Abstract
There is a general agreement among historians that Residential Schools were among the shameful phases in North American history because extending over many years. These schools had some extremely severe conditions under which kids were separated from their relatives into the education system, where all their cultural hand-downs and principles were ruined for good. Instead, they became those lost ‘Indians’ who hardly knew about their native background. This proposition can be devoted to the examination of the Residential Schools operation’s long-term effect, mainly based on children’s experiences and passed-on intergenerational trauma to their community. With primary and secondary materials such as natives’ eyewitness accounts, diaries, books, academic journals, and media sources, this paper aims to highlight how Indigenous peoples were mal-treated and the significance of getting knowledge from that history.
The goals of this study have evolved from different aspects. First, the essay will discuss the historical background of residential schools and their emergence, giving an understanding of what led to their motivation. Following on, the paper examines the policies and practices of the US and Canadian governments depicted in the era when Native children were forced to be taken away from their homes and families. On the other hand, it will also explore the background of Residential Schools and look into the documentation of numerous cases of maltreatment, negligence, and destruction of Indigenous cultures. The latter section will also examine examples of resistance and suffering by Indigenous students. At the same time, they were in these institutions, as well as the tragic deaths of young Indigenous people in these schools, including the discovery of recent mass graves and the current efforts to face up to these horrors of the past. Ultimately, the research strives to measure the historical and social wounding that continued for Indigenous communities due to Residential Schools. This shows how the consequences of these schools do not happen only for the present generation but last for generations.
The technique will focus on interdisciplinary sources, with primary and secondary sources used to provide a detailed reconstruction of the history of residential schools and their impact on Native peoples. Incorporating survivor testimonies and newspaper articles will also give readers an idea about the exact procedures of implementing and running Residential Schools in addition to particular instances of abuse and betrayal. The secondary data from this type of literature, including academic journals, magazines, books, and media, will form a framework that will superimpose historical context and an independent review of residential schools and their repercussions. In addition, the article will disclose possible effects that could be more apparent even though they are intricate by utilizing the qualitative research methodology. By doing so, it, on the one hand, educates and establishes the existing injustices and, on the other, generates empathy and accountability for the injustices in modern society.
Finally, this research paper aims to record the row of injustices that Indigenous children and their villages had to face in Residential Schools and raise questions about colonialism, cultural extinction, and reconciliation in the modern era. It puts the accent on acknowledging historical trauma and struggling for justice and recovery of all the persons who were hurt in the boarding schools and their descendants. Lastly, the paper strives to expand the knowledge of Native people’s injustice and provokes an understanding that is compassionate, empathetic, and engaged in the aftermath of Residential Schools.
Introduction
The narrative of Indigenous American history by residential schools has expanded with time, and it is because researchers employed different perspectives and methods. The 1800s-1900s were a pivotal epoch in American history when Native Americans faced hardships. The school building plan for the Native Americans in both the United States and Canada during the turbulent period was one of the most atrocious effects of that period. These organizations were a central part of the more extensive strategy of forced assimilation, which attempted to get rid of the Indigenous languages, cultures, and customs. Residential schools were established by the government, and they have broken the spirit of the Indigenous people since the beginning of time.
Our study will consider the very complicated and complex period in Native American history, which is the vicious period, through a systematic historiography. Rather than simply narrating the historical events, the aim here is to explore the essence of the human perspective in the residential schools. Furthermore, historiography entails an investigation of historians’ views of this period and how it was represented. This involves addressing the intricacies and tinges of understanding the residential school’s effect on the First Nations communities. This research is to be carried out by critically analyzing the wide range of primary sources, academic journals, and oral narratives, which are expected to bring new insights into the tales.
On the other hand, the study is based on an Indigenous person’s worldview, the psychological, social, and mental effects that are continually passed down from generation to generation. This research seeks to provide substantial enlightenment on the colonial strategies’ long-term outcomes by analyzing the trauma caused by residential schools and its never-ending effect.
In addition, this research is intensely involved in the historiographical landscape by looking into the numerous approaches and perspectives that have rendered the discourse on residential schools fluid and dynamic. This paper seeks to unravel the mysteries of historical research by exploring the intricacies of multiple perspectives. This will be an in-depth study of the possibilities and limitations it offers.
Historical Context: Origins and Development of Residential Schools
The foundation and the evolution of an Indian boarding school for Native American children in North America started with colonial history and the assimilationist rules of the European colonists. As for historical research, the story of residential schools emerges from the background of laws and ideas and the political landscape of Canada at the end of the nineteenth century and the early twentieth century. The creation and progress of these schools ran through several decades, showing a multidimensional relationship of religious, political, and cultural tendencies.
Accordingly, the latter 19th and early 20th centuries became a tumultuous time of social and political change driven by rapid industrialization, western expansion, and new economic circumstances. The transformation policies carried out by the European settlers extended all over North America, and government policies equally challenged the Indian issues by embracing assimilation. Additionally, socio-political forces merged with traditional race systems, creating a suitable ground for assimilationist policies. The schooling system was the most noticeable. Such an ideology stimulated the Adoption of acts such as the Dawes Act in the United States and the Indian Act in Canada, which were enormously driven by the race-based ethnocentrism of that time.
These policies, purported as “civilizing” efforts, aimed to practically uproot the Indigenous traditions and methods, giving rise to the assimilationist ideology that was embraced by the residential schools institution. “Government officials hoped that the efficient evangelical Indian service would successfully “civilize” the Native population before it completely disappeared under the push of white settlement.” In his “Kill the Indian in him, and save the man” speech, Richard Henry Pratt – a wealthy but assimilations advocate of the Native Americans in the late 19th and early 20th century – came up with this phrase. In the sixties, the Comanches, whom I visited frequently, persevered with the man wearing the civilized clothes, drank the beverage out of a cup, and knew some English. He was enterprising and earned more money than his tribe. For instance, his recognition by whites and blacks was equally noteworthy. Unlike the latter, in the former, the Pratt method, a frame of the ‘Proceedings of the National Conference of Charities and Correction,’ is one where assimilationist goals are the focus. He has endorsed the assimilation of such Western values as dress and language, as well as the denying Indian identity to the natives via education. Thus, he questioned the setting up of the Carlisle Indian Industrial School in 1879.
Worst of all, assimilationist policies were a likely outcome of this concentration. In the mid-nineteenth century, there was the creation of residential schools under the joint forces of the Canadian and US governments and religious denominations, who sought to consolidate their mechanism of assimilating Indigenous children in such centres. Furthermore, they thought civilizing missions had a place in their work among the children removed from their communities and culture as deemed proper for their moral and cultural education.
Indigenous Experiences within Residential Schools: Navigating Trauma and Resistance
Abuse in the residential schools brought talks and stories that became widely known. Yet, as cultures, they also developed numerous acts of revolt, bravery, and cultural survival. In this chapter, the author suggests a complicated connection between medium cultural resilience and the oppression of the Indigenous kids and family members who suffered the worst of the residential schools. It can accomplish that task by unearthing the fine details of suffering and endurance through the annals of time.
3.1 Analyzing Lived Experience
Scholars conducted a comprehensive investigation of the experiences and their families in residential schools, enabling them to understand the magnitude of the damage done to them. The researchers will probe in detail the eyewitness reports, letters, and official government records since they are the tools that will be used to reconstruct the daily life of the Native American students. The cultural domination was an evident fact, seeing that the native culture, language, and religion were subjugated, hence the loss of their identity. Aside from that, it was an effort to force the integration through dressing, styling hair, and religious teachings, which offended most students’ outlook against their will. Aside from that, it was physical and emotional abuse, during which most of the native children were tormented physically and emotionally. In a similar situation, some students were split from their family groups, and this consequently caused them to be very sad and lonely. To continue, the schools were overcrowded with a lack of resources, resulting in poor hygiene and the inability to have appropriate facilities that affect one’s physical health.
However, along with the residential schools came the eradication of the Indigenous languages, which in no way helped the student to understand and speak their language, which was detrimental to the whole generation in the long run. Moreover, cultural detachment was a result of attendance at the residential schools because the children were deprived of the chance to get involved and learn the traditional cultural practices, thereby cutting them off from their cultural heritage. Indirectly, the residential schools also confronted cultural disruptions since the parents whose schools were attended found it challenging to pass on the culture simply because their families were disorganized.
3.2 Resistance Strategies and Cultural Preservation
In the face of the inhuman act of residential schools, people started to oppose it as a sign of hope and cultural preservation. Indigenous individuals and communities demonstrated incredible resilience and survived by inventing numerous cultural preservation methods. Despite all the rules, some Indigenous children were involved in secretive traditional ways, which they did at their peril. They thrust their oral traditions and secret ceremonies, which led to the ancestral knowledge being acts of rebellion against the forced cultural integration. Historiographical surveys of these resistance ventures explicitly demonstrate the sovereignty of the Native people in maintaining their languages, culture, and spirituality. Through these acts of cultural preservation, the researchers add to the narrative, which underlines the indomitable spirit that withstands the sanctuaries of the most oppressive environments.
By combining the roles of the historical strings, researchers produce the idea that the Indigenous residential school experience is complex and has multidimensional features. The cultural resilience, the survival after the tragedy, and the indigenous people and their communities are some of the issues that historiographical research contributes to the joint understanding of this period through the analysis. The scholars analyzed the cultural revitalization of the residential school system; from that, Indigenous communities got the chance of the cultural rebirth of their artistic practices, languages, and traditional knowledge. While doing this research, historians have been the ones to give credence to the existence of agency and cultural resilience of the indigenous people who would not be eliminated even with all the effort to do the unthinkable.
Comparative Analysis: Residential Schools Across Indigenous Nations
4.1 Policies and Practices of Residential Schools
Residential schools set the stage for many controversial policies and practices. Residential schools aim to make children a part of only one culture. Nevertheless, the rules and practices of residential schools were widely different from one First Nations culture to another and their location. To Indianize the Indigenous kids, the Indian Act of 1876 in Canada, among other things, called for the establishment of residential schools where kids were forcefully taken from their homes. Similarly, the American practice of forcible removal was a catalyst of the Stolen Generations, which likewise disrupted the life and traditions of the Indigenous kids. Unlike the case with the Indian mission schools in the USA, where cultural assimilation was encouraged but enforcement was not stringent, there was no specific regulation to enforce the instructions. The research on these statuses shows that there were a lot of different methods of cultural repressions and levels altering the lives of Indian groups.
4.2 Impacts on Indigenous Cultures, Languages, and Social Structures
The schools of residence, however, affected the cultures, languages, and social structures of the First Nations so deeply and destructively that the damage was both irreversible and catastrophic. The methods and the practices of residential schooling for the Indigenous children who were made to adopt a non-Indigenous culture had an impact on the social and political life of the Indigenous societies until today. Everything that represents them is being lost; this includes their languages, customs, traditions, and other self-knowledge because when they migrate to other countries, they are separated from their families and communities. A situation would arise where children were disallowed from using their cultural languages and indulging in their traditions, and consequently, cultural self-identification would weaken. Such cultural changes still have an impact on Indigenous clan societies and undermine their feeling of continuation and identity. Besides, intergenerational trauma resulting from social structures disintegrating, leading to poor relationships between people and a culture of individualism within communities.
Also, Indian residential schools, in their harsh and traumatic form, negatively influenced the lives of the children under strict regimes, physical abuse, and cultural and language censorship. Most of the Indigenous survivors, as well as their descendants, experienced different kinds of severe mental illnesses such as depression, anxiety, and posttraumatic stress disorder, which was an unfortunate pain for the community. Conversely, a significant number of the Indigenous students in this education system were unable to overcome the educational gaps imposed upon them by the system. It limited their chances for higher education, putting them among those with socio-economic differences. In addition, those schools resulted in restorative measures adopted as a reaction to the influence of residential schools on Indigenous language, culture, and traditions. Although many challenges have been successfully tackled through this carefully designed journey, the mission of cultural revival is ongoing.
4.3. Local Quantum Factors of Government Regulation
Residential school policies enacted by the governments differed in nature and extent according to the locality and heritage of the concerned regions. Indigenous peoples were initially offered an apology and an effort to rebuild and improve the situation, which the settlers were accountable for by setting up the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) with the role of dealing with the aftermath of residential schools. In the first place, the US enacted the Indian Self-determination and Education Assistance Act that gave the tribes authority over the educational systems they had. This act is one of the leading causes of their culture’s growth and revival. These geographical features highlight the level of forgiveness important in understanding the injustices done and putting the rightful remedies for reconciliation and restoration in place.
Historiographical Debates and Methodological Approaches: Decomposing Residential School Researching Tangles
Historians have and continue to fiercely dispute the studying of residential schools, with different approaches to the whole subject. This part offers a critical analysis of the changing dialogue, interpretative inconsistencies, and methodological complexities of the research on this unfortunate event.
5.1. Historiographical Debates and Interpretations
Various historiographical disputes involving residential schools are central in the scholarly realm. These controversies cover a range of contrasting views and versions, signifying the intricate nature of the topic itself. The questions of responsibility and independence and the ambiguous issues of people and institutions entangled with the residential school system proved challenging for historians. Some researchers believe that to maintain moral principles, governments and religious institutions must be rules, while others disagree and consider the activities according to their historical importance. These discussions reveal the highly intricate and complicated moral, ethical, and historical territory that researchers researching the outcomes of residential schooling need to navigate.
5.2. Methodological Approaches and Critiques
A broad scope of the analysis is reflected in the methods archaeologists and academicians used to learn about the residential school period. So, historians have analyzed official papers, personal accounts, archive materials, and oral narratives to develop a complete picture of the events. Indigenous viewpoints and experiences have been widely documented through oral histories in general. However, these strategies are open to some criticism since researchers deal with such problems as the bias of the data, the lack of sources, and the ethics of portraying war-time trauma. Selecting the sources, the point of view and relying on survivor testimonies are among the methodological features that the historiography field has been controversial about..
5.3. Limitations and Biases in Sources
The limitations and biases of historical research on residential schools, in turn, can be explained by various parameters related to the nature of historical evidence, the standpoint of researchers, and the challenges connected with access to the correct information. A thorough assessment of the biases and constraints in the sources used in the analysis of residential schools is a fundamental part of the historiographical analysis. On the one hand, historical documents can only encompass a truly general representation of the event if historical documents are what we call the narrative of the people in power. The biases and restrictions, if not corrected in writing, often present a problematic situation for historians because they may lack the necessary information to put together the diverse realities of the Indigenous people; historiographical analysis explores problematic interpretive issues these materials reveal, questioning their significance in historical narratives..
In addition, disputes, methods, and the inherent prejudice of sources are further ingrained in this historiographical inquiry’s multidimensional discussion of residential schools, which generated a comprehensive debate. With this, researchers can create a deeper understanding of this troubled past, for there are many different ways it can be interpreted and the ethical issues therein. Historians are deliberately attempting to cope with the problem of depicting trauma and telling various stories of the people who were affected by residential schools by considering different strategies and what they can use. The historiographical analysis in this part of the work is focused on how vital analysis, reflection, and critical thinking are to unravel residential school studies’ complicated web.
In the historic writing, the researchers had to deal with the issue of information control. The government could also control the historical documents connected with the residential schools, which could result in some information being unavailable. The one-sided official governmental reports can leave some factors of the residential school system unaccounted for. The historical writing also reflected the semblance of survivors’ testimony, subject to forgetting, trauma, and time lag. The limitation can be the outcome of separate perspectives of students, which in turn can miss the overall picture of the residential schools. Lastly, the historians were up against an obstacle of understated historical records for the reasons of misreading the effects of residential schools on the Indigenous communities.
Conclusion
Through this scholarly investigation into the Indigenous American history surrounding the residential schools, it becomes clear that an intricate tapestry of historical narratives, views, and continuing impacts is revealed. Besides the above, this historiography parrots the varying approaches to interpreting residential schools in the bigger picture of the entire Indigenous experience at that time. It has covered this era from its deepest point, unravelling unbelievable difficulties, resilience, and cultural survival. Indigenous peoples continue to grapple with the aftermath of the residential school experience, which is manifested in today’s reality.
First, in the residential school system, the Indigenous people were denied vital aspects of their identities, culturally grounded traditions, and mother tongue. The deliberate elimination of native cultures is much more than just the opinion of the failure of a one-generation plan to produce a homogenous American-European identity. But, the light appears amid this darkness when resistance stories are told; Indigenous people of that time have proved their skills and refusal to store the culture and tradition until they have been able to divine them as it has always been done, even in the face of hardships and trials. These stories are, therefore, symbolic of the human condition, where humanity prevails even in brutal and terrifying memories, and they are also emblems of the Indigenous tribes.
Secondly, the intergenerational nature of the trauma embodied by the residential school system demonstrates the profound effect of the historical trauma on people not only in their personal lives but also in their family lives and those of the communities to which they belong. Indigenous peoples are still being defined by the scars borne by their ancestors – mental and spiritual ones – from these times. It, therefore, becomes apparent that as a nation, we must take a step to acknowledge our past so that healing can begin. The historiographical study revealed the issues’ existing debates and layered or multidimensional natures. While some schools pay attention to the processes of Indigenous communities that bypass many challenges engendered by residential schools, others dwell on structural injustices that shaped the future of cultural identity and language.
Lastly, the topic is related to the hurdles of researching residential schools, which has also been shown by this historiography. Highly complicated conversations, problematic methodologies, and moral questions are its reputations. Historical source accessibility is a complex problem for historians and academics since these scholars are conscious of the prejudices and omissions that dominate historical records. Accordingly, joint research projects with Indigenous scholars and communities, through which the outlook and role of community members in creating their histories that look at the contribution of residential schools to the multi-generational experiences of Indigenous nations, would be more inclusive. However, the structural basis of this faulty historical knowledge is the need for continuous excavation of these stories and the refusal to express these voices, which have been suppressed for years..
Indeed, in the present and the future, historiographical analysis and discourse shall continue to create a place that expects hearings and registering of Indigenous people’s stories of historical trauma. This stance provides a valuable addition to the dialogue of colonial impacts on Indigenous peoples and the ongoing reconciliatory measures, as well as a healing process that has to be continued for a long time. Through all these, this type of historiography is a necessary lesson that history should be addressed without hushing the wrongs of the past. Therefore, the truth should prevail for a better and fairer world.
Bibliography
“Kill the Indian, Save the Man” – Carlisle Boarding School – Extra History.” Extra History. June 3, 2022. Video. https://youtu.be/fbRBNSjT_FQ?si=7XV3MHgPp0Zg7cb _
“Native American Boarding g School Survivors Share Their Stories.” MSNBC. August 24, 2021. Video, https://youtu.be/Kfpz8Jn8ZQM?si=TDzP0cnioDtVmUg_
“Residential School Survivor: ‘I Grew up Hating the Colour of My Skin.’.” CBC News. March 23, 2018. Video, https://youtu.be/j2ITeM8D93Y?si=hScN5xo_W-I8dbz3.
(Date accessed: October 10, 2023).
‘Kill the Indian in him, and save the man’: R. H. Pratt on the education of Native Americans (no date) ‘Kill the Indian in him, and save the man’: R. H. Pratt on the Education of Native Americans | Carlisle Indian School Digital Resource Center. Available at: https://carlisleindian.dickinson.edu/teach/kill-indian-him-and-save-man-r-h-pratt-education-native-americans
Adams, David Wallace. Education for Extinction: American Indian and the Boarding School
Dunbar-Ortiz, Roxanne, Jean Mendoza, and Debbie Reese. 2013. An Indigenous Peoples’ History of the United States. Beacon Press.
Experience, 1875-1928. Lawrence: University Press of Kansas, 1995.
Government of Canada; Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada; (2010) Statement of apology to former students of Indian Residential Schools, Government of Canada; Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada; Available at: https://www.rcaanc-cirnac.gc.ca/eng/1100100015644/1571589171655
Hoxie, Frederick E., A Final Promise: The Campaign to Assimilate the Indians, 1880-1920. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 1984.
Hoxie, Frederick E., ed. Talking Back to Civilization: Indian Voices in the Progressive Era. Bedford/St. Martins, 2001. https://doi.org/10.1080/03612759.1996.9952481
Lomawaima, K. Tsianina. 1994. They Called It Prairie Light: The Story of Chilocco Indian School—University of Nebraska Press.
Lookingbill, Brad D., War Dance at Fort Marion: Plains Indian War Prisoners. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 2006. https://doi.org/10.2307/25094673
MacDonald, David. “First Nations, Residential Schools, and the Americanization of the Holocaust: Rewriting Indigenous History in the United States and Canada.” Canadian Journal of Political Science / Revue Canadienne de Science Politique 40, no. 4 (2007): 995–1015. http://www.jstor.org/stable/25166181. DOI: 10.1017/S0008423907071107.
Stolen Children | Residential School Survivors Speak Out.” CBC News: The National. June 2, 2015. Video: https://youtu.be/vdR9HcmiXLA?si=2Lf8tLWxG1nGRl1x.
The Quarterly Journal of the Society of American Indians January-April 1913: Vol 1 ISS 1 : Free Download, borrow, and streaming (no date) Internet Archive. Available at: https://archive.org/details/sim_american-indian-magazine_january-april-1913_1_1
write