Introduction
Curriculum evaluation assesses the educational content of a course, program, or curriculum (Button, n.d, introduction section). It is used to determine if the curriculum is meeting its intended goals and outcomes. Evaluation involves collecting feedback from stakeholders, analyzing data, and revising the curriculum as necessary. Thus, it is important for educators to continuously evaluate the curriculum to ensure that the program is up-to-date and meets the needs of both the students and the educational institution. In nursing, curriculum evaluation has been used to assess and look for the best strategies to improve nursing healthcare learning. The nursing field has been evolving tremendously throughout time, calling for evaluation. Nursing has focused on promoting health, preventing disease, and supporting ill or injured people. Nurses provide compassionate care, evaluate and assess patients, and collaborate with other healthcare professionals to ensure the highest quality of care. Nursing requires a wide range of knowledge and skills, including communication, critical thinking, problem-solving, and clinical decision-making. However, over time, there has been an adjustment. These adjustments have created difficulties and brand-new demands for the profession that must be handled. Traditionally, nurses have been educated using the Bachelor of Science in Nursing (BSN) program. However, it has been discovered that the most present challenges call for a curriculum change that would consider these demands and challenges (Button, n.d, introduction section). Current nursing demands include nurse leadership, patient-informed consent issues, and inadequate resources and staffing. The nurse leader position was not included in the conventional BSN curriculum.
Because of this, most nurses have never seen leadership as anything other than politics, and they may thus choose not to assume leadership roles. Therefore, the new curriculum has to be evaluated since it might have many negative effects. First, identifying areas that want improvement won’t be feasible if no curriculum evaluation is carried out in nursing. In addition, it will only be possible to evaluate how the adjustments affect things. For example, suppose the new course needs to meet its goals, and no evaluation is carried out. In that case, institutional management will continue to invest in resources without reaping any rewards for the course. Thesis, ongoing curriculum evaluation in nursing is crucial, and evidence-based nursing concepts, theories, and best practices can be employed to enhance curriculum development.
Importance of ongoing curriculum evaluation in nursing, why is it important and to whom?
Curriculum evaluation is an important process in nursing, as it helps ensure that nursing curricula are developed and delivered to meet the needs of the students, the profession and the public. Nurses, nursing educators, and healthcare administrators must assess and evaluate the quality of nursing curricula to ensure that the best possible education is provided to nursing students. Curriculum evaluation is important for several reasons. It provides valuable feedback from stakeholders, including students, faculty, and employers, about the quality of the curriculum, which can be used to continuously improve the curriculum (Button, n.d, purpose section). This helps ensure that nursing students are prepared for their roles with the most current knowledge and skills. The evaluation also helps to ensure that the curriculum meets the needs of the profession and the public and meets accreditation standards.
Besides, it enables nursing educators and administrators to identify areas of strength and weakness in the curriculum and ensure that the necessary resources are allocated to support it.
For nursing educators and administrators, curriculum evaluation is important to ensure that the curriculum meets the needs of the students and the profession. It serves as the foundation for curricular policy choices, input on ongoing curriculum adjustments, and application procedures (Button, n.d, purpose section). Evaluation provides valuable insight into areas where the curriculum needs to be improved or changed to meet the profession’s demands. Additionally, evaluation helps identify any potential gaps in the curriculum that need to be addressed to ensure that students are getting the best possible education.
For students, curriculum evaluation can help ensure that they receive a quality education that meets the profession’s needs. Evaluation can also provide students with valuable feedback about their learning experience, which can be used to help them make informed decisions about their educational path (Button, n.d, purpose section). For example, students can evaluate their courses on various criteria, such as the quality of instruction, the relevance of the curriculum, and the availability of resources. This information can then be used to improve the curriculum, ensuring students receive a quality education that meets their needs.
Curriculum evaluation is also important for community stakeholders, such as parents. It provides information about which curriculum elements are effective and which must be revised or improved. Through curriculum evaluation, community stakeholders can provide valuable feedback to educators and administrators that can be used to create a more effective learning environment (Button, n.d, sustainability section). Additionally, curriculum evaluation can help community stakeholders identify areas of improvement in their school or district and develop strategies to address them. Curriculum evaluation also allows community stakeholders to be involved in curriculum development, which can lead to a greater sense of ownership and engagement with the educational system.
Therefore, curriculum evaluation is an important process in nursing, as it helps to ensure that nursing curricula are developed and delivered to meet the needs of the students, the profession and the public. Also, it ensures that the best possible education is provided to nursing students.
What criteria are important in evaluating curriculum in nursing?
Alignment with the standards: When evaluating a nursing curriculum, it is important to ensure that it aligns with the profession’s standards. This means that the curriculum should cover all the knowledge and skills required for nursing practice, as outlined by the relevant regulatory body (Button, n.d, criteria section). This includes infection control, patient safety, and clinical decision-making. Each topic should be thoroughly evaluated to come up with the necessary strategies that can be useful in improving their Learning.
Clinical Relevance: Clinical relevance is another key criterion for evaluating a nursing curriculum. It involves the preparation of the students with the nursing curriculum. The curriculum criteria include content relevant to the clinical setting, such as patient assessment, care planning, and evidence-based practice, as well as opportunities for students to develop clinical skills through simulation and clinical experiences. The curriculum includes content that is applicable to the current nursing practice and healthcare environment.
Accreditation Standards: Nursing programs must meet accreditation standards set by the National League for Nursing Accrediting Commission (NLNAC) or Accreditation Commission for Education in Nursing (ACEN). Accreditation standards ensure that nursing programs provide quality education to their students. When evaluating a nursing curriculum, it is important to consider if the curriculum meets these standards.
Consistency with objectives: Another important factor to consider when evaluating a nursing curriculum is consistency with the objectives of the program (Button, n.d, criteria section). It is important that the curriculum is designed to meet the goals and objectives of the program, and that each module or unit of the program covers the necessary material for the student to successfully complete the program.
Learning Outcomes: The curriculum should have clearly defined learning outcomes that reflect the goals and objectives of the program. These outcomes should be measurable and achievable. Besides, the curriculum should also include assessments that measure student learning and competence in the various competency areas.
Competency-Based Learning: A competency-based learning approach should be incorporated into the curriculum. This approach is a learner-centered approach that focuses on the development of specific competencies. This approach ensures that students are able to apply what they have learned in the classroom to the clinical setting.
Comprehensiveness of the curriculum: As well as ensuring that the curriculum meets the standards and objectives of the program, it is also important to ensure that the curriculum is comprehensive (Button, n.d, criteria section). This means that the curriculum must cover all of the topics necessary for the student to become a competent nurse. This includes topics such as anatomy and physiology, pharmacology, and communication skills. Additionally, the curriculum should incorporate evidence-based practice and provide the student with the opportunity to develop critical thinking skills.
Student Engagement: The curriculum should include activities and assignments that promote student engagement and active Learning. This includes activities such as problem-based Learning, simulations, and case studies. These activities help students to better understand the material and apply it to real-life situations.
Technology: Technology can also be used as criteria for evaluating curriculum. It includes the use of online learning platforms, interactive websites, and multimedia. Technology can help to make learning more engaging and accessible for students.
Inter professional Learning: The curriculum evaluation criteria can include content that promotes inter professional Learning and collaboration. This includes learning activities that involve working with other healthcare professionals, such as physicians, dietitians, and social workers. Interprofessional Learning helps students to better understand the roles and responsibilities of other healthcare professionals and how to work effectively as a team.
Lastly, flexibility can be used as criteria for curriculum evaluation. The curriculum should provide flexibility for students. This includes the ability to complete the program at their own pace, choose electives that meet their interests and needs, and the ability to transfer credits to other institutions.
Explain how and why pilot testing can be used in curriculum evaluation.
Pilot testing has been used to evaluate a curriculum or program prior to a full-scale implementation (Diem, 2019, section 1). It is a way to identify potential issues and test the feasibility of the material, program, or intervention. In nursing pilot testing is an essential step in the process of curriculum development and implementation. It involves testing the curriculum before it is implemented in a clinical setting in order to identify any potential issues or challenges that may arise. Pilot testing typically involves a small group of students who are given a new or revised curriculum to complete (Diem, 2019, procedure section). This is done in order to determine if the curriculum is effective and if it meets the learning objectives of the course. During the pilot test, instructors observe and assess the students’ performance. Besides, questionnaires are distributed to students to get feedback about their experiences. This helps to identify any potential issues with the curriculum, such as lack of clarity or difficulty in understanding certain concepts. Thereafter, there is collecting data from the students, such as their performance on assessments, feedback on their experience with the curriculum, and any changes that may need to be made (Diem, 2019, procedure section). Therefore, Pilot testing can be used to identify any problems or modifications needed for the program prior to implementation and to estimate the amount of resources needed for the full-scale implementation.
In nursing, pilot testing is important because it can provide a way to assess the potential outcomes of a new program or curriculum. It provides a way to assess the effectiveness of the program or curriculum in a real-world setting before the full-scale implementation. It also allows the program or curriculum to be adjusted if necessary, before full implementation. Pilot testing can also provide valuable feedback on the program or curriculum from nurses and other healthcare professionals who are involved in its implementation (Diem, 2019, section 1). This feedback can help to identify any issues or problems with the program or curriculum and can help to identify areas that need to be improved. Finally, pilot testing can provide data on the performance of nurses and other healthcare professionals involved in the pilot testing, which can provide valuable insights into the effectiveness of the program or curriculum. This data can be used to inform the full-scale implementation and ensure that the program or curriculum is implemented correctly and efficiently. Therefore, pilot testing Is vital since it provides a way to assess the effectiveness of a program or curriculum prior to full-scale implementation and can provide valuable feedback and data that can help to inform the implementation and ensure that it is successful.
Give instances of both short-term and long-term process assessments for curriculum, and describe why both are important for curriculum development.
Short-term curriculum evaluation is an important tool for assessing the effectiveness and relevance of a curriculum in the present. It allows for an immediate assessment of the material, the structure and delivery of the course, the performance of the instructor and the results of the students’ Learning. In the field of nursing, for example, a short-term evaluation of an online course in medication administration can be conducted. This evaluation can assess how well the course materials are understood by students, how the course is being delivered, how the instructor is performing and what student outcomes were achieved. By doing this, it is possible to identify any areas that could be improved in the present and make necessary changes to the curriculum (Kelly, 2020). The evaluation could involve a review of the materials used in the course, the structure of the course, the delivery of the course, the performance of the instructor, and the student outcomes. Besides, the evaluation could also involve a feedback survey from the students, which can provide valuable insight into the effectiveness of the course and the areas that could be improved. The evaluation could also include a comparison to other courses in the same field, in order to assess the effectiveness of the curriculum relative to other courses. This comparison could include the materials used, the structure and delivery of the course, the performance of the instructor and the results of the student learning. Finally, the evaluation could also include a review of the long-term impact of the course. This could include assessing if the course has led to any changes in the practice of nursing or if it has had any effect on patient care. Thus, by conducting a short-term evaluation of a course, it is possible to identify any areas that need to be improved in the present and make necessary changes to the curriculum (Kelly, 2020, introduction section).
Long-term curriculum evaluation is an important tool for assessing the effectiveness and relevance of a curriculum over a longer period of time. This type of evaluation can be used to review the materials, course structure and delivery, instructor performance, and student outcomes over several years or even decades, allowing for a more comprehensive understanding of a program’s impact. For example, in nursing, a long-term evaluation could be conducted to review the impact of a Master’s program in nursing administration. This evaluation process can involve a range of analytical methods, such as surveys, interviews, document reviews, and focus groups. Surveys can be used to assess student perceptions of the course materials and instructor performance. Interviews and focus groups can provide more in-depth insights into the efficacy of the curriculum (Kelly, 2020, introduction section). Additionally, document reviews can be used to assess trends in student outcomes over time. By collecting and analyzing this data, it is possible to identify areas of strength and weaknesses in the curriculum, as well as potential opportunities for improvement. Furthermore, long-term curriculum evaluation can also provide valuable insight into how well the curriculum is meeting the needs of students and the profession. Therefore, by looking at student outcomes over time, it is possible to determine whether the curriculum is adequately preparing students for their future roles. Additionally, the evaluation can provide insight into the relevancy of the curriculum, and how well it is keeping up with changing trends in the field. Overall, long-term curriculum evaluation is a valuable tool for assessing the effectiveness and relevance of a curriculum over time. By utilizing a variety of analytical methods, it is possible to gain a comprehensive understanding of the curriculum and its impact, allowing for necessary changes to be made to ensure that the curriculum is meeting the needs of students and the profession.
Both short-term and long-term curriculum evaluations are necessary for process improvement. Short-term evaluations provide important feedback on how the curriculum is performing in the short-term and can help identify areas of improvement and make changes to the curriculum (Kelly, 2020, comment section). Long-term evaluations are used to assess the effectiveness and relevance of a curriculum over a longer period of time and can provide insight into how the curriculum is performing over time. Furthermore, Short-term evaluations allow for the implementation of quick fixes and adjustments to a curriculum that can have a direct and immediate impact on the effectiveness of the curriculum. Long-term evaluations provide a more accurate assessment of the overall success of a curriculum, and can help identify areas that require more attention or may need to be reworked (Kelly, 2020, comment section). Hence, information can be used to make changes to the curriculum to ensure it is meeting the needs of students and the profession.
Describe ways to enhance the development of curriculum by applying evidence-based nursing principles, theories, and best practices.
Evidence-based nursing (EBN) is a critically important concept for curriculum development. It involves the use of the best evidence from research, clinical practice, and patient preferences to develop the most effective and efficient curriculum for nursing students. The process of applying evidence-based nursing in curriculum development begins with the identification of the population of nursing students and the competencies they need to acquire. This population is clearly defined and the desired competencies are identified using evidence-based research. Once the target population and competencies are identified, the curriculum is designed to meet the identified competencies. This can be done in a variety of ways, such as using problem-based Learning, case studies, simulations, and other teaching strategies. The curriculum is evaluated to ensure it meets the identified competencies (Button, n.d, measurement section). Evidence-based research is used to assess the effectiveness of the curriculum. This can involve surveys, focus groups, and interviews with students and faculty. Additionally, the curriculum could be evaluated for its impact on patient outcomes. This could include measuring patient satisfaction, improvement in patient outcomes, and cost-effectiveness. Evidence-based research can be used to inform the development of the curriculum. It can be used to identify the most effective strategies for teaching and Learning, like inquiry-based Learning and collaborative Learning. Besides, it can be used to identify the most appropriate content for the curriculum. Evidence-based research can also be used to evaluate existing curricula and inform decisions about what needs to be added, modified, or removed.
Best practice guidelines are also applied at all stages of the curriculum development process in order to ensure the curriculum is effective and of high quality (Bisoux, 2021). At the beginning of the process, best practice guidelines are used to identify and prioritize the needs of the students and to ensure that the curriculum meets the needs of the students and aligns with current best practices. This can be done through stakeholder surveys and interviews, focus groups, and reviews of existing research and literature. Next, best practice guidelines are also used to develop the curriculum. This can include the creation of a timeline for development and implementation, the use of a variety of instructional methods to meet the learning objectives, and the development of a plan for ongoing evaluation and revision of the curriculum. As the curriculum is implemented, best practice guidelines are then used to monitor and evaluate the effectiveness of the curriculum. This can include the use of formative and summative assessments, and feedback from students, teachers, and other stakeholders. Hence, best practice guidelines update the curriculum. These guidelines can be used to inform the development of the curriculum and to ensure that the curriculum meets the needs of the students and aligns with current best practices.
Furthermore, integrating technology into the curriculum can be used to improve curriculum development. Technology can be used to enhance the learning experience, and to provide students with access to the latest evidence-based research and resources. Technology can also be used to develop interactive and engaging learning experiences, and to facilitate collaboration among students and faculty.
Besides, evidence-based nursing theories can be used to develop and inform curriculum content. The Neuman Systems Model is an evidence-based nursing theory that provides a holistic approach to nursing care, emphasizing the interdependencies between the Nurse, the Client, and the Environment in order to promote optimal health. This model can be used to inform curriculum content by providing a framework for understanding the knowledge, skills, and attitudes needed for successful practice (Neuman, 20119). It can also be used to identify the most appropriate content to include in the curriculum. For example, the Neuman Systems Model includes five major components: the person, the environment, the health care system, the nursing system, and the interaction between the person and the environment. Each of these components can be incorporated into the curriculum in order to provide students with an understanding of the roles and responsibilities of nurses in the health care system. Additionally, the model can be used to identify the appropriate content to include in courses related to health assessment, diagnosis, and treatment. The Neuman Systems Model also includes specific concepts related to the client’s health and well-being (Neuman, 2019). These concepts can be used to develop curriculum content that focuses on nursing interventions, health promotion, and disease prevention. Additionally, the model can inform curriculum content related to the assessment of health risk factors, the development of care plans, and the delivery of nursing care. By incorporating evidence-based theories such as the Neuman Systems Model into the curriculum, students will gain an understanding of the knowledge, skills, and attitudes needed to provide effective nursing care. Finally, the Neuman Systems Model can be used to inform curriculum content related to the ethical and legal aspects of nursing. This model emphasizes the nurse’s role in advocating for the rights of the client, maintaining confidentiality, and ensuring the safety and well-being of the client. Therefore, incorporating this model into the curriculum, students will gain an understanding of the ethical and legal aspects of nursing practice, which is essential for delivering quality care (Neuman, 2019). Therefore, by utilizing evidence-based nursing concepts, theories, and best practices, curriculum developers can ensure that their curriculum is based on the latest evidence and best practices, and that it meets the needs of students and faculty.
Determine the proper accreditation agency for a chosen curriculum and specify the accreditation evaluation criteria.
The Commission on Collegiate Nursing Education (CCNE) is the accrediting body for baccalaureate, graduate, and residency nursing education programs. As the nursing profession has grown and become more complex, CCNE has responded by implementing standards and criteria that ensure the quality and integrity of nursing education programs. CCNE accreditation is based on a comprehensive review of a nursing program’s organizational structure and governance, core faculty credentials and experience, curriculum design, learning environment, and evidence of student achievement. Organizational structure and governance are evaluated by CCNE to ensure that the program’s mission and objectives are being met. The program has an effective governing body and administrative structure that provide oversight and promote the program’s mission. Its structure also provides for effective communication within the program, between faculty and students, and with external stakeholders. Core faculty credentials and experience are also reviewed by CCNE to ensure that the program is staffed with qualified and experienced individuals. Faculty should have appropriate academic credentials, clinical experience, and expertise in the program’s specialty areas. The curriculum of a nursing program must also meet CCNE standards. The curriculum must be designed to prepare graduates to meet the needs of the healthcare system. It should include an appropriate balance of theory, clinical practice, and evidence-based research and practice. The learning environment of a nursing program must be conducive to student learning and success. The learning environment should include a supportive faculty, adequate resources, and active engagement of the students. Finally, evidence of student achievement of program outcomes must be provided. The program must have a plan for assessing and evaluating its own performance, and must report its outcomes to the public. It must also have a plan for tracking and measuring the performance of its graduates. Therefore, accreditation by CCNE provides assurance that a nursing program meets quality standards and prepares graduates to enter the healthcare system with the knowledge and skills necessary to provide safe and effective care. The standards and criteria of CCNE are regularly reviewed and revised to ensure that they remain current and meet the needs of the nursing profession.
Conclusion
In conclusion, curriculum evaluation is an important process for nurses, educators, and healthcare providers. It not only ensures that the curriculum is up-to-date and meeting the needs of the students and the educational institution, but also that the curriculum is meeting the needs of the other stakeholders. When evaluating a curriculum, it is important to consider criteria such as content, Learning objectives, educational methods, and evaluation methods. Additionally, pilot testing can be used to identify and address any potential issues before the curriculum is fully implemented. Pilot testing can be used to identify any problems or modifications needed for the program prior to implementation and to estimate the amount of resources needed for the full-scale implementation. Additionally, both short-term and long-term evaluations are necessary to ensure that the curriculum is meeting its objectives and providing the best outcomes. Both short-term and long-term curriculum evaluations are necessary for process improvement. Short-term evaluations provide important feedback on how the curriculum is performing in the short-term and can help identify areas of improvement and make changes to the curriculum. Long-term evaluations are used to assess the effectiveness and relevance of a curriculum over a longer period of time and can provide insight into how the curriculum is performing over time. Furthermore, Short-term evaluations allow for the implementation of quick fixes and adjustments to a curriculum that can have a direct and immediate impact on the effectiveness of the curriculum Evidence-based nursing concepts, theories, and best practices should also be applied to ensure that the curriculum is up-to-date and relevant. Finally, the appropriate accreditation body and evaluation criteria should be identified to ensure adherence to quality standards. Accreditation by CCNE provides assurance that a nursing program meets quality standards and prepares graduates to enter the healthcare system with the knowledge and skills necessary to provide safe and effective care Through ongoing curriculum evaluation, nurses, educators, and healthcare providers can ensure that the curriculum is providing the best outcomes for all stakeholders.
References
Button, L. J. (n.d.). Factors That Influence Curriculum and curriculum evaluation – Curriculum essentials: A journey. PressbooksOER – An OER Creation Platform for Individual Faculty Authors and Small-Enrollment Institutions. https://oer.pressbooks.pub/curriculumessentials/chapter/chapter-factors-that-influence-curriculum-and-curriculum-evaluation/
Neuman, B. (2019, June 6). Neuman’s systems model. Nursing Theory. https://nursing-theory.org/theories-and-models/neuman-systems-model.php
Diem, K. (2019, October 16). Pilot testing 4-H curriculum. : Rutgers New Jersey 4-H. https://nj4h.rutgers.edu/pubs/pilottesting.asp
Kelly, S. (2020, December 31). Short term evaluation vs long term evaluation. Ephlux – Connected Customer Experience | JD Edwards | Internet of Things | Machine Learning | Industry 4.0. https://www.ephlux.com/short-term-vs-long-term-eval/
Bisoux, T. (2021, June 21). Best practices in curriculum design. Global Business Education Network | AACSB. https://www.aacsb.edu/insights/articles/2011/09/best-practices-in-curriculum-design
Edx. (2022, September 16). Nursing school accreditation. CORP-MSN0 (NLM). https://nursinglicensemap.com/nursing-degrees/nursing-accreditation/
write