Transformational Leadership is Better than Situational or Transactional
Any association places a strong focus on providing substantial rewards. The leader who moves the staff in this way is the entry point. Depending on the leader’s style, leadership in an organization is normally divided into different categories. Different leadership viewpoints are employed to realize desired goals, but the use of transformational leadership is the key to an association achieving its goals successfully. A leader typically practices authority via the use of influence and power. In any event, the idea behind transformational leadership is to emphasize how to engage with the groups and get them on board with comprehending the leader’s vision. With regard to its impact on employee inspiration and company achievement, the transformational leadership style is, therefore, more viable over the longer run.
It is possible to define transformational leadership as the execution of ground-breaking ideas through the adoption of a more flexible and pervasive approach to influencing and steadily improving those around them (Purwanto et al., 2021, 63). In order to further improve each other’s levels of inspiration, this type of leadership calls for the leader and the employees to work together. Situational and transactional leaders bravely seek to make the team aware of the need for higher thinking and their vision for the future of the company. In any event, transformational leaders typically set a good example for their followers and channel their energy by openly letting them see their thoughts and actions. He also frames his true private convictions to demonstrate to his followers that he possesses these traits. These results can be achieved by transformational leaders having a set of traits and qualities.
Leaders in transformation identify their strengths and unwaveringly maintain their values. They are kept motivated and connected with the group authentically by their confidence in their abilities. They possess high levels of self-assurance that influence the supporters, help them create an internal compass for the organization, and collectively, they steer the association in the right direction (Nawaz & Khan, 2016, 3). Their self-drive helps them visualize themselves as achievers who don’t rely on karma to produce exceptional results. With their understanding of self-improvement, they can influence those around them. As a transformational leader, Richard Branson, the founder, and CEO of Virgin Atlantic makes sure that he transcends the aspects of innovation and inspiration. Through his creative spirit, he comes up with vibrant advertising ideas and innovative methods of attracting people, and he is regarded as a corporate hero. Even after going through multiple failures, he still managed to get up, grabbing the attention of people and ensuring that he overcame the business challenges that come up.in this way, he takes pride in ensuring that his company offers the best value for money for his customers.
The ability to understand everyone around them, especially those under them, is another quality of successful transformative leaders. They will always carefully consider, tenaciously influence, and persuade the team to comprehend the mission and vision of the company, and together they work to achieve those goals because he enables them to recognize their expected value (McCleskey, 2014, 117). This calls for the transformational leader to own the appropriate relational skills to be able to pass off the vision they possess to a cause for attracting the devotion of the followers in order that they, too, are fired up and motivated to bring about the ideal change. Branson also uses an unconventional attitude and informal style of leadership reflected in his affinity for adapting to the times. his motivation is not based on the money, instead being established by the challenge. in this way, he motivates his employees to also get engaged in finding solutions to whatever challenges come up retaining them in the team as they establish themselves within the business. As a transformational leader, he comprehends what he wants to accomplish, and the process of carefully passing along that expectation to the supporters’ calls for a glorified influence that ensures the followers are not shielded from the idea.
To accomplish this, the leader must also be prepared to effectively involve them in exploring the path forward in order to reach the goal. The transformational leader once again offers persuasive inspiration to make a significant distinction for them and energizes their psyches to have the drive to complete the task after they have all understood the proper course of action (Purwanto et al., 2021, 67). The interaction only begins after the transformational leader deliberately develops the staff members’ thinking and influences them for too long before the goal is achieved. Branson always had the vision of transforming people in the business world through his concern or ethics, values, standards, emotions and long-terms goals (Northouse 2016, 161). this is based on his personal philosophy that “Life is short, one has to make the most of it. Do things that you like. If you work and your hobby are the same, you will work long hours because you are motivated” (Kets De Vries, 1998, 9). In this way, he focuses on employee empowerment, using their ideas and allowing them to be creative. This is because the current strategy designed by the transformational leader is to consistently keep the staff focused on the vision, help them adhere to the decided strategy to achieve the vision, and continuously be effectively engaged with influencing an ever-increasing number of associates to support the vision. Here, it is important to make sure that the staff clearly understands the founder’s vision for the association’s future and that they will maintain the course and remain knowledgeable about the mission’s significance for years to come (Nawaz & Khan, 2016, 3). The personnel should be involved in the gig because they understand how important the outcome will be, rather than just going about their assigned duties.
Combining three qualities, the final quality of change leadership necessitates that the transformational leader takes into fresh account perspectives. A transformative leader won’t be afraid to evaluate the organization’s practices and make adjustments without impeding the heart of the organization’s operations. This calls for them to come up with original ideas and creative solutions that support the association’s mission. They are perceived as ignoring the here and now in their pursuit of change and yearning for a better future. The fact that they are open to new ideas and innovations is a factor that supports this. The transformational leader exhorts others to devise novel methods and advancements consistent with realizing the vision (Nawaz & Khan, 2016, 3). They do this to demonstrate that they are keeping up with the times and that they are aware that future challenges will necessitate fresh solutions. As a result, they provide support for ideas and appropriately evaluate the greatest solutions. The third similarity is that the transformational leader assumes their role as the group’s counsel and helper. Here, their responsibility is to guide the entire group through the exercises. This assumes that they are aware that each person has unique strengths and weaknesses in particular areas.
The innovator also considers the individual’s maturity and willingness to adapt to new ideas. The leader can plan the ideal moment for implementing the unique ideas in order to keep the obstruction at a minimum by understanding the preparation levels. The ability to advance and complete another altered association depends on the transformational leader’s influence on the team and ability to nurture them in the areas necessary to complete another association.
In a transactional leadership style, the goals and objectives are predetermined, and the leader uses punishment and rewards to motivate his subordinates. It focuses on elevating the association’s current situation by specifying the ways and managing hierarchical activities (Hansen and Pihl-Thingvad, 2019, 929). This type of leadership is fundamentally necessary for the repair of the current business culture and to enhance current arrangements and procedures. The leader uses his duty and position as his power in this style, and the style has a correct technique (Saeed & Mughal, 2019, 48). Rewards and punishments are employed by different means. For example, on the off chance that an employee completes the task within the required time, he is given motivation for his work, while on the off chance that the undertaking isn’t finished within the required time, he will be punished for something similar. This type of leadership was evident in Bill Gates where he remained a charismatic leader and also followed a strict chain of command. He delegated and guided his employees on what he wanted exactly, highlighting how it could be worked on, and providing very little freedom to them. this establishes control, focusing on completing the tasks at hand and ensuring efficiency by focusing of achieving the targets. as a transactional leader, he also used extrinsic motivators like rewards, gifts and recognition to entice and retain his employees, establishing a system where positive reinforcement ensured better work performance. Instead of using a pragmatic approach o a visionary with long-term goals, he focused on a step-based method of progress toward his vision ignoring the opinions and ideas of employees and other staff members.
The situational leadership idea analyzes what is occurring and modifies an organization’s leadership style in light of the participants and the primary task (Cheong et al., 2019, 36). Paul Hersey and Ken Blanchard developed this theory to help leaders become more effective at making hiring decisions. Bosses use the telling approach to instruct their staff. Using the selling approach, one provides guidance but focuses on persuading representatives to complete the task (Nawaz & Khan, 2016, 2). Building connections is the focus while using the taking, an interesting technique. By using the assigning approach, one enables subordinates to feel a sense of ownership over the tasks while monitoring progress over time. Steve Jobs was famous for using the situational approach, using product launches to excite customers about the new products and also selling his vision to the employees. This became a unique way of employee motivation, enabling the team to pursue their ideas that were internally unpopular even when they eventually became successful in the end. Jobs also had the capability of delegating leadership, hiring the best people in the industry in areas he had no familiarity. He used this method with the hope of creating success even when he had no direct intervention.
Comparing transformational leadership to transactional and situational leadership, the former has proven to be far more persuasive. This is due to the compelling nature’s attempts to encourage both the leader and the devotee to support one another as they work toward realizing a dream and, in turn, forming another association. The benefits of adopting change leadership are evident in the outcomes. At the highest leadership level, change leadership creates influence. Unlike transactional or situational leaders, transformational leaders serve as excellent role models for other association employees, who then follow them and take note of their approach to personnel management. The result is an organization where there is great solidarity between the founder and the workers, which creates a sense of mutual confidence and encourages viable correspondence.
The way the leader radiates charisma and has enthusiasm while carrying out their responsibility is another benefit of transformational leadership (Cheong et al., 2019, 45). The other members of the team can see clearly what the leader desires, so they continue to work toward realizing the dream as well. Because they are inspired by their boss’s genuine desire to elevate the organization to a previously unheard-of level, transformational leaders’ energy is meant to be a big supporter of other staff members’ eagerness to join.
Overall, the ability of the leader to have a vision, the ability to forge a consensus with the members, and the ability to adapt his leadership style so that it may guide the entire group toward the ideal route are what make an organization successful. This is how transformational leadership approaches it: by making the leader plainly comprehend the direction he needs to take the business in, by influencing the workers and making them comprehend how significant the change is, and by bringing them all into action at the same time. In order to achieve a smooth progression of cycles that, over time, provide a strong linkage that communicates in its results and is reliable in achieving the optimal alterations, it brings together the appropriate representatives and thinking processes and moves inspiration and imagination.
Cheong, M., Yammarino, F.J., Dionne, S.D., Spain, S.M. and Tsai, C.Y., 2019. A review of the effectiveness of empowering leadership. The Leadership Quarterly, 30(1), pp.34-58.
Hansen, J.A. and Pihl-Thingvad, S., 2019. Managing employee innovative behaviour through transformational and transactional leadership styles. Public Management Review, 21(6), pp.918-944.
Kets de Vries, M. F. (1998). Charisma in Action: The Transformational Abilities Of Virgin’s Richard Branso And ABB’s Percy Barnevik. Retrieved June 19, 2020, from http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.467.3374&rep=rep1&type=pdf
McCleskey, J. A. (2014). Situational, transformational, and transactional leadership and leadership development. Journal of business studies quarterly, 5(4), 117.
Nawaz, Z. A. K. D. A., & Khan, I. (2016). Leadership theories and styles: A literature review. Leadership, 16(1), 1-7.
Northouse, P. G. (2016). Leadership: theory and practice. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Purwanto, A., Purba, J.T., Bernarto, I. and Sijabat, R., 2021. Effect of transformational leadership, job satisfaction, and organizational commitments on organizational citizenship behavior. Inovbiz: Jurnal Inovasi Bisnis, 9(1), pp.61-69.
Saeed, M., & Mughal, Y. H. (2019). Role of transactional leadership style upon performance: Mediating role of culture. Journal of Managerial Sciences, 13(1), 47-57.