The issue I want to talk about is how poorly domestic abuse victims are protected in Canada. No matter a person’s gender or sexual orientation, domestic violence is defined as any incidence or series of episodes involving controlling, coercive, or threatening behavior, violence, or abuse between people aged 16 or older who are or were intimate partners or close relatives. (Home Office, 2019). Domestic violence is a serious issue, with an estimated 2 million incidents reported in the year ending March 2019 (ONS, 2019). The current legal framework is inadequate in protecting victims of domestic violence. The criminal law offers some protection, but only if the perpetrator commits a criminal offence such as assault or harassment (Law Society, 2020). In addition, civil law offers some protection through injunctions or non-molestation orders, but these are only available to a limited number of victims (Law Society, 2020). Furthermore, the current system is slow and complicated, with victims having to go through multiple steps in order to get the legal protection they need (Law Commission, 2020).
Definition of the issue and problem
Domestic violence is an ongoing problem in Canada, with an estimated 1.3 million women and 695,000 men experiencing domestic abuse in the past year alone. Despite this, victims of domestic violence in Canada often find themselves with inadequate protection and support. This is due to a range of factors, including a lack of awareness of the issue, a lack of resources to support victims, and a lack of understanding of the complexities of domestic violence.
Despite the fact that domestic violence is a crime in Canada, a lack of awareness and understanding can lead to perpetrators not being held accountable for their actions. The police, who are often the first point of contact for victims, often lack the resources to properly investigate cases of domestic violence and to provide victims with adequate protection. This can lead to victims feeling unsupported and that their cases are not taken seriously. Furthermore, a lack of education and awareness of domestic violence can lead to victims being blamed for the abuse they suffer, or feeling that they are unable to access the help and protection they need. Canada also has a range of services available to victims of domestic violence, such as helplines, counselling, and refuges. However, these services are often underfunded and understaffed, meaning that victims may not receive the help they need. Furthermore, many victims feel unable to access these services due to fear, stigma, or a lack of knowledge about available services.
The existing legal landscape
The existing legal landscape on inadequate protection of victims of domestic violence in Canada is extremely concerning. Domestic violence has a serious and devastating impact on victims, but the legal framework in place to protect them is lacking in many areas. The primary legislation on domestic violence is the Domestic Violence, Crime and Victims Act 2004. This act provides victims with access to civil and criminal law remedies such as civil injunctions, non-molestation orders, police protection powers, and prosecution of offenders. However, the legislation has been criticized for its lack of protection for victims, particularly in terms of enforcement and access to justice. The government has recently introduced additional measures to address the inadequate protection of victims of domestic violence, such as the Domestic Abuse Bill, which seeks to provide more protection for victims and to ensure that perpetrators are held accountable for their actions. However, this bill has been met with criticism from various groups, including victims’ rights advocates, as it does not go far enough to ensure adequate protection for victims.
A variety of laws and programs are in place in to combat domestic abuse, such as Clare’s Law and the Domestic Violence Disclosure Scheme. Through this program, people can formally ask the police to provide details about their partner’s history of domestic abuse. The lack of efficacy of this program in providing victims of domestic abuse with proper protection has drawn criticism.
Why is reform needed?
The has a long history of failing to adequately protect victims of domestic violence. Despite years of pledges, legislation and policy changes, the prevalence of domestic violence in Canada remains high. Domestic violence continues to be a major cause of injury and death in Canada, and everyone has a right to be protected from it. In order to ensure that victims of domestic violence are fully protected, it is essential that reform is undertaken.
One of the key problems with the current protection of victims of domestic violence in Canada is that there is a lack of awareness among victims, perpetrators and members of the public. Without an understanding of the signs of domestic violence and the rights of victims, many individuals remain unaware that they are being abused or that they can access help and support. A reform of the education and awareness of domestic violence is therefore needed. This should include providing information about the signs of domestic violence, the rights of victims and the support available.
Another issue is that the current laws and policies relating to domestic violence in Canada are inadequate. For example, the law does not currently recognise economic abuse, psychological abuse or coercive control as forms of domestic violence. This means that victims of these types of abuse are often unable to access the protection and support they need. Therefore, it is essential that the law is updated to recognise these forms of abuse and that existing laws are enforced more effectively. In order to ensure that victims of domestic violence in Canada are adequately protected, it is essential that reform is undertaken. This should include measures to increase public awareness of domestic violence, as well as updating the law to recognise all forms of abuse and ensure that existing laws are enforced. Additionally, resources must be allocated to ensure that victims can access the support they need. Only through these reforms can victims of domestic violence be fully protected in Canada.
Finally, there is a lack of resources available to victims of domestic violence. This includes a lack of specialist domestic violence services, safe housing, legal advice and emotional support. These resources are essential for helping victims to escape from abuse and rebuild their lives. Therefore, a reform of domestic violence services is needed, to ensure that victims have access to the resources they need.
Have there been other attempts at reform? Did this work? Why or why not?
In Canada, there have been initiatives to improve domestic violence victim protection. Two laws that have been implemented to help protect victims are the Domestic Violence, Crime, and Victims Act of 2004 and the Domestic Abuse Act of 2020.
The Domestic Abuse Disclosure Scheme was established by the Domestic Violence, Crime and Victims Act of 2004 to enable persons who face domestic abuse to inquire of the authorities about their spouse’s prior violent behavior. Additionally, it created the Domestic Violence Safety Notices and Domestic Violence Safety Protocols, which are legal procedures that can be utilized to safeguard individuals in urgent circumstances. A new official concept of domestic abuse was adopted by the Domestic Abuse Act of 2020. A modified legal definition of domestic abuse was adopted by the Domestic Abuse Act of 2020, which already encompasses financial and emotional assault in conjunction to sexual and physical abuse. Additionally, it imposes obligations on local governments to offer secure and safe housing for those escaping domestic violence and also measures for law enforcement agencies to act immediately to safeguard individuals.
Despite these reforms, there are still shortcomings in the protection of victims of domestic violence in Canada. For example, survivors of domestic violence may still face difficulties in accessing legal aid and secure accommodation, and victims may still be inadequately supported by the criminal justice system. Additionally, domestic abuse may still go unreported due to the stigma attached to it, and this can make it difficult for victims to access the help that they need.
Overall, while there have been attempts at reform to provide better protection for victims of domestic violence in Canada, there is still room for improvement and more needs to be done to ensure that victims can access the help and support they need. Furthermore, there is still a lack of awareness of the prevalence of domestic violence, which can lead to inadequate support for victims. It is important that the government, law enforcement, and other agencies continue to work to raise awareness of domestic violence and provide support for victims.
What social or cultural factors exist those present challenges or opportunities
In Canada, social and cultural factors present both challenges and opportunities when it comes to inadequate protection of victims of domestic violence. On one hand, Canada has a long history of traditional gender roles, with men expected to be the breadwinners and women expected to stay in the domestic sphere. This can lead to victims feeling powerless and unable to seek help, as well as making it difficult for authorities to take action against perpetrators. On the other hand, Canada has seen a shift in attitudes towards gender over the last few decades, with more recognition of the need for equality and respect between genders. This has led to an increase in awareness of domestic violence, as well as more services being made available to victims. However, there is still a long way to go in order to ensure adequate protection of victims, and further cultural and social change is needed in order to make this happen.
In addition to traditional gender roles, social stigma around domestic violence is another factor that can present challenges to adequate protection of victims. Many victims feel ashamed or embarrassed to come forward and disclose their experiences of abuse, leading to a lack of reporting and difficulty in obtaining sufficient evidence for legal proceedings. This can make it difficult for authorities to intervene and provide the necessary support and protection for victims. Furthermore, the lack of knowledge and understanding about the various forms of domestic violence can mean that victims are not taken seriously or are not believed when they reach out for help.
On the other hand, there have been significant changes in attitudes towards gender and domestic violence in recent years, which have opened up opportunities for better protection of victims. There is now much more awareness of the issue in the public sphere, with a greater understanding of the various forms of abuse and the impact it has on victims. This has led to an increase in the number of services available to victims, as well as more support from authorities. There has also been a move towards more inclusive and supportive policies and legislation, which aim to protect victims and hold perpetrators accountable for their actions.
Evidence-based policy recommendation
My evidence-based policy recommendation is to introduce a series of measures to improve inadequate protection of victims of domestic violence in Canada. First, I recommend that Canada government provide additional funding for domestic violence shelters and services. This will enable victims to access safe, secure and confidential support in a timely manner. Additionally, I recommend that the Canadian government implement policies to improve access to legal aid for victims of domestic violence, making it easier for them to secure legal representation and access justice. Furthermore, I recommend Canadian government introduce mandatory training for police officers and other frontline workers on the identification and response to domestic violence cases. This will ensure that victims receive the appropriate support and protection they need. Finally, I recommend that the Canada government launch an awareness campaign to reduce the stigma surrounding domestic violence and encourage victims to speak out. This will help victims feel empowered to seek help and support, as well as deter perpetrators from engaging in domestic violence.
These measures will help to create a more supportive environment for victims of domestic violence in Canada and will ensure that victims are adequately protected and supported.
In addition to the measures recommended above, I also suggest that Canadian government improve access to mental health services for victims of domestic violence. This will ensure that victims receive appropriate counseling and therapy to cope with their experiences and rebuild their lives. Additionally, I recommend that the Canadian government introduce legislation to strengthen protection orders, providing victims with greater legal rights and recourse in cases of domestic violence. Furthermore, I suggest that the Canadian government introduce specific measures to protect vulnerable victims, such as those with disabilities, and ensure that they have access to the necessary support and protection. Finally, I recommend that the government collaborate with civil society organizations and local authorities to provide victims with access to a range of services and support, such as housing, employment, and financial assistance. These measures are necessary to ensure that victims of domestic violence in Canada are adequately protected and supported.
Finally, domestic violence is complicated and frequently entails a variety of behaviors, including actual assault, sexual assault, mental torture, and economic exploitation. Since of this intricacy, it may be challenging for victims to get the help they need because providers may not even be aware of the entire scope of the assault a sufferer is going through. In order to better protect victims of domestic violence, Canada needs to ensure that all levels of society are aware of the issue and understand the complexities of domestic violence. This includes providing more training and resources to police, increasing public awareness campaigns and education, and ensuring that services are adequately funded and staffed to provide victims with the support they need. The Canadian government also needs to take steps to ensure that victims of domestic violence have legal protection and access to the justice system. This includes ensuring that victims are able to access legal aid and that the criminal justice system is adequately resourced to ensure perpetrators are held accountable for their actions. Furthermore, the government should ensure that victims are aware of their rights and that all levels of society are aware of the signs of domestic violence so that victims are able to get the help they need.
Finally, the government needs to ensure that victims of domestic violence are able to access the services they need, without fear of stigma or judgment. This includes providing more funding for services, such as helplines, counselling, and refuges, so that victims are able to access the help they need. In order to adequately protect victims of domestic violence in Canada, it is essential that all levels of society are aware of the issue and that victims are able to access the help they need. This requires a multi-faceted approach, including increased public awareness, better resourced services, and improved legal protection for victims.
Howells, A. (2020). ” Out with the Old, in with the New”: Are Civil Remedies for Domestic Abuse in Scotland in Need of Reform?. Edinburgh Student L. Rev., 4, 64.
Speed, A., Thomson, C., & Richardson, K. (2020). Stay home, stay safe, save lives? An analysis of the impact of COVID-19 on the ability of victims of gender-based violence to access justice. The Journal of Criminal Law, 84(6), 539-572.
Moreira, D. N., & da Costa, M. P. (2020). The impact of the Covid-19 pandemic in the precipitation of intimate partner violence. International journal of law and psychiatry, 71, 101606.
Huntley, A. L., Potter, L., Williamson, E., Malpass, A., Szilassy, E., & Feder, G. (2019). Help-seeking by male victims of domestic violence and abuse (DVA): a systematic review and qualitative evidence synthesis. BMJ open, 9(6), e021960.
Leitão, R. (2019, June). Anticipating smart home security and privacy threats with survivors of intimate partner abuse. In Proceedings of the 2019 on Designing Interactive Systems Conference (pp. 527-539).
Lorenzetti, L., Wells, L., Logie, C. H., & Callaghan, T. (2017). Understanding and preventing domestic violence in the lives of gender and sexually diverse persons. The Canadian Journal of Human Sexuality, 26(3), 175-185.
McMahon, M., & McGorrery, P. (2016). Criminalising controlling and coercive behaviour: The next step in the prosecution of family violence?. Alternative Law Journal, 41(2), 98-101.
Trevillion, K., Oram, S., Feder, G., & Howard, L. M. (2012). Experiences of domestic violence and mental disorders: a systematic review and meta-analysis. PloS one, 7(12), e51740.
Hester, M. (2011). The three planet model: Towards an understanding of contradictions in approaches to women and children’s safety in contexts of domestic violence. British journal of social work, 41(5), 837-853.
Choudhry, S., & Herring, J. (2006). Righting domestic violence. International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family, 20(1), 95-119.
Hyder, T., & Mac Veigh, J. (2007). Gender-based violence against children in emergencies: Save the Children UK’s response. Gender & Development, 15(1), 81-93.