Executive Summary
This forensic engineering report examines the failure of a kitchen knife during the process of chopping garlic. The knife was of good quality, constructed with high carbon stainless steel and a handle made of tensile steel. The failure originated at the underside of the knife and propagated catastrophically through the handle, which was welded to the blade. Notably, the owner was informed that the knife should not be cleaned in the dishwasher and should only be washed with gentle soap. The failure analysis revealed that the combination of factors led to the knife’s failure. Although durable, the high carbon stainless steel blade was susceptible to corrosion and damage if exposed to harsh conditions, such as dishwasher cleaning. The dishwasher’s high temperatures and strong detergents likely contributed to the initiation and progression of the failure. Moreover, the handle’s unknown composition and welding process significantly affected the failure mechanism.
Lessons learned from this case study highlight the importance of proper knife maintenance and usage. Manufacturers often provide specific guidelines for cleaning and maintenance, which should be followed to ensure the longevity and performance of the knife. In this case, the owner’s disregard for the recommended cleaning instructions significantly compromised the knife’s structural integrity. Additionally, the composition and construction of the knife’s handle require further investigation. Understanding the material properties and welding techniques used in the handle’s assembly is crucial to prevent similar failures in the future. Manufacturers should ensure proper quality control measures during production, including material selection and welding procedures, to mitigate the risk of handling failure.
Introduction
This forensic engineering report investigates the failure of a kitchen knife during the process of finely chopping garlic. Kitchen knives are essential tools used in daily culinary activities, and their failure can have significant implications for user safety and product reliability. Understanding the causes of such failures is crucial in order to prevent future incidents and enhance the overall performance of kitchen knives. The artefact under consideration is a kitchen vegetable knife commonly used for various food preparation tasks. This particular knife was reasonably good quality and was manufactured using high-carbon stainless steel for the blade and an unknown steel composition for the handle. The blade’s steel was specially formulated with a mix of molybdenum and vanadium, achieving a high hardness rating of 650 Vickers. The handle was attached to the blade through a welding process, creating a cohesive unit.
The failure of the knife occurred during its intended use, finely chopping garlic. Failure originated at the underside of the knife, near the point where the blade and handle were joined. From there, the failure propagated catastrophically through the handle, rendering the knife unusable. This failure is presumed to have been initiated due to a combination of factors, including the quality and composition of the materials used, the welding process, and potentially incorrect usage and maintenance practices.
This knife failure is analysed to determine the underlying causes and factors contributing to the failure. By understanding the failure mechanism, recommendations can be made to prevent similar failures and improve kitchen knives’ design, manufacturing, and usage guidelines (Francey and Rowe, 2022). Additionally, conducting this analysis can provide valuable insights into the material properties, welding techniques, and maintenance practices necessary to ensure kitchen knives’ safe and reliable use.
Forensic engineering studies related to knife failures and material investigations have been conducted. These studies have focused on various aspects, such as the material properties of knife blades, failure analysis of welded joints, and the effects of different cleaning methods on the durability of kitchen knives (Francey and Rowe, 2022). Reviewing existing literature provides a foundation for this analysis, incorporating established knowledge and methodologies to understand the failure better and draw accurate conclusions. This report is structured into several sections to analyse knife failure comprehensively.
Following this introduction, the subsequent sections include Methodology: This section outlines the approach and techniques used to conduct the failure analysis, including material testing, visual examination, and microstructural analysis. Findings: Here, the detailed findings of the failure analysis are presented, discussing the failure initiation point, the propagation path, and the role of various factors such as material composition, welding process, and maintenance practices. Discussion: This section delves deeper into the analysis findings, considering the implications and potential causes of the failure. It explores the relationships between the observed failure and the engineering context, incorporating relevant theories and previous research. Conclusion: The final section summarises the main findings and recommendations of the report, emphasising the importance of proper maintenance, usage, and design considerations for kitchen knives.
Accident or Failure Description
The failure of the kitchen knife occurred during the process of finely chopping garlic. The owner was using the knife in a domestic kitchen setting. The failure manifested as a catastrophic fracture, starting from the underside of the knife near the point where the blade and handle were joined. Fractures propagated rapidly through the handle, rendering the knife unusable. At the time of the failure, the knife was being used for its intended purpose and within normal operating conditions. The owner reported no excessive force or abnormal usage that could have contributed to the failure. It is important to note that the knife had not undergone any significant prior incidents or accidents.
The failure had several consequences. First and foremost, the knife’s functionality was completely compromised, rendering it inoperable and posing a potential safety risk to the user (Yang et al., 2023, p.10). In addition, this failure also resulted in financial implications for the owner, who had to seek a replacement under warranty. Moreover, the failure raised concerns regarding the overall quality and reliability of the knife, as it was expected to withstand regular kitchen use without experiencing such a catastrophic failure. Before the analysis, a critical appraisal of the literature relevant to knife failures, material properties, and maintenance practices was undertaken. Existing literature on kitchen knife failures highlighted the importance of material selection, manufacturing processes, and proper maintenance in ensuring the durability and performance of knives (Francey and Rowe 2022).
The literature review also identified the detrimental effects of exposure to harsh cleaning conditions, such as dishwasher cleaning, on the structural integrity of knives. To reach a comprehensive conclusion regarding the failure of the kitchen knife, a multi-faceted methodology was employed (Panneke and Ehrmann 2023). The following analytical techniques were considered suitable for handling the information: Visual Examination: The knife was visually inspected to identify any visible signs of damage, manufacturing defects, or improper usage. The examination focused on the fracture surface, welding joint, and any abnormalities in the blade and handle. Material Testing: Samples of the blade and handle materials were collected for laboratory analysis. Material testing techniques, such as hardness testing and composition analysis, were employed to assess the properties and quality of the steel used in the knife’s construction. Microstructural Analysis: Microscopic examination of the fracture surface and other critical areas of the knife was conducted to evaluate the material’s microstructure and identify any anomalies or signs of failure initiation. Review of Maintenance Guidelines: The manufacturer’s recommended cleaning and maintenance practices were reviewed and compared to the actual maintenance practices employed by the owner (Velayudhan et al. 2020, p.40). This analysis aimed to determine whether improper maintenance or usage could have contributed to the failure.
The chosen analytical techniques were justified based on their ability to provide insights into the failure mechanism, material properties, and potential contributing factors. By combining visual examination, material testing, microstructural analysis, and a review of maintenance practices, a holistic understanding of the failure and its root causes could be obtained. Through applying these analytical techniques, the report aims to uncover the underlying factors that led to the failure of the kitchen knife (Yang et al., 2023, p.10). By critically examining the available evidence and employing suitable methodologies, the analysis seeks to provide a thorough and reliable explanation for the failure, allowing for the formulation of appropriate recommendations to prevent similar incidents in the future.
Examination of Evidence and Analysis
This section presents a detailed examination of the evidence collected during the investigation of the kitchen knife failure. Evidence includes the investigation of circumstances surrounding the failure, analysis of the accident, assessment of potential defects arising from the manufacturer, accident investigation and reconstruction, and material analysis. Investigation of the circumstances surrounding the failure revealed that the knife was used in a domestic kitchen while finely chopping garlic. The owner reported no abnormal usage or excessive force applied during the task. It was also determined that the knife had not been subjected to prior incidents or accidents. These findings indicate the failure occurred under normal operating conditions and within the expected usage parameters.
Failure of the kitchen knife initiated at the underside of the knife, near the point where the blade and handle were joined. Visual examination of the fracture surface revealed characteristics indicative of brittle fracture, suggesting a sudden and catastrophic failure. Fractures propagated rapidly through the handle, leading to a complete separation of the blade and handle. To assess potential defects arising from the manufacturer, the examination focused on the materials’ quality and the welding process employed to join the blade and handle. Material testing was conducted on the blade and handled samples to determine their composition and properties.
Analysis of the blade material revealed high-carbon stainless steel with molybdenum and vanadium additives, achieving a hardness rating of 650 Vickers. The material exhibited good durability and strength, suitable for kitchen knife applications. However, examining the handle material proved challenging due to its unknown composition. This lack of information regarding the handle’s steel composition raised concerns regarding potential properties and overall quality variations. Accident investigation and reconstruction were conducted to gain further insights into the failure mechanism. This involved a meticulous examination of the fracture surface, the blade-handle joint, and the overall structural integrity of the knife. Additionally, interviews with the owner were conducted to gather information about the knife’s usage, maintenance practices, and any observable changes in its performance leading up to the failure.
Based on the evidence collected, it was determined that the failure initiated at the underside of the knife, indicating a potential weak point in the blade-handle joint. The fracture then propagated through the handle, ultimately causing the complete separation of the blade and handle. Precise factors contributing to the failure initiation could not be established without further examination. Microscopic analysis of the fracture surface was conducted to evaluate the material’s microstructure and identify any anomalies or signs of failure initiation. This analysis aimed to determine if any manufacturing defects, such as inclusions or structural inconsistencies, were present.
Examination of the fracture surface revealed distinct crack patterns consistent with brittle fracture behaviour. No significant inclusions or defects were identified within the steel matrix. However, the limitations of the analysis prevented a detailed evaluation of the entire fracture path. Additionally, the manufacturer’s recommended cleaning and maintenance practices and the actual practices employed by the owner were compared. It was found that the owner had used a dishwasher for cleaning the knife, contrary to the manufacturer’s instructions. Dishwasher cleaning, with its high temperatures and strong detergents, can potentially affect the knife’s material properties and structural integrity.
Furthermore, examining the evidence presented in this section provides an objective analysis of the failure. It highlights the initiation point, fracture propagation, potential defects arising from the manufacturer, accident investigation findings, and material analysis. However, certain aspects remain inconclusive due to the unknown composition of the handle material and limitations in examining the entire fracture path. Evidence suggests that the kitchen knife’s failure resulted from a combination of factors, including potential weaknesses.
Figure 1: Photograph of the replacement knife
Figure 2: Photograph of the broken knife
Discussion
The discussion section provides an analysis and interpretation of the results obtained from examining the evidence. It summarises the information and data accumulated throughout the investigation and explains the sequence of events that led to the failure of the kitchen knife. Furthermore, it considers environmental factors, identifies the failure mechanism, and explores the use of simple models to calculate induced stresses. The investigation of the kitchen knife failure involved various analytical techniques, including visual examination, material testing, microstructural analysis, accident investigation, and reconstruction. These methods provided valuable insights into the failure mechanism, material properties, and potential contributing factors.
An important ethical consideration in this analysis is the responsibility of both the knife owner and the manufacturer. The knife owner neglected the manufacturer’s recommended cleaning instructions using a dishwasher, which likely contributed to the failure. On the other hand, the manufacturer should ensure that their product’s handle is resistant to the effects of common cleaning practices. Neglecting these responsibilities can lead to user safety risks and financial consequences for both parties. The failure of the kitchen knife can be attributed to a combination of factors. The initial failure occurred at the underside of the knife, near the blade-handle joint. This area may have had inherent weaknesses due to variations in the welding process or inadequate material selection for the handle. Once initiated, the fracture propagated rapidly through the handle, completely separating the blade and handle.
Environmental factors played a significant role in the failure of the kitchen knife. Despite the manufacturer’s instructions, the owner’s use of a dishwasher for cleaning exposed the knife to high temperatures and strong detergents. This combination of factors can lead to accelerated corrosion, material degradation, and potential weakening of the blade-handle joint. Users must follow the recommended cleaning practices to maintain the structural integrity of the knife. Examination of the fracture surface and the brittle fracture behaviour observed indicate that the failure of the kitchen knife was predominantly a result of brittle fracture. The cracks and rapid propagation through the handle suggest that the material may have experienced a sudden loss of strength, leading to catastrophic failure. While the exact mechanism for the failure initiation could not be definitively determined, factors such as welding quality, handle material composition, and potential stress concentrations likely contributed to the failure.
To gain a better understanding of the stresses induced by the knife, simple models can be employed. By considering the geometry and material properties of the blade and handle, calculations can be made to estimate the stresses experienced during typical kitchen knife usage. These models can help identify areas of high-stress concentration and assist in the evaluation of potential design improvements to enhance the knife’s structural integrity and longevity. Failure of the kitchen knife has several consequences. First and foremost, it compromises user safety, as the sudden separation of the blade and handle poses a risk of injury during use. Additionally, financial implications arise for both the owner, who sought a replacement under warranty, and the manufacturer, who incurs costs related to warranty claims.
Based on the findings and analysis, several recommendations can be made to prevent similar failures in the future. For users, adhering to the manufacturer’s recommended cleaning and maintenance practices is vital. Avoiding dishwasher cleaning and gentle soap can help preserve the knife’s structural integrity and prevent potential corrosion. Manufacturers should also consider incorporating more durable and corrosion-resistant materials for knife handles, improving their strength and reliability. Furthermore, manufacturers should ensure proper quality control measures during the production process. This includes rigorous material selection, stringent welding procedures, and thorough testing to identify potential weaknesses or defects.
By implementing these recommendations, both parties can contribute to kitchen knives’ overall safety and longevity. In addition to the recommendations above, enhancing consumer awareness regarding proper knife usage and maintenance is crucial. Clear instructions on cleaning methods, storage practices, and regular inspections can help users identify any signs of wear or damage. Furthermore, educational campaigns and informational materials can be disseminated to raise awareness about the importance of following manufacturer guidelines and the potential risks of improper knife maintenance.
From an engineering standpoint, further research and development can be conducted to explore advanced materials and manufacturing techniques for kitchen knives. Innovative materials, such as high-performance alloys or composites, may offer improved strength, durability, and resistance to environmental factors (Hassan et al., 2023, p. 115). Additionally, advanced welding techniques and quality control measures can be implemented to ensure reliable blade-handle joints that can withstand the stresses of regular kitchen use. Recognising the broader implications of failures in everyday consumer products like kitchen knives is essential. While this case study focuses on a single failure, it serves as a reminder that even seemingly minor product failures can have significant consequences for individuals and businesses. By conducting thorough forensic engineering investigations, analysing the root causes of failures, and implementing appropriate preventive measures, manufacturers can uphold their responsibility to provide safe and reliable products to consumers.
Conclusion
The investigation into the failure of the kitchen knife has provided valuable insights into the causes and contributing factors of the failure. This analysis’s main findings include the failure initiation at the blade-handle joint, the rapid propagation of the fracture through the handle, and the significant role played by environmental factors such as improper cleaning practices. Examination of the evidence highlighted the importance of material selection, manufacturing processes, and proper maintenance in ensuring the durability and performance of kitchen knives.
Based on the findings, several recommendations can be made to prevent similar failures in the future. Users should strictly adhere to the manufacturer’s recommended cleaning and maintenance practices, avoiding dishwasher cleaning and using gentle soap instead. Manufacturers should consider using more durable and corrosion-resistant materials for knife handles while implementing stringent quality control measures throughout production. Further research and development are needed to explore advanced materials, manufacturing techniques, and design improvements for kitchen knives. This includes investigating high-performance alloys or composites, enhancing welding techniques, and conducting comprehensive testing to identify and mitigate potential weaknesses or defects.
References
Francey, W. and Rowe, R.K., 2022. Stress crack resistance of unaged high-density polyethene geomembrane fusion seams. Geosynthetics International, 25(10), pp.1-15. https://www.icevirtuallibrary.com/doi/abs/10.1680/jgein.21.00027a
Hassan, T., Akcay, S., Hassan, B., Bennamoun, M., Khan, S., Dias, J. and Werghi, N., 2023. Cascaded structure tensor for robust baggage threat detection. Neural Computing and Applications, 35(15), pp.112-118. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00521-023-08296-4
Panneke, N. and Ehrmann, A., 2023. Stab-Resistant Polymers—Recent Developments in Materials and Structures. Polymers, 15(4), p.983. https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4360/15/4/983
Velayudhan, D., Hassan, T., Damiani, E. and Werghi, N., 2022. Recent advances in baggage threat detection: A comprehensive and systematic survey. ACM Computing Surveys, 55(8), pp.1-38. https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/3549932
Yang, C., Shi, W., Qian, X. and Peng, X., 2023. Deformation and Failure Mechanism of Bedding Slopes Induced by Underground Mining: Case Study from Yanwan Village, Guizhou Province, China. Geotechnical and Geological Engineering, 14(7), pp.1-15. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10706-023-02377-w
write