Introduction
The term renaissance is derived from French and means “rebirth” or “revival.” It refers to a period of revival in art and literature that birthed classical models. According to Bentley (2014), the Renaissance is “…a round of intellectual and artistic creativity” (p.463). The City of Florence was pivotal in spreading the Renaissance to other regions. Remarkable cultural and intellectual transformations characterized Renaissance. The essay discusses Renaissance in Florence and how it shaped the Renaissance in Italy, China and Europe during the postclassical era. While there exist similarities in the renaissances, there are distinct disparities due to geographical, cultural, humanistic, and philosophical differences.
The Italian Renaissance in Florence was characterized by remarkable development and improvement in art, science and architecture (Crowell, N. (n.d.). Significant improvement in art forms such as painting, sculpture, architecture, and literature began here. Similarly, the Chinese Renaissance was marked by a remarkable artistic transformation in painting, printing and landscape painting, emphasizing elegance and emotional expression (Hearn, 2008). The Florence Renaissance highlighted scientific and technological expansion with important inventions in anatomy and engineering. Florence is considered the cradleland of humanism., and the birthplace of the Renaissance. The city is home to artistic and architectural artefacts developed in Middle Ages and later in the 15th and 16th centuries under the Medici family (Crowell, N. (n.d.). Renowned Florentine painters and architects include Giotto, Brunelleschi, Botticelli, Michelangelo, Arnolfo, and Andrea Pisano. Furthermore, Artists include Brunelleschi, Donatello and Masaccio and the Founders of the Italian Renaissance like Botticelli, Leonardo da Vinci and Fillipo Lippia, among others. In particular, Leonardo da Vinci doubled as an architect, painter and scientist credited for his paintings like the Mona Lisa and The Last Supper.
Numerous scientific and philosophical contributions to the field of knowledge also characterize the Florentine Renaissance. Influential philosophers that emerged from Florence include Niccolò Machiavelli, whose political philosophies in The Prince and Discourses on Livy still influence modern-day political thinking and ideology. In East Asia, The Chinese Renaissance experienced significant scientific and technological expansion. Under the Tang dynasty, remarkable inventions such as printing, metallurgy, and medicine were made (Hearn, 2008). Still, significant innovations such as gunpowder, magnetic compass, and printing emerged from the Chinese Renaissance.
Centralized imperial rule characterized the Chinese Renaissance (Hearn, 2008). The Tang Dynasty encouraged urbanization, trade, and commerce. Furthermore, the dynasty encouraged scholarship and cultural restoration. Both Florentine, the Chinese and European Renaissance emphasized intellectual transformation and expansion of classical and scientific knowledge. Postclassical Europe underscored advancement in art, science, and technology (Art in Context, 2021). These Renaissance movements birthed new understanding and artistic expression.
The Florentine Renaissance happened between the fourteenth and sixteenth centuries and emphasized cultural transformation. On the other hand, the Chinese Renaissance occurred between 618-907 CE and 581-618 under Sui and 960-1279 under Song. In Europe, the postclassical era occurred between the fourteenth and seventeenth centuries and similarly characterized intellectual and artistic transformations (Bentley, 2014). The Florentine Renaissance, however, underscored a renewed focus on Roman art and classical Greek philosophy. The city emerged as an artistic and intellectual centre of innovation. The Chinese Renaissance experienced remarkable expansion and improvement in various art forms, science, and technology (Department of Asian Art, 2004). Under the imperial reign of Tang, Sui, and Song, Confucianism emerged with a strong emphasis on meritocracy and knowledge expansion. In Europe, cultural and intellectual shifts marked the postclassical era, similarly emphasizing classical knowledge, scientific invention, and artistic expression (Art in Context, 2021).
The City of Florence was the epicentre of artistic and architectural transformation. Major Architectural contributions include structures like the Florence Cathedral and Palazzo Medici. On the hand, the Chinese Renaissance emphasized attention to detail, Landscape painting, calligraphy, and ceramics (Delbanco, 2008). The Chinese architectural monuments like the Grand Canal and the Great Wall emerged during the Renaissance. In Europe, Art and architecture experienced marked expansion characterized by numerous inventions such as using perspectives in art, architecture and painting. Popular works of art include Leonarda Vincis Last Supper and architectural landmarks such as Saint Peters’s Basilica (Art in Context, 2021).
The Renaissance in Florence profoundly impacted the artistic transformation in postclassical Europe. Developments in philosophy and literature paved the way for the emergence of humanists and cultural exchanges. (Greatest Renaissance Paintings, n.d). On the contrary, the Chinese Renaissance accelerated the expansion of Confucianism and Buddhism, which remarkably impacted all facets of Chinese society. In Europe, the postclassical era witnessed the expansion of knowledge and the emergence of humanists. Scientific inventions, philosophies, and artistic styles shaped socio-political transformation. There was an Emphasis on classical knowledge and artistic expression in Europe. However, the Chinese Renaissance exhibited marked differences influenced by Confucian doctrine and cultural transformation (Delbanco, 2008). Wealthy individuals patronized artistic and intellectual endeavours, thereby facilitating artistic advancement.
China played a crucial role in the Renaissance movement. According to Bentley (2014), “The revival of centralized imperial rule in China had profound implication for all of the East Asia..” (p.287). Emphasis on classical knowledge epitomized the Chinese Renaissance under the Song, Sui, and Tang dynasties. However, unlike the Italian Renaissance, the Chinese Renaissance underscored Confucianism, a philosophical system that largely influenced every facet of the Chinese socio-political system. Similarly, the Italian and Florentine Renaissance focused on classical knowledge and humanistic approaches. The movement comprised artists, poets, philosophers, and intellectuals who sought to follow in the footsteps of their ancient Greece and Roman counterparts (Renaissance Art Characteristics, n.d). These philosophers and artists emphasized humanism and individualism like their Greek and Roman counterparts. What cuts across the Renaissance movements is renewed emphasis on classical knowledge acquisition and cultural resuscitation.
The Renaissance revived interest in artistic accomplishment and meritocracy. It sought to expand and build on the accomplishments of the classical era while emulating the Greek and Roman Philosophers and humanists (Renaissance Art Characteristics, n.d).In particular, the Italian Renaissance in Florence triggered a renewed interest in studying classical works by Ancient Greek Philosophers like Plato and Aristotle. There was also renewed interest in humanities (Delbanco, 2008). Humanists like Petrarch and Pico della Mirandola underscored the significance of studying Greek classics.
While European artists and architects studied ancient Roman and Greek sculptures and architecture, their Chinese counterparts studied ancient Confucian texts, Taoism and Buddhism (Delbanco, 2008). Unlike their European counterparts, they emphasized the interpretation of Confucius’s classics. Similarly, the Chinese Calligraphers and poets were inspired by the achievements of their Greek counterparts. European philosophers, scholars, and thinkers focused on translating the ancient Greek and Roman texts of the Middle Ages, thus paving the way for disseminating classical knowledge (Renaissance Art Characteristics, n.d). However, Humanists focused on studying philosophy and literature to understand ancient texts. They studied ancient Greek sculptures, architectural treatizes, and artistic work. The renewal of classical knowledge had a significant impact on the three renaissances. Classical knowledge provided the foundation for studying classical texts and humanistic values. Furthermore, it provided a foundation for cultural and intellectual transformations underpinning the Florentine, Italian and Chinese renaissances (Renaissance Art – Characteristics, n.d).
Famous classical humanists include Florentine Francesco Petrarch (1304-1374), a collector of classical manuscripts and a student of Byzantine scholars who sought to expand the Greek and Latin classical works (Bentley, 2014). The Italian Humanist Giovanni Pico della Mirandola (1463-1494) depicts the enthusiasm of Renaissance scholars to explore other civilizations and harmonize the teachings of great philosophers. Humanists, who included Renaissance artists and architects, were inspired by the classical Greek models and focused on literature, history, and moral philosophy. (Renaissance Art: History, Characteristics, n.d). Desiderius Erasmus (1466-1536) published the first Greek New Testament, while other Italian humanists emulated the classical Greeks. Famous classical humanists include Florentine Francesco Petrarca (1304-1374), a collector of classical manuscripts (Bentley, 2014, p. 465). In Europe, The Italian Humanist Giovanni Pico della Mirandola (1463-1494) depicts the enthusiasm of Renaissance scholars to explore other civilizations outside Europe.
Artists and Architects pushed the boundaries of artistic and architectural knowledge to extraordinary levels. These Italian Renaissance artists include Buonarotti (1475-1564), who depicted human subjects naturally (Bentley, 2014, p. 464). Renaissance architectural designs emphasized elegance and designed domed, large, open, and airy architectural buildings. Florentine architects invented new equipment designs. The Renaissance was marked by accelerated urbanization and the development of cities. For instance, the state-building concept emerged in Italy before other civilizations adopted it. The state building in Russia emerged in the fourteenth century and was built by the Grand Princes of Moscow (Bentley, 2014). The Renaissance that began at Florence prompted the need to expand and develop armies and militaries as dynasties developed a military for territorial protection.
The postclassical era was characterized by militarization and the development of sophisticated weaponry. Paper money and Taxes were introduced due to the need to finance state operations. These aspects of financial systems developed in the late fifteenth century are still in use today (Bentley, 2014). The Chinese Renaissance was characterized by exchanging goods and cultural values. The Silk Road connected China to the outside world. The grand canal facilitated cultural exchange while Buddhism entered China from India, influencing every aspect of Chinese society. “Buddhism attracted Chinese interests partly because of its high standards of morality, its intellectual sophistication, and its promise of salvation.” (Bentley, 2014, p.279).)
During the postclassical era, Europe focused on exploring and colonizing foreign territories. Importing goods from colonies spurred economic growth and development. There was a scientific, cultural, and artistic exchange through exploration and expeditions. Cultural exchange and trade were vital components of the Renaissance in China and Europe and facilitated the exchange of architectural, artistic, intellectual, and cultural ideals (Art, N. G. of., n.d). These exchanges contributed to remarkable intellectual, cultural, and social economic development. “Trade grew so rapidly during Tang and Song times that China experienced a shortage of copper coins….” (Bentley, 2014, p.275).
The invention of Gutenberg’s Printing press enabled the publishing of books, turning Florence into a printing and publishing hub in the 15th century. The Aldus Manutius printer (Aldine Press) facilitated the publication of ancient Greek and Roman texts. The Chinese Renaissance saw the advent of woodblock printing, which facilitated printing publishing (Renaissance Art: History, Characteristics, n.d). The Diamond Sutra, an ancient Chinese text, was produced during the Tang Dynasty. The advent of the printing press characterized Renaissance in postclassical Europe. Johannes Gutenberg invented the printing press in the 15th century. Besides revolutionizing the intellectual landscape, it enabled bible translation (Bentley, 2014). Printing and publication enabled the preservation and transmission of information. The printing and publishing industry necessitated knowledge and information exchange.
The Renaissance significantly shaped socio-political systems, introduced new perspectives., challenged the status quo and stirred intellectual movements (National Gallery of Art, n.d). Notwithstanding similarities, each Renaissance is distinct and different. For instance, colonization emerged in Europe in the Renaissance era. Bentley (2014) opines that “Exploration and colonization also dominated the classical Renaissance era” (p.465). The Chinese Renaissance was characterized by imperial courts and patronage where emperors and state officials supported artists. Tang Emperor Xuanzong was an artistic patron who supported artistic and intellectual endeavours. Similarly, Buddhist monasteries patronized artistic works (Chinese Renaissance Architecture, n.d.).
European humanists focused on the revival of interest in human transformation. These scholars include Erasmus and Thomas, who was an ardent proponent of humanism. They emphasized holistic human development and underscored the importance of education, critical thinking, and knowledge advancement (Renaissance Art, n.d). They challenged the dominant authority of religious institutions using classical knowledge.
The Florentine Renaissance was characterized by artistic and architectural sophistication. Italian artists expanded their painting, sculpture, and architecture knowledge through perspective and expressive artworks (Renaissance Art in Rome, n.d). Architectural advancements encompassed classical elements and linear perspective—for example, Filippo Brunelleschi’s architectural work. Chinese Artists of this era include Wu Daozi and Yan Liben, who mastered artistic elegance, attention to detail and orientation (Bentley, 2014). The Song Dynasty painters include Fan Kuan and Xia Gui, whose work was characterized by landscaping.
In Europe, Raphael, Titian, and Albrecht Durer advanced realism and artistic perspective in their work of art. However, in architecture, there was a return to using classical elements, proportions, columns, arches, and domes borrowed from Greek and Roman Architecture. According to Bentley (2014), “Interactions with peoples of other societies encouraged cultural exchange in postclassical China” (p.277). Throughout the Renaissance, artistic and architectural advancements were influenced by innovation, the study of classical models, and an obsession with realistic representation. A departure from artistic rigidity also characterized the Renaissance period, and artists began to embrace realism and emotionality (Renaissance Architecture, n.d.). Throughout the Renaissance, there was a significant improvement in art and architecture, with an Emphasis on elegance and aesthetic excellence.
The Renaissance artefact is the sardonyx cup, which has a heavy casting with silver. The cup is adorned with stone filigrees and white glass pearls. The cup is circlet studded and has pearls on top of the pearl (Chalice of the Abbot, n.d). However, it is not in its original state since a lower curl and a loop were embedded in its curling upper handles. Still, the faceted knobs are medieval additions. Only a few original stones remain from the 16th-century collection. The glass inset additions are imitations of white glass. The foot’s lower part differs from the original artefact before the French Revolution. The artefact has been fashioned into a narrow conical shape (Chalice of the Abbot, n.d). Other renovations to the artefact include the reshaping and flattening the bottom and the beaded string, cable and surrounding stones.
The source of the sardonyx cup remains a mystery as Abbot Sugar failed to disclose it. The artefact displays the advanced technology in Renaissance Europe. The technology used to fashion the sardonyx cup clearly reflects advanced artistic, scientific and architectural techniques in postclassical Europe. Given that the exact origin of the cup remains unknown, it is impossible to make a conclusive analysis of the artefact. The Sardonyx cup is preserved in the National Gallery Museum. (Painting and Sculpture, n.d). The second artefact that depicts Renaissance technology is a masterpiece by Irish artists. The Marriage of Strongbow and Aoife” was done by Maclise. This painting highlights the artwork by European artists. This artefact is in the National Gallery of Ireland (Painting and Sculpture, n.d). The two artefacts discussed have been featured in sourcebooks available at the Fordham University portal. The sardonyx cup and Maclise’s work reflect the influence of increased awareness and incorporation of nature and a more individualistic human view. Based on the artefacts, there was a departure from medieval values (Internet History Sourcebooks, n.d). The sardonyx cup illustrates a new artistic style that employs clear, simple structures instead of linear representations of objects.
Conclusion
Renaissance was a period of rebirth characterized by cultural, intellectual, artistic, architectural, and humanistic development. The period was marked by cultural and intellectual growth across all human civilizations and differed based on geography, timing, cultural, political, technological, scientific and philosophical ideologies.
References
Art in Context. (2021, June 25). Renaissance Art – An Artistic Exploration of the Renaissance Time Period. artincontext.org. https://artincontext.org/renaissance-art/
Art, N. G. of. (n.d.). The classical treatment of the body. Italian Renaissance Learning Resources. http://www.italianrenaissanceresources.com/units/unit-7/essays/classical-treatment-of-the-body/
Bentley, J. (2014). Traditions & Encounters, Vol. 1, from the beginning to 1500. McGraw-Hill Humanities/Social Sciences/Languages.
Crowell, N. (n.d.). 10 Renaissance Masterpieces You Can Only See in Florence. Culture Trip.
https:///europe/italy/articles/10-renaissance-masterpieces-you-can-only-see-in-florence/
Chinese Renaissance Architecture. (n.d.). Chinese Renaissance Architecture. https://biblioasia.nlb.gov.sg/vol-14/issue-1/apr-jun-2018/chinese-rensc-archit/
Chalice of the Abbot Suger of Saint-Denis. (n.d.). Art Object Page. https://www.nga.gov/collection/art-object-page.1437.html#provenance
Department of Asian Art. (2004), “Landscape Painting in Chinese Art.” In Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History. New York: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 2000. http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/clpg/hd_clpg.htm
Delbanco, D. (April 2008). “Chinese Calligraphy.” In Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History. New York: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 2000 http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/chcl/hd_chcl.htm
Florence, the Golden Age, 1138-1737 : Brucker, Gene A : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive. (n.d.). Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/florencegoldenag00bruc
Greatest Renaissance Paintings. (n.d.). Greatest Renaissance Paintings. http://www.visual-arts- cork.com/history-of-art/renaissance-paintings.htm
Hearn, M. (June 2008). “Chinese Painting.” In Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History. New York: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 2000. http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/chin/hd_chin.htm
Internet History Sourcebooks Project. (n.d.). Internet History Sourcebooks Project. https://sourcebooks.fordham.edu/index.asp
National Gallery of Art, N. (n.d). The Early Renaissance in Florence. Available at: https://www.nga.gov/features/slideshows/the-early-renaissance-in-florence.html
Painting and Sculpture. (n.d.). National Gallery of Ireland. https://www.nationalgallery.ie/art- and-artists/painting-and-sculpture
Renaissance Architecture. (n.d.). Renaissance Architecture: History, Characteristics, Designs History, Characteristics, Designs. http://www.visual-arts- cork.com/architecture/renaissance.htm
Renaissance Art in Rome Under the Popes. (n.d.). Renaissance Art in Rome Under the Popes. http://www.visual-arts-cork.com/history-of-art/renaissance-in-rome.htm
Renaissance Art: History, Characteristics. (n.d.). Renaissance Art: History, Characteristics. http://www.visual-arts-cork.com/renaissance-art.htm
Renaissance Art: Visual-Arts-Cork.com. (n.d.). A-Z of Renaissance Art: Visual-Arts-Cork.com. http://www.visual-arts-cork.com/site/renaissance.htm
Renaissance Art – Characteristics, Definition & Style. (n.d.). HISTORY. https://www.history.com/topics/renaissance/renaissance-art
write