Summary of the Two Speeches
The first video, “I Have a Dream speech by Martin Luther King. Jr delves into the demonstration for the freedom of Negros in the US. It talks about the oppression and segregation of the Negros in the modern-day society. Luther emphasizes that the Negros are still crippled by the manacles of segregation and the chains of discrimination and poverty. This systemic racism and oppression is rooted in the culture and structures of the US systems (Mulligan, 2021). He dreams that one day, the US will live the true meaning of its creed and recognize that all men are created equally. Alicia Garza, an organizer, writer, freedom fighter, and co-founder of black lives matter, sheds light on Black Lives Matter, a robust network of black people who have come together to eradicate anti-black racism and state sanctions violence. In her speech, she highlights that the lives of black people have not mattered for several years, witnessed by the sheer number of black convicts. This video asserts that the National Domestic Alliance is integral to the movement. This organization is linked to domestic work, which is rooted and shaped by the legacy of slavery.
Comparison of Leadership, Charisma, Power, and Passion
Similarities
Dr. King and Alicia Garza are charismatic leaders who utilize their speeches to motivate and mobilize their audience. They elicit strong emotional responses from their listeners using intimate tales and striking images. Dr. King and Garza are passionate speakers. Their passion is seen through the intensity with which they discuss their topics.
Differences
Dr.King employs a poetic and metaphorical style of speech, referencing the bible and American Patriots symbols to deliver his message. On the other hand, Garza’s speech reflects the urgency of the Black Lives Matter movement and is more direct and combative. Additionally, the differences in the context and time of their speeches influence the content and focus of their speeches.
Impact of Location on Messaging
The location of Dr. King’s speech at the Lincoln Memorial symbolizes American freedom and equality. This location adds power to his message. The church environment also provides spiritual depth to his speech. Additionally, the church environment supports his purpose of raising awareness about the problems in American society regarding civil rights and pointing out the reasons why racism and discrimination must be eradicated. The church offers a perfect vicinity for spreading the message against racism and mobilizing Christians to advocate for equality (Denney, 2023). Alicia Garza’s message instantaneously reaches a global audience because it is delivered through contemporary venues, such as social media. Social media reaches a broader audience, including the community, and allows for connection with the audience and building relationships. These connections are crucial in spreading the message against the murder of black people such as Jordan Davis and Johnatan Sandals. Additionally, social media is an excellent tool for mobilizing US citizens against the criminalization of Black Americans and the exploitation of black domestic workers. This use of social media amplifies the Black Lives Matter message.
Audience Comparison
It is feasible to say that the speeches’ intended audiences overlap because both presentations illustrate injustice and unfairness about how society views Black people. However, Alicia Garcia’s speech focuses primarily on th
/]=o\statistical figures. Therefore, her address is narrowly focused. Martin Luther King’s speech aims to portray African Americans’ full range of obstacles and struggles in the United States without focusing on any one movement or group. These speeches inspired several US elections, including the 2018 that emphasized equality and the end of Negro oppression (Greenberg, 2018). Both seminars paint a comprehensive picture of the disparity between whites and blacks in American culture, so the two speeches are intended for similar audiences. However, the remarks from these speeches are directed at both Black Americans and white people, who need to witness and comprehend the feelings that Black people experience when they encounter racism and unfair treatment.
References
Greenberg, E. S & Page, B. I. (2018). The Struggle for Democracy, 2018 Elections and Updates Edition. (12th ed.). Pearson.
Denney, M. G. (2023). The Fragmented Gateway to Collective Repentance: Race, Policing, and the Black Church in America (Doctoral dissertation, Yale University).
Mulligan, C. J. (2021). Systemic racism can get under our skin and into our genes. American Journal of Physical Anthro
write