Introduction
Revisionist Westerns, a subgenre that first appeared in the 1960s and 1970s, are best represented by Clint Eastwood’s Unforgiven (1992). The goals of revisionist Westerns were to question and trample on the genre’s established tropes. A retired outlaw, William Munny (Eastwood), is the movie Unforgiven’s main character. He is induced to leave seclusion to exact revenge on a man who beat a prostitute brutally.
Given that it challenges many of the established Western genre’s tropes, Unforgiven is a revisionist Western. In contrast to the glorified cowboy heroism prevalent in traditional Westerns, the movie’s main character is an anti-hero. Munny has an ethically questionable personality flaw and has murdered innocuous individuals in the past (Eastwood, 1992). Because the distinction between good and evil is hazy throughout the story, the movie also questions the moral relativism typical of the Western genre.
Subversion of Western Tropes:
Unforgiven is a self-aware Western that subverts many clichés present in classic Westerns by taking a revised stance. By depicting Munny as a flawed and mentally complicated character, the movie, for instance, questions the idea of the Western hero. When Munny informs the Schofield Kid that he is “not like he heard” and confesses to having killed innocent people, it is clear that he is subverting the Western hero trope (Eastwood, 1992). This revelation challenges the notion of the Western hero as a morally upright person who consistently does the right thing.
The “white hat” hero trope, in which the hero consistently dons a white cap to signify his moral rectitude, is also challenged in Unforgiven. Instead, the movie presents Little Bill Daggett, the primary antagonist, as a sheriff who dons a white hat but is anything but a moral exemplar. He is played by Gene Hackman (Eastwood, 1992). This subversion of the white hat cliché demonstrates the film’s readiness to question and undercut established Western norms.
Good and Evil’s Boundaries are Ambiguous:
By obscuring the distinction between goodness and wickedness, Unforgiven additionally questions the Western genre is overly moralistic outlook. The movie refuses to categorize its main protagonists according to straightforward good and evil concepts, instead portraying them as nuanced and uncertainly moral individuals. For instance, English Bob (Richard Harris), first presented as an honorable and gallant character, eventually becomes a ruthless and sadistic killer (Eastwood, 1992). Similar to Little Bill, who initially seems like a good lawman but whose brutality toward the prostitutes exposes his violent and misogynistic habits. The ethical ambiguity of the movie is also demonstrated by Munny, the protagonist who originally seeks vengeance but later develops sympathy and empathy for the prostitutes. His moral development and intricacy are demonstrated when he promises to give the prostitute Delilah (Anna Levine) the funds she needs for her kids.
The Western Genre’s Evolution:
Since the era of silent film, the Western genre has considerably changed. The 1950s and 1960s saw a peak in appeal for Westerns, initially produced as low-budget B-movies. Throughout this period, Westerns were viewed as promoting American principles and beliefs like hardy exclusivity, the significance of law and order, and the victory of righteousness against wickedness (Eastwood, 1992). The uncomplicated ethical behavior and stereotyped protagonists that had come to be identified with the Western genre, nevertheless, turned audiences and filmmakers off in the 1970s, which led to the genre’s decreasing appeal.
Unforgiven and the Revisionist Western: The movie also emphasizes the harsh and violent actuality of the West, as opposed to the sentimental depiction of the Western border in classic Westerns. Unforgiven’s brutal and violent sequences, including the prostitute’s torture, the sheriff’s killing, and the decisive shootout, are realistic and graphic. The film’s critique of the Western genre’s mythologizing of the West is strengthened by this reality. The portrayal of women in the Western genre is also subverted in Unforgiven. In traditional Westerns, women frequently play love interests, prostitutes, or damsels in trouble (Eastwood, 1992). Prostitutes are not depicted in Unforgiven as subjects of desire or sympathy. Instead, they are portrayed as strong, motivated people seeking retribution and justice. By showing women as powerful, independent people, the movie subverts the gender stereotypes of the Western genre.
Unforgiven is one of the revisionist Westerns questioning the American myth of the frontier as a site of opportunity and freedom. The movie portrays the West as an unruly, violent place where brutality rules paramount. The law enforcement organizations, including the sheriff, are portrayed as corrupt and ineffective, emphasizing the instability of the West even more. This critique of the frontier myth changes the traditional Western genre’s depiction of the West as a land of chance and hope. Therefore, unforgiven is a prime illustration of a revisionist Western that defies the rules of the standard Western genre (Eastwood, 1992). Strong female characters, an anti-hero protagonist, and realistic brutality in the movie challenge the romanticized and idealized depictions of the West in traditional Westerns. Revisionist Westerns, such as Unforgiven, challenge the mythologizing of the American frontier and the West to present a more complicated and nuanced picture of the Western frontier.
Individual Question:
What conventional Western genre conventions is Unforgiven subverting, and how?
Unforgiven challenges the conventional Western genre norms in some ways. The main character of the movie, William Munny, is an anti-hero. Unlike the idealized cowboy hero of old-fashioned Westerns, Munny is a flawed and ethically dubious figure. Having murdered unsuspecting people in the past, he is a former outlaw who is still troubled by his crimes. The movie also criticizes the oversimplified values of the Western genre. The characters’ actions are motivated by complicated motives rather than straightforward ideas of right and wrong throughout the story, and the distinction between good and evil becomes increasingly hazy (Braudy & Cohen, 2014). The movie also challenges the Western genre’s tendency to glorify bloodshed. Unforgiven features brutal and explicit violence, and the protagonists’ deeds have genuine repercussions. The movie argues that violence is destructive and should not be praised because it has long-lasting effects.
Conclusion:
The norms of the conventional Western genre are questioned and subverted in the revisionist Western Unforgiven. The film’s depiction of William Munny, a flawed and complicated character, subverts the Western hero trope. The fuzziness of good and evil challenges the overly moralistic trope of classic Westerns. The revisionist approach of Unforgiven distinguishes it from the trite and formulaic Westerns of the past, making it a significant work in the annals of the genre. The norms of the conventional Western genre are questioned and subverted in the revisionist Western Unforgiven. The film’s depiction of William Munny, a flawed and complicated character, subverts the Western hero trope. The fuzziness of good and evil challenges the overly moralistic trope of classic Westerns. The revisionist approach of Unforgiven distinguishes it from the trite and formulaic Westerns of the past, making it a significant work in the annals of the genre.
References
Braudy, L., & Cohen, M. (Eds.). (2004). Film theory and criticism (6th ed.). New York, NY: Oxford University Press. (pp. 691–702).
Eastwood, C. (Director). (1992). Unforgiven. United States: Warner Bros. Pictures.
write