descent, on both his father’s and mother’s side, as far back as any genealogist has traced the ancestry of modern New-England families’ (Bužonja, 2023). Of all his ancestors – Pilgrims or not – one, the Reverend John Hawthorne of Salem, a relative on his mother’s side, had acquired what might be called the kind of fame, if not notoriety, that the 19th century was home to – a thorough-going Puritan leader of the ‘witch-hunt’ at Salem. The 19th-century world was one, in many ways, a half-transitional world. From country to city, from the old to the ‘new’ – ‘new’ as in the new world. The nation experienced a religious ‘Awakening,’ the boiling over of a rhetorical argument about slavery (Obenland, 2021).
We can see how critics, for example, have often viewed Hawthorne as a ghostly GC presence, as someone ‘relapsing … to the Puritans … by whose sometime ancestor that witch [hangs] in old Salem’, as he put it in the passage closing The Scarlet Letter. A magisterial writer whose fiction, it is said, could and did explore the concerns of guilt, sin, and forgiveness centrally – within the coordinates and calibrations of Puritanical New England. He was preoccupied, as it turns out, among other things, with problems of anxiety about ‘anticipatory human consciousness of – and evasion of – some terrible, evil punishment.’ These tropes are present in all his characters and stories (Méndez & Judith, 2021).
Analysis of “The Minister’s Black Veil”
Puritanical social customs are the primary framework for ‘The Minister’s Black Veil’ (1836), which occurs in a small, tightly bound community of New Englanders (Hawthorne, 2021). In this supposed Puritan town, the members accept the authority of their religious leader – an honest-seeming reverend named Hooper – until one Sunday when he shows up in church wearing a black veil that covers his face. This seemingly arbitrary action shatters the believers of Hooper’s charisma, sending ripples through the community that show them all viewing their reverend in negative and shadowy terms. Each of his parishioners looks at his veiled face and grows fearful, while others piously engage in gossip. They know what they see as inevitably humane and correct – the abandonment or expulsion of those who resist the norms of society.
The veil represents the unspoken sin and shame that Rev Hooper bears, and the town’s bear is also ‘the fellow-pain of all that lived furtive lives, burdened by a culture of unspoken sin and repression.’ ‘In the end,’ The New York Review of Books said of the tale in 2006, ‘it is a story about psychological tension and moral ambiguity. Hawthorne asks his readers not just to feel with their hearts but also to think with their heads. Hawthorne demands this of his readers because he wants to probe the terrain of the human condition: the sin, the wolf, the guilty heart or soul, the wish that death might kiss us and ‘break down his life with his bitter breath’ (Bužonja, 2023).
Social Context
The forces of industrialization and urbanization were already undermining small-town life in the US by the end of the 18th century; evangelical groups were dominating the political landscape and calling for a broader wave of moral self-examination, people’s sexuality was no longer holy, and ordained ministers were preaching about aspects of human depravity from their pulpits and the pages of the popular dailies. Hawthorne’s fiction carries the stench of these unusually impure layers of social history. Hawthorne’s great-great-grandfather had arrived in Massachusetts on the Arbella, one of the flotilla of ships that brought the Puritan colonists to the New World.
The lingering effects of Puritanism still made themselves felt in the US, as Hawthorne knew, and Victorian attitudes to sexual behavior – itself repressive and sentimental in uneasy reaction to the more, not less, repressive behavioral norms from their Puritan forebears – emphasized individual wrongdoing and fostered a fatalistic understanding of men and women. The village where ‘The Minister’s Black Veil’ is set is a small, tightly knit New England community bound by ‘the ever-repressive and ever-repressive regulations of religion and society.’ The Reverend Hooper’s decision to don the veil disturbs this communal being and exposes the fears and hypocrisies of the village inhabitants. In their reactions to the veil, Hawthorne’s villagers attack the insincere social practices that seek to judge others through appearance (Obenland, 2021).
Economic Context
By the 19th century, the US had seen the dramatic expansions of a capitalist economy and rapid and sweeping industrialization in the second half of the century. Capitalism and the rise in class that followed publication became the foundational elements of this century as some got wealthier than ever before, and others suffered under economic disenfranchisement and class inequality (Bužonja, 2023). Hawthorne was of the New England merchant class and experienced the complexities of economic life in the US. However, this suggests that the tale articulates moral and spiritual poverty set adrift in a world of material plenty. To be sure, Hawthorne’s story of the village presents a picture of a community saturated with material goods. However, those people seem deprived spiritually and bound in guilt, shame, and fear. The black veil stands for the moral ambiguity of sin that lurked beneath the surface of the materialism of his society. His depictions of the characters’ struggle with sin and salvation implied moral critique of materialism and complacency in his age(Obenland, 2021).
Cultural Values
Particularly about the secondary world in which ‘Young Goodman Brown’ is set, individualism, self-actualization, and the interrogation of human feeling gained cultural prominence in the 19th century. The Romantic preoccupation with nature, the imagination, and the supernatural offered a counter to the moderate rationalism and empiricism that marked the Enlightenment. That makes Hawthorne a Romantic writer (Bužonja, 2023).
The Black Veil embodies many of the Romantic preoccupations that shape ‘The Minister’s Black Veil’ – the dialectics of good and evil, of the interior and the exterior, and the tension between our spiritual heart of hearts and the human husk of flesh; the capacity of humans for ‘self-veiling’ and for ‘self-deception’ in all its varieties, and again, like so much else in ‘The Minister’s Black Veil,’ it pulls double or triple duties in exploring what in Hawthorne was ‘the projectivity of human subjectivity.’ I counted here two euphemisms: 2 partite symbolisms (religious and ethical) of euphemism.
Endless minor self-deceptions work on this theme, fanning into the osmotic-electric illusion of ‘unconscious’ human nature. How many significant threads, even in a work where parsimony is strategic, are omitted, and how many sympathies correspond to each one that is gauged out of, say, any thousand pages of Plato or any writer of the last two centuries? However, here, for once, the proofs are as sparkling as they could ever be. One of the ironies of all his art is that in believing in the unconscious diversity of what we experience as human nature (which is to take an extreme, radically causally ambiguous view of the determination of the good), Hawthorne had, among the many authors then, and far more of the many operators since, the surest moral sense(Méndez & Judith, 2021).
Reflection and Critique
Hawthorne’s treatment of the Reverend Hooper and the villagers captures our author’s critique of 19th-century society and articulates, explicitly at least, his contempt for the hypocrisy and high morals of the period: ‘Though the polish of an outward reputation covered that matter with a luminous gloss, it got great sins and secret violence to boil up under it.’ Hooper is again the moral conscience of his age, flushed to the surface of the society and given a body, pipe, and all. The villagers’ response to the ‘monstrosity’ of Hooper’s veil speaks to their diminishing small-town minds, fear of things they cannot see, and judging others based on exteriority.
However, his story is equally a cultural critique of 19th-century epistemological and ethical tensions – including the veil’s status as an emblem of existential and moral ambiguity and the gap between individual conscience and social conformity. Hawthorne urges us to think about how to deceive ourselves and close our eyes to moral potential(Obenland, 2021).
Communication of Author’s Opinions
Although its ideological meaning is clear, the complexity of its narrative form, dramatic inflection, symbolic imagery, and characterization belies a naïve statement of fact in the voice of its narrator. It is the basis of Hawthorne’s desire to honor, qualify, and promulgate ideas about morality and philosophy in trenchantly poetic ways. Hooper and the villagers can be said to have attacked the moral inequality and spiritual poverty of Hawthorne’s day, which he regards as induced and condoned by the hypocrisies of his society. Still, he does not attack with any confidence that people can get it right to reason and virtue, dismantling history’s compulsions(Bužonja, 2023).
Conclusion
The Minister’s Black Veil reflectively and satirically engages with the moment’s economic, social, and cultural codes, all through the prism of Puritan values and institutions, especially its grappling with guilt and secrecy and its tender judgments. These are fully apparent in Hawthorne’s characters, as much as his settings and themes. With it, the author explores life and meaning in early 19th-century America that seamlessly integrates the past and the future.
Hawthorne’s earnest lip service to historical detail and willingness to bend accepted history to his literary ends furthered his personal and literary goal of critiquing the age. The emphasis on sin, morality, guilt, and shame in Puritanism created the necessary trappings for Hawthorne to explore how the guilt of individual sins is amplified when brought out in the public light and willfully maintained through society’s willful blindness to others’ sins. Hidden behind his black veil, Reverend Hooper marked his inner sins and his guilt; he, in turn, represented the sins and guilt marked on everyone in such an oppressive society(Méndez & Judith, 2021).
References
Bužonja, M. (2023, November 2). Sensationalism in the Works of Nathaniel Hawthorne. Urn.nsk.hr. https://urn.nsk.hr/urn:nbn:hr:162:397146
Hawthorne, N. (2021). The Minister’s Black Veil Illustrated.
Méndez, D., & Judith, M. (2021). The Puritan Heritage in the Fiction of Nathaniel Hawthorne. Minerva.usc.es. http://hdl.handle.net/10347/27471
Obenland, F. (2021). 18 Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter (1850) and the Historical Imagination in American Romanticism. De Gruyter EBooks, 389–414. https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110592238-019
write